In this week's TGIF we examine the question: when
can a mortgagee claim a right to retain reasonable security for
costs of anticipated litigation with a mortgagor?
In
A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd v Manassen Holdings Pty
Ltd [2024] NSWSC 178, Richmond J held that a
mortgagee could retain surplus funds from the sale of secured
assets as security for a contingent liability, namely reasonable
costs to be incurred by the mortgagee in the event of an
anticipated dispute with the mortgagor, provided the terms of the
mortgage define potential enforcement costs as a secured
liability.
The decision turned on the finance documents and general law.
While 'Secured Moneys' within the mortgage was not defined
with precision, it did cover the borrowers' contingent
liability to indemnify the Defendant (Manassen) for costs incurred
defending reasonably anticipated claims by the borrowers.