• Rankings
    • Jurisdictions

    • Submissions

    • Research+

    • Green Guide

    • Future Lawyers

  • Firms & Lawyers
    • Service Providers

    • Barristers’ Sets

    • Networks

    • Hall of Fame

    • Interview with…

  • In-House
    • In-House Lawyer

    • GC Powerlist

    • GC Magazine

  • Knowledge Centre
    • Data Products

    • Legal Business

    • News & Developments

    • Special Reports

    • About us
      • Legal 500

      • FAQs

      • Newsletters

      • Contact us

  • Comparative Guides

  • Events

  • Legal 500 TV

About us
  • Legal 500

  • FAQs

  • Newsletters

  • Contact us

  • Deutschland DE

  • Paris FR

  • homehome
  • RankingsRankings
  • SingaporeSingapore
LVM Law Chambers LLC logo

LVM Law Chambers LLC

  • lvmlawchambers.com
Show options
  • Rankings
  • Lawyers
  • News and developments
  • Teams
  • Contact

News and developments

Contracts

Commentary: Court Of Appeal Strikes Down “Clever Drafting” Designed To Circumvent The Penalty Doctrine: A Case Of Too Clever By Half?

In 2020, the Court of Appeal (the “CA”) reiterated that the penalty doctrine is restricted in its application to secondary obligations; primary obligations are insulated from the doctrine: Leiman, Ricardo and another v Noble Resources Ltd and another [2020] 2 SLR 386. It described this restriction as the “threshold issue.” The rationale for this differential treatment was explained by the UK Supreme Court in Cavendish Square Holding BV v Makdessi [2016] AC 1172 (“Cavendish”) in the following terms (at [13]): “There is a fundamental difference between a jurisdiction to review the fairness of a contractual obligation and a jurisdiction to regulate the remedy for its breach. Leaving aside challenges going to the reality of consent, such as those based on fraud, duress or undue influence, the courts do not review the fairness of men’s bargains either at law or in equity. The penalty rule regulates only the remedies available for breach of a party’s primary obligations, not the primary obligations themselves.”
21 February 2023
LVM Law Chambers LLC
  • Rankings
    • Jurisdictions

    • Submissions

    • Research+

    • Green Guide

    • Future Lawyers

  • Firms & Lawyers
    • Service Providers

    • Barristers’ Sets

    • Networks

    • Hall of Fame

    • Interview with…

  • In-House
    • In-House Lawyer

    • GC Powerlist

    • GC Magazine

  • Knowledge Centre
    • Data Products

    • Legal Business

    • News & Developments

    • Special Reports

    • About us
      • Legal 500

      • FAQs

      • Newsletters

      • Contact us

  • Comparative Guides

  • Events

  • Legal 500 TV

About us
  • Legal 500

  • FAQs

  • Newsletters

  • Contact us

  • Deutschland DE

  • Paris FR

© 2025 Legalease Ltd. All rights reserved

Registered company in England & Wales No. 02427356 VAT GB 321 5727 22

Registered address: 188 Fleet Street, London, EC4A 2AG

  • Data Protection policies
  • Cookies Policy
  • Contact Us