In NSW, to be eligible for compensation for a compulsory
acquisition, you must be able to point to an interest in the
acquired land which is divested, extinguished, or diminished. But
what qualifies as an interest? In a recent judgment, the NSW Court
of Appeal held that a bare licence, especially one which is
undocumented, does not meet the threshold of an "interest in
land" and as such, is not compensable.
The facts and issue presented
Antonino and Carmel Gaudioso owned a property in Camperdown and
were the sole directors and shareholders of a company, Olde English
Tiles Australia Pty Ltd (Olde English). They
operated Olde English on their Camperdown property but did not have
a formal written lease or any other written agreement in place to
document this arrangement, relying on an implied licence to occupy.
When the property was subsequently acquired by Transport for NSW,
the Gaudiosos alleged that they were entitled to compensation, but
not only for themselves in