The 'client focused, responsive and hardworking' multidisciplinary team at Blake Morgan LLP effectively draws from the expertise of lawyers with core public sector expertise from across several key practice groups, including employment, social housing and commercial. In addition, unlike some of the ranked firms, it has a core focus on public law and, in particular, in-depth expertise on Welsh devolved law in areas including healthcare. In this context, the instructions are not purely restricted to Wales-based entities but also often to English clients seeking guidance as to the interaction with Welsh law. The 'outstanding' Eve Piffaretti heads up the overarching group and provides 'balanced and thorough' public law advice as it pertains to health and social care, including on safeguarding issues, mental health and mental capacity law. Graham Miles ' professional regulatory expertise also regularly seems him involved in the health and social care setting, particularly in the context of advising regulatory bodies investigating and presenting fitness to cases involving practitioners in the space. Miles also has niche prowess in relation to fertility law and genetics and continues to represent the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, including in relation to the defence of judicial review challenges. The team is also noted for its ability to provide 'high quality advice on the most complex of public sector procurements'. In this setting Penri Desscan and Simon McCann regularly take the lead on the non-contentious front, while Joanne Thompson handles public procurement litigation, both for public sector organisations as well as for failed bidders. At an associate level, Sarah Whittle is particularly skilled at defending public sector health care entities against judicial review challenges, and Emily James has a flourishing state aid practice.
Public sector in Wales
Blake Morgan LLP
Practice head(s):
Other key lawyers:
Penri Desscan ; Simon McCann ; Siân Jones ; Paula Kathrens ; Graham Miles ; Claire Rawle ; Louise Howells; Lee Fisher; Joanne Thompson; Sarah Whittle; Joanna Corbett-Simmons; Tom Walker; Delme Griffiths ; Tomos Lewis ; Emily James ; Tanya Barrett; Kate Howell
Testimonials
‘All of the lawyers are very client focused, responsive and hardworking.’
‘Eve Piffaretti and her team have provided my Local Authority with legal support for Education and Court of Protection work during the pandemic. They have a wealth of experience of both sides of the fence which is evident in the legal advice they provide, as it is always balanced, thorough and first class.’
‘The team of experts are able to advise and provide high quality advice on the most complex of public sector procurements.’
‘Eve Piffaretti has been outstanding in her communication at all times and her people skills have made the client department and indeed myself feel at ease and as if nothing is too much trouble.’
Key clients
Welsh Government & The Welsh Ministers
NHS Wales Shared Services Partnership
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority
NHS England & NHS Improvement
Natural Resources Wales
Transport for Wales
Welsh Language Commissioner
Senedd Cymru/ Welsh Parliament
Children’s Commissioner for Wales
Equality and Human Rights Commission (in Wales)
Older People’s Commissioner for Wales
Social Care Wales
Education Workforce Council
Development Bank for Wales
South Wales Fire and Rescue Service
Police and Crime Commissioner for Gwent
Clwyd Alyn Housing Association
Pobl Housing Association
Cardiff and Vale College
Health Care Professions Council
Work highlights
- Provided the Welsh Government with a broad range of legal support across a range of legal specialisms including advice on IT infrastructure and Welsh Government’s response to the coronavirus pandemic.
- Providing legal support to NHS England and NHS Improvement throughout the pandemic.
- Acting for a wide range of public sector clients including regulators such as Social Care Wales, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority and the Human Tissue Authority.
Geldards LLP
Benefiting from 'incredible strength in depth' in the public sector (which is reflected by its strong showing in the various NPS lots), Geldards LLP provides 'excellent quality' work to a broad cross-section of clients including local authorities, central government, and regulatory bodies. As well as being able to draw upon the strength of lawyers with public sector expertise from across the firm's full-service offering, the firm is also noted for its pure public law knowledge with a real understanding of 'the law in Wales and the differences that now exist with the law of England and Wales'. Construction head Tony Norris is 'stratospherically brilliant' at advising Welsh Government on key infrastructure projects, as well as in any arbitrations which should subsequently arise. 'Exceptionally well-organised and calm' litigator Jonathan Griffiths is particularly effective at handling judicial review matters for claimants and defendants, as well as in procurement-related cases. Recognised as a 'keen tactician', Charles Felgate has a particular focus on public sector panning matters and regularly represents local authorities 'when they hit a brick wall in their toughest cases'. As part of her core public sector employment expertise, Helen Snow 'is outstanding in her knowledge and experience' within the agricultural space and continues to advise The Agricultural Advisory Panel for Wales on aspects relating to agricultural workers.
Other key lawyers:
Charles Felgate ; Tony Norris; Jonathan Griffiths; Helen Snow
Testimonials
‘The team has incredible strength and breadth in advising the public sector. They understand law in Wales and the differences that now exist with the law of England and Wales.’
‘Their work is tailored to us, always of excellent quality and always delivered swiftly.’
‘Charles Felgate is a highly experienced adviser on planning matters in Wales – local planning authorities turn to him regularly when they hit a brick wall in their toughest cases. He is a keen tactician and active litigator.’
‘Jonathan Griffiths is exceptionally well-organised and calm.’
‘Tony Norris is stratospherically brilliant.’
‘Helen Snow is extremely efficient, responsive and is an expert in her field. She understands the mechanisms of policy development and Government processes and she is outstanding in her knowledge and experience.’
Key clients
Senedd Commission
Snowdonia National Park Authority
South Derbyshire District Council
The Welsh Ministers
Development Bank of Wales plc
The Natural Resources Body for Wales (Natural Resources Wales)
The Agricultural Advisory Panel for Wales
Blaenau Gwent County Borough Council
Estyn (the education and training inspectorate for Wales)
Torfaen County Borough Council
Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority
Gwynedd Council
Bridgend County Borough Council
National Museum of Wales
Vale of Glamorgan Council
The Agricultural Advisory Panel for Wales
Caerphilly County Borough Council
Carmarthenshire County Council
Work highlights
- Advising Snowdonia National Park Authority on the Hillside Parks Ltd v Snowdonia National Park Authority [2020] EWCA Civ 1440 planning dispute, in the High Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court.
- Representing the Welsh Ministers in the defence in the High Court of an application for a declaration in relation to a Development Consent Order for the proposed Swansea Bay Tidal Lagoon.
- Advising a local authority on the restructure of its senior leadership team.
Capital Law Limited
The ‘extremely cohesive, efficient and well organised’ multidisciplinary team at Capital Law Limited is ‘fantastically knowledgeable‘ in the space, as was recently underscored by its impressive showing across a multitude of lots on the NPS. The undoubted ‘star player‘, however, remains team head Nicola Mead-Batten who has ‘the right blend of technical expertise and client facing skills’ and is according to one client: ‘probably the best public law solicitor in England and Wales at the moment’. This expertise manifests itself in a range of ways, including in relation to freedom of information requests and judicial review matters. ‘Extremely efficient and organised‘ senior associate Trish D’Souza is also a key member of the team, particularly as a result of her ‘excellent knowledge of higher education in the public sector’.
Practice head(s):
Other key lawyers:
Testimonials
‘The team is fantastically knowledgeable and wise as a result of experience on both sides of the fence.’
‘The team is extremely cohesive, efficient and well organised.’
‘Nicola Mead-Batten is the star player and has a real depth of knowledge of medical regulatory judicial reviews.’
‘Nicola Mead-Batten is a strategic three-dimensional thinker with an eye for hidden issues others might miss.’
‘Nicola Mead-Batten is probably the best public law solicitor in England and Wales at the moment, in terms of having the right blend of technical expertise and client facing skills.’
‘Trish D’Souza is extremely efficient and organised, inspiring confidence in clients.’
Key clients
Welsh Government
Gambling Commission
UK Anti-Doping
Rhondda Cynon Taf County Borough Council
Development Bank of Wales
Bridgend College
Future Generations Commissioner
Welsh Language Commissioner
University of South Wales
Bridgend County Borough Council
Caerphilly County Borough Council
Solicitors Regulation Authority
British Medical Association
Natural Resources Wales
Qualifications Wales
Estyn
Transport For Wales
Work highlights
- Reappointed as adviser to the Solicitors Regulation Authority across a wide range of legal, policy and regulatory matters for the General Counsel team.
- Acting for the British Medical Association (BMA) in its public law challenge to the government’s changes to public service pension schemes, including the NHS Pension Scheme.
- Representing the BMA and five test claimant GP practices in their High Court claim against NHSPS in challenging the basis of these demanded service charges.
Hugh James
Public sector-related work has been pivotal to Hugh James‘ strategy since its formation over 25 years ago and it has consequently gained an excellent insight into the requirements of a myriad central/local authorities, as well as third sector entities. This expertise was recently underscored by the firm’s strong showing across the various NPS lots, including gaining a coveted spot as one of the firm’s specifically acting for the Welsh Government. Ioan Prydderch and Martin Jones co-head the multidisciplinary team which includes senior associate Justin Davies, who has a market-leading reputation advising on fire safety law and continues to represent South Wales Fire & Rescue Service on enforcement matters.
Practice head(s):
Other key lawyers:
Key clients
Social Care Wales
Welsh Government
Natural Resources Wales
Denbighshire County Council
The City of Cardiff County Council
Blaenau Gwent County Borough Council
Torfaen County Borough Council
Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency (DVSA)
Coleg Gwent
Cardiff University
Swansea City Council
Gwynedd Council
Flintshire Council
Monmouthshire County Council
Transport for Wales
Independent Office for Police Conduct
Welsh Language Commissioner
Conwy County Council
Pembrokeshire County Council
CAFCASS Cymru
Care Inspectorate Wales
South Wales Fire and Rescue Service
Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Service
Bridgend County Borough Council
Carmarthenshire County Council
Neath Port Talbot County Borough Council
Isle of Anglesey County Council
Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council
South Wales Police
South Wales Police and Crime Commissioner
University of South Wales
Linc Cymru Housing Association
Trivallis Housing Association
Caerphilly County Borough Council
Hafod Housing Association
Wrexham County Borough Council
Crown Estate
Natural England
Gwent Police
Dyfed Powys Police
Dwr Cymru / Welsh Water
Aneurin Bevan University Health Board
Curo Housing Association
Cardiff and Vale University Health Board
Aelwyd Housing Association
Bro Myrddin
Bron Afon Community Housing Ltd
Cadwyn Housing Association
Cardiff Community Housing
Charter Housing Association
Coastal Housing Association
Cynon Taf Community Housing Group
Derwen Cymru Ltd
Grwp Gwalia Cyfyngedig
Grwp Cyfnefin
Merthyr Tydfil Housing Association
Monmouthshire Housing Assocation
Newport City Homes
Newydd Housing Assocation
Pobl Group
Taff Housing Association
Tai Ceredigion
Untied Welsh Housing Association
Work highlights
- Advised Wrexham Borough Council on property elements of the Wrexham Gateway Project and redevelopment of racecourse stadium transferred to Wrexham AFC and supported by grant funding in the region of £25m.
- Acted for Natural Resources Wales in high-profile proceedings concerning mineral rights before the Court of Appeal in Summer 2021.
- Successfully represented the Welsh Government in an arbitration against Costain Limited in connection with cost overruns on a £340m road expansion project.
Watkins & Gunn Limited
Under the guidance of the 'exceptional' Michael Imperato , Watkins & Gunn Limited has developed a market-leading reputation acting for claimants seeking to challenge unlawful acts by public bodies. In this context, the firm is particularly accomplished at handling complex High Court judicial review challenges, an area that Imperato has 'an excellent track record of success built upon his vast experience'. Senior associate Lucy O’Brien 'has an amazing eye for detail, particularly in the most complex cases', including those involving Equality and Human Rights.
Practice head(s):
Other key lawyers:
Testimonials
‘The very professional and communicative team provides reasoned advice.’
‘They are really the leaders in public law cases in Wales. They have such a wide case range and are on top of so many issues, both locally and nationally.’
‘The public law team is the leading private sector firm in South Wales dealing with public law cases, particularly with complex High Court judicial review.’
‘It is a small and committed team with excellent client care and innovative thinking.’
‘This firm is very prominent with significant leading expertise in challenges to unlawful acts by public bodies.’
‘Michael Imperato is particularly able at conducting litigation on behalf of the his clients, often individuals who are not used to court proceedings, and at finding mechanisms for funding public interest litigation in the field of public law.’
‘Michael Imperato is a real rain maker. He is fantastic at working cases from the ground up, meeting the campaigners, working out if there is a runnable issue, getting funding in place, then liaising with counsel. He has an excellent track record of success built upon his vast experience.’
‘Lucy O’Brien has an amazing eye for detail, particularly in the most complex cases. She also knows how to be firm with difficult lay clients.’
Key clients
Haemophilia Wales
Haemophilia Northern Ireland
Busk
Elidyr Communities Trust
Hepatitis B Trust
Infected Blood Australia
Save Our Libraries (SOLE)
School & College Students Union
Travelling Ahead; Gypsy, Roma and Traveller Advice & Advocacy Service
Swansea Bay University Health Board
Ethnic Minorities and Youth Support Team Wales (EYST Wales)
Work highlights
- Acting for Haemophilia Wales on the ongoing public inquiry into the 1980s contaminated blood scandal.
- Acting for number of small rural schools in Powys challenging County Council’s closure proposal.
- Acting in several Welsh traveller cases involving planning and Human Rights.
Harding Evans LLP
At Newport-based firm Harding Evans LLP, Craig Court, who was promoted to partner in May 2021, has a thriving claimant side public law practice which is gaining particular traction in the market as a result of some high-profile work for vulnerable clients in judicial review challenges against public bodies. Notably, Court has recently been instructed to represent the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice Cymru in respect of the Covid-19 Statutory Public Inquiry.
Practice head(s):
Testimonials
‘Craig Court is excellent with clients and pursues their interests with great tenacity.’
Work highlights
- Instructed by the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice Cymru Group to represent them in respect of the Covid-19 Statutory Public Inquiry.
- Representing three claimants in a challenge to the UK Government’s introduction of the Loans for Mortgage Interest Regulations 2017 which changed the previous Support for Mortgage Interest Scheme into a repayable loan secured by way of a charge on the property.
- Acting for the Estate of the deceased (who had a history of mental illness) in a challenge to the coroner’s decision not to engage Article 2 and widen the scope of the inquest (to allow the coroner to consider the series of failings by the community mental health team) following his death by hanging.