We recently reported on the decision in Probuild
Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd
[2018] HCA 4. There, the High Court held that Australian security
of payment legislation did not allow adjudicators' decisions to
be challenged for:
- misinterpreting contracts;
- or misinterpreting the law.
The High Court did, however, reaffirm the position that State
Supreme Courts around Australia had been taking, that adjudications
could be challenged based on "jurisdictional errors".
This raises the question: what is a jurisdictional error?
Justice Pritchard of the WA Supreme Court sheds light on this
question in Total Eden Pty Ltd v Charteris [2018] WASC
60.
Her Honour reminds us that a jurisdictional error is basically a
mistake about the nature and limits of an adjudicator's role
under security of payment laws. So, for example, as Justice Chaney
had said in Delmere Holdings v Green [2015] WASC 148,
adjudicators are constrained by the contract in