Executive Summary
The Land Court of Queensland (Court) has recommended that mining leases and an environmental authority be granted to Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd (Whitehaven) for its Winchester South open-cut coal mine (Project) despite environmental objections in the recent decision of Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd v Australian Conservation Foundation Inc & Ors (No 4) [2026] QLC 24.
The Court accepted evidence that 557 million tonnes of emissions projected to arise from the Project would be “a massive amount”. However, as one of likely thousands of similarly impactful projects worldwide, the Project was held not to cause, although it would contribute to, the degradation of the entire Queensland environment. Climate considerations did not overwhelm or extinguish the other factors to be considered in the Court’s assessment.