Two decisions addressing offset well obligations pertaining to
leased lands in Saskatchewan were recently released: Canadian
Natural Resources Limited v Lisafeld Royalties Ltd. and
Whitecap Resources Inc. v Canadian Natural Resources
Limited. These decisions are significant given their
interpretation of offset well clauses in light of horizontal
drilling operations that were not contemplated when the lease was
entered into.
Canadian Natural Resources Limited v Lisafeld Royalties
Ltd. (2019 SKQB 201) (Lisafeld)
Overview
On August 21, 2019, the Saskatchewan Court of Queen's Bench
ruled on a dispute regarding Canadian Natural Resources
Limited's (CNRL) obligations under a lease
that was originally granted in 1949 (the 1949
Lease). It should be noted that given the age of this
lease, it employed an earlier version of the offset well clause
than in Whitecap Resources (discussed below). Unlike in
Whitecap Resources, there was no "drill, drop or
pay" obligation;