In most commercial leases that contain an option to renew, there
is a condition which states that the Tenant may only exercise the
option if they are not in default of the terms of the lease. This
condition may be limited to not being in default at the time of
exercise or it may be a more onerous condition stating that the
Tenant must not have been in default at any time during the
term.
The question is, are such provisions effective in preventing a
defaulting Tenant from exercising the option to renew? The answer
is not so easy!
Prior to the introduction of Part 8 Division 4 of the
Conveyancing Act 1919 (Act), conditions such as
these were interpreted strictly and any breach by the Tenant would
preclude the exercise of the option. However, following the
introduction of Part 8 Division 4, the Court now has discretion to
allow a Tenant to exercise an option to renew despite the fact that
there may have been defaults during the term or even subsisting
defaults at