Stanley D. Berger B.C.L.,L.L.B, Certified Specialist
Environmental Law (Mr. Berger was in-house counsel to the
proponent, Ontario Power Generation Inc.(OPG), during the public
hearing of the EA)
On May 14, 2014, the Federal Court of Canada in a 213 page
decision in Greenpeace Canada et al. v Canada et al),
returned the environmental assessment (EA) of the Darlington
Nuclear New Build Project to "a duly constituted Joint Review
Panel" for further consideration and determination. The EA
Report was not set aside in its entirety, but until such time as
the Panel completed its reconsideration, the Canadian Nuclear
Safety Commission (CNSC), the Department of Fisheries and Oceans
and Transport Canada had no jurisdiction to issue any
authorizations or licences, which would enable the Project to
proceed in whole or in part. The reasons for judgment, though based
on a federal environmental assessment law which has since been
amended in some significant respects, continue to be