Crosslink Bridge Corp. (Crosslink) purchased contaminated land
from CN Railway
(CN) in 2008 to develop a tourism, entertainment, retail and sports
venue in the Niagara region. Crosslink received a box of
environmental reports, including the Certificate of Requirement
(also registered on title) that revealed the existence of a Ministry of the Environment Director's
order relating to a risk assessment of the contamination. It was
not clear, however, whether Crosslink had actually received the
order. Could they void the transaction five years later, in the
first case ever decided under s. 197 of the Environmental Protection Act?
Crosslink tried to void the transaction in late 2012, after an
attempt to sell the land failed because of the contamination.
Crosslink claimed $5.913 million from CN for the costs of
purchasing, carrying, maintaining and developing the property, on
the basis that it had not been provided with a copy of the
Director's Order. The Court rejected