It probably seemed like a great idea at the time; making
sure only happy customers received the email inviting them to give
Meriton a TripAdvisor review. But the ACCC and the Federal Court
said - hmm not so much.
Meriton has been hit with a $3M penalty for false
representations based on conduct with its TripAdvisor reviews.
So how did the Court get to $3M? It was a lot less than the $20
million that the ACCC asked for, but a lot more than the $330,000
to $440,000 that Meriton suggested.
For a company, the Court is limited to a maximum penalty of
$1.1M per contravention. 'Per contravention' is the key
part here, as the number of contraventions was hotly contested. The
ACCC was arguing one contravention per email address masked, or
group of emails withheld (in the thousands). Meriton argued it was
one contravention for each of the two relevant sections breached.
The judge ultimately found 13 contraventions, one for each
property. This meant a maximum penalty of