The Canadian
Bar Association (CBA) has been engaged in a fierce
internal debate over the Association's decision, now revoked,
to intervene in Chevron's appeal to the Supreme Court. The Ecuadorian
plaintiffs in the case are seeking to enforce a $9.5 billion
judgment obtained in Ecuador for terrible oil pollution and health
damages allegedly caused by Texaco and others. Chevron (the
corporate successor of Texaco) has no direct assets in Canada, but
does have an indirect Canadian subsidiary with substantial assets.
Chevron has obtained a US court decision that the Ecuador judgment
was obtained by fraud, and argues that it cannot and should not be
enforced in Canada.
The CBA originally decided to intervene to support a traditional
pillar of Canadian corporate law: that, for most purposes (barring
fraud), each corporation is a separate legal person, liable for its
own obligations but not for those of their parent and subsidiary
companies. This provoked a furious debate.