Arnold & Porter represents pharma and medical device companies in complex litigation, including class actions, multi-district litigations (MDLs), and state-coordinated proceedings, as well as multinational disputes. The firm defends clients in product liability litigation and develops strategies to resolve entire litigation portfolios. Known for navigating complex scientific, regulatory, and technical issues, the team has secured favorable outcomes in some of the country’s most challenging jurisdictions. The practice is co-chaired by New York’s Anand Agneshwar, who represents pharma companies as national, strategic, trial, and appellate counsel; having, for example, served as co-lead counsel in Sanofi’s Zantac MDL. Anand also advises on litigation risks and the litigation and compliance impact of potential legislation. Also in New York, Arthur Brown serves as national and coordinating counsel in bet-the-company litigations. Washington DC-based Daphne O’Connor, who also co-chairs the practice, focuses on managing and trying complex scientific and medical product liability and mass tort cases. Paige Sharpe, also in DC, has extensive experience defending clients against personal injury claims in state and federal court, at both trial and appellate court levels.
Product liability, mass tort and class action - defense: pharmaceuticals and medical devices in United States
Arnold & Porter
Practice head(s):
Anand Agneshwar; Daphne O’Connor
Other key lawyers:
Paige Sharpe; Arthur Brown; William Hoffman; Jeffrey Horowitz; Daniel Pariser; Julie du Pont
DLA Piper LLP (US)
DLA Piper LLP (US)’s product liability team is a trusted defender of global pharma and medical device companies, having successfully handled numerous high-stakes disputes. It has defended or ended several mass torts through resolution, dispositive preemption, Daubert hearings, and other motions. Leveraging its cross-practice expertise, the team collaborates closely with appellate, regulatory, and life science partners. Atlanta-based Christopher Campbell, co-chair of the product liability group, leads high-profile matters such as Bayer’s global Essure litigation and its phenylephrine cough-cold MDL litigation. Ilana Hope Eisenstein, chair of US litigation based in Philadelphia, specializes in complex issues, developing and managing legal strategy. In New York, Loren Brown chairs the wider US disputes practice and leads the firm’s representation of Novo Nordisk as national trial counsel in litigation related to diabetes and obesity medications Ozempic, Wegovy, and Rybelsu. Boston-based Matthew Holian is another key figure in the practice, frequently serving as national counsel in complex, multi-jurisdictional matters. ‘Client-focused’ Katie Insogna, also in Boston, is ‘outstanding at managing the intricacies of a day-to-day high-stakes mass tort’, while New York’s Lucas Przymusinski leverages his medical background to drive legal strategy. Meanwhile, Steve Huffaker, who joined the Austin office from King & Spalding LLP in September 2024, focuses on mass tort coordination and strategy, early case resolution, group settlements, litigation risk strategy, and fact and expert witness development and discovery.
Practice head(s):
Christopher Campbell; Ilana Hope Eisenstein; Loren Brown
Other key lawyers:
Matthew Holian; Katie Insogna; Lucas Przymusinski; Mary Gately; Jessica Wilson; Steve Huffaker
Testimonials
‘In my experience, one of the best practices I have worked with in over 2 decades of experience – the level of responsiveness, breadth of expertise, industry and technical knowledge, and pragmatic approach is unmatched.’
‘DLA Piper LLP (US) is doing a fantastic job in global strategy for cross-country litigation.’
‘The team focuses on the client’s expectations and preferences. Their strengths are strategy, providing concrete legal advice, coordination skills, and reliability to get things done. They integrate/cooperate well with legal teams from other law firms to achieve the overall goal rather than being competitive.’
‘The team is very responsive and thorough. They quickly understand the issues. The advice is practical and proportionate to the risk.’
‘I would particularly like to stress the work that Chris Campbell is doing. He gives precise advice as required, he always thinks in the best interest of his clients and always thinks ahead. He will think through the most complex issues very fast, taking all relevant facts into consideration. This always leads to the best advice. Mary Gately is fantastic in analyzing complex medical issues and their impact on the litigation strategy.’
‘Loren Brown has tremendous credibility with Judges and opposing counsel. He is terrific at managing a mass tort. Lucas Przymusinski is an MD/JD who leverages his medical background to drive medical/legal strategy. Katie Insogna is client-focused and does an outstanding job of managing all the intricacies of a day-to-day high-stakes mass tort.’
‘Lucas Przymusinski, Katie Insogna and Ray Lewis have exceptional responsiveness, a pragmatic approach, and breadth of knowledge of industry combined with medical expertise, yet are all humble and approachable.’
‘Lucas Przymusinski very quickly understands the science so he can provide an important risk perspective. I’m continually impressed by the speed and rigor with which he does his analysis.’
Key clients
3M Company, The
BASF Corporation
Novo Nordisk A/S
Bayer Corporation
Danone
Exxon Mobil Corporation
Medtronic, Inc.
Pfizer
Sanofi
Johnson & Johnson
Work highlights
- Representing Novo Nordisk regarding litigation and regulatory issues related to its diabetes and obesity medications Ozempic, Wegovy, and Rybelsus.
- Representing Sanofi for litigation and regulatory issues relating to Zantac, a common heartburn medication that allegedly contains and/or is contaminated with NDMA, a possible carcinogen.
- Representing Bayer in proceedings relating to Essure, a permanently implantable contraceptive device for women that Bayer voluntarily discontinued in 2018.
Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP
Litigation boutique Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP handles major product liability, mass tort, class action, antitrust, intellectual property, and other high-stakes cases for leading pharma and medical device companies. Its lawyers are recognized not only for their experience in trying complex litigation cases but also for their deep scientific and technical expertise. The practice is led by Chicago-based Tarek Ismail, who has extensive experience as lead trial counsel in a variety of high-profile matters, including bet-the-company cases. Dallas-based Joe Tomaselli serves as national counsel for Merck in the product liability MDL regarding the Gardasil HPV vaccine; Chicago-based Shayna Cook, Rami Fakhouri, and Emma Ross are also key figures in the matter. Santa Monica’s Ken Baum leads the firm’s representation of Eli Lilly as lead science counsel in litigation concerning its GLP-1 dulaglutide and tirzepatide products. ‘Collaborative and client-focused’ Jennifer Greenblatt, based in Dallas, and Chicago’s Brian O’Donoghue are recognized for their creativity in developing trial strategies. Joining the Chicago team from Mayer Brown, Craig Woods has extensive experience organizing multidisciplinary expert teams, defending against expert testimony admissibility challenges under Daubert and Frye standards, and translating complex medical and scientific concepts into compelling litigation strategies.
Practice head(s):
Tarek Ismail
Other key lawyers:
Ken Baum; Shayna Cook; Joe Tomaselli; Brian O’Donoghue; Jennifer Greenblatt; Rami Fakhouri; Emma Ross; Craig Woods
Testimonials
‘Goldman Ismail has the unique ability to combine unparalleled knowledge of medical and scientific issues (they have multiple lawyers who are also medical doctors) with the ability to communicate those issues effectively to judges and juries. They work up a case, strategically deploy Rule 702 and summary judgment motions, and prepare cases for trial as well as or better than any other firm in the country.’
‘The individuals that stand out most are trial lawyers Tarek Ismail, Shanya Cook, and Emma Ross, as well as some of the top expert witness development lawyers in the country, Joe Tomaselli and Ken Baum. Brian O’Donaghue is also a consummate strategist, leading some of the largest and most important litigations in the country. They combine intelligence, talent, unrelenting work ethic, and a decency that makes them a pleasure to work with.’
‘The group is full of brilliant, experienced attorneys. There is not a firm I have encountered in my 15 years of practice that comes close to their depth of talent.’
‘Emma Ross is the smartest science mind in the defense bar for product liability litigation. Shayna Cook is a dynamite, first-chair trial lawyer who connects with jurors with ease. Tarek Ismail is a fabulous trial lawyer as well who has “seen it all.”’
‘The team brings a client-focused and results-driven focus to each case, thinking creatively about the best and most efficient path towards success. Notwithstanding the relatively small size of the team, they never overextend and constantly make each matter a priority.’
‘Tarek Ismail is one of the finest trial attorneys I’ve seen. He is nimble as the trial evolves in real time. Jen Greenblatt is incredibly collaborative and client-focused. When working with her as co-counsel, there is never any matter of egos, as the client’s objectives are all that matter. She is exceptionally bright, creative, and knows how to put together a trial narrative. Emma Ross is one of the most intelligent people I have ever met, and she somehow retains her ability to clearly convey complex scientific and medical principles to the jury. All three individuals are warm, friendly, and easy to work with.’
‘Goldman Ismail is a unique practice because they are like the Special Forces of Product Liability law firms.’
‘Up and down, left and right the group is just full of brilliant, experienced attorneys.’
Key clients
Merck & Co., Inc.
Merck Sharp & Dohme LLC
Bayer HealthCare Pharmaceuticals Inc.
Bayer HealthCare LLC
Bayer Corp.
Bayer AG
Monsanto Company
Gilead Sciences, Inc.
Johnson & Johnson and Ethicon, Inc.
GlaxoSmithKline
AbbVie Inc.
Dow Chemical Company
Union Carbide Company
Medtronic, Inc.
Medtronic MiniMed, Inc.
Eli Lilly and Company
Work highlights
- Lead counsel and trial counsel to GSK in products-liability cases in Illinois where plaintiffs claim its Zantac over-the-counter heartburn medication causes cancer.
- Lead national counsel in all U.S.-based products-liability litigation relating to Merck’s Gardasil vaccine, which protects against human papillomavirus (HPV) infection and cervical cancer, as well as other types of cancer caused by HPV infection.
Greenberg Traurig LLP
Greenberg Traurig LLP’s ‘thorough’ and highly skilled team is regularly called upon to serve as national, regional, special trial, or science counsel in mass torts, MDLs, class actions and individual cases for leading pharma manufacturers and medical device companies. The team has handled significant and complex litigation in areas including the opioids crisis, Zantac, and pelvic and hernia mesh cases. Atlanta-based Lori Cohen is widely recognized for her trial expertise in defending pharma and medical device companies in high-stakes litigation. Also in Atlanta, Sara Thompson and Victoria Lockard craft and execute sophisticated legal strategies to resolve complex litigation, having represented Teva Pharmaceuticals in MDLs involving generic ranitidine (Zantac) and valsartan, respectively. Gregory Ostfeld, in Chicago, is a first-chair trial and appellate attorney with experience handling large product claims and class actions, while Austin Evans, who splits his time between Denver, Atlanta, and Philadelphia, joined the team from King & Spalding LLP.
Practice head(s):
Lori Cohen; Sara Thompson; Gregory Ostfeld
Other key lawyers:
Austin Evans; Will Wagner; Victoria Lockard
Testimonials
‘The best trial team in the business.’
‘They are thorough, tough and if you have a complicated or mass tort matter, this is the team to go with.’
Key clients
Albertsons Companies, Inc.
Bausch Health Companies, Inc.
Lockheed Martin Corporation
Medtronic, Inc.
Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation
Qualcomm Incorporated
Sandoz
Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.
GE Healthcare
Eli Lilly and Company
Senseonics
International Medical Devices
Smith + Nephew
Boehringer Ingelheim
Bracco Diagnostics / ACIST Medical Systems
Himmel Management Co. LLC
Teleflex
UCB
Becton, Dickinson and Company (“BD”); C. R. Bard, Inc.
Bird Global, Inc. (f/k/a Bird Rides, Inc.)
Alcon Vision LLC
Univar Inc.
Red Bull North America
Sterigenics U.S., LLC; Sotera Health
Berkley Life Sciences, LLC
Advantage Logistics Midwest, Inc.
DevaConcepts LLC/DevaCurl
Target Corporation
aap Implantate AG
Coty, Inc.
Artivion (f/k/a CryoLife)
Danaher Corp.
W. L. Gore & Associates, Inc.
B. Braun Interventional Systems, Inc.
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Johnson & Johnson / Janssen
Kimberly-Clark Corporation
The Colgate-Palmolive Company
Bausch + Lomb Corporation
Work highlights
- Acting as national counsel and trial counsel for product liability litigation for Medtronic Inc. arising from its business units, including its implantable cardiovascular devices (ICDs).
- Acting as national counsel for Sandoz in litigation related to the chemotherapy drug Taxotere (docetaxel), including the 11,000+ case MDL involving allegations of permanent hair loss, a new secondary MDL alleging eye injuries, a New Jersey multicounty litigation, and an action by the Mississippi Attorney General.
- Representing a consortium of contract manufacturers of over-the-counter cold medicines and seven retail pharmacies that sold store-brand over-the-counter medications containing phenylephrine in the MDL regarding sales and marketing practices in the Eastern District of New York.
Kirkland & Ellis LLP
Renowned for its excellence in trial work, Kirkland & Ellis LLP has vast experience handling bet-the-company litigation for generic pharmaceutical and manufacturing companies involving complex technical and scientific issues. The practice serves as primary counsel on a wide range of product liability and mass tort matters, including multi-district litigations, class actions, defect/recall investigations, and appeals. Mike Brock is a seasoned litigator based in Washington DC specializing in representing pharma and life sciences companies in product liability and mass torts. In Chicago, trial lawyer Donna Welch spearheads the firm’s representation of Gilead in multiple matters regarding its Covid-19 antiviral drug Veklury – including product liability action related to alleged manufacturing negligence and class action regarding its marketing and promotion. The team saw significant expansion in January 2025 with the addition of Allison Brown, Jessica Davidson, Geoffrey Wyatt, Nina Rose, and Christopher Cox from Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP. Kim Bueno joined the team in May 2025 from King & Spalding LLP.
Other key lawyers:
Mike Brock; Donna Welch; Allison Brown; Jessica Davidson; Geoffrey Wyatt; Nina Rose; Christopher Cox
Key clients
AbbVie
Allergan
Crown Laboratories
Eagle Pharmaceuticals
Eli Lilly and Company
Gilead Sciences
GlaxoSmithKline
Haleon
Kenvue
Ranbaxy Pharmaceuticals
Syngenta
Torrent Pharmaceuticals
TPG Capital
Work highlights
Williams & Connolly LLP
Leveraging its trial expertise, Williams & Connolly LLP consistently secures favorable settlements for major pharmaceutical companies, device manufacturers, and medical distributors in product liability litigation. The firm’s broad practice encompasses all aspects of legal strategy, also serving as national strategic, resolution, and appellate counsel. Practice co-chair Joseph Petrosinelli, a seasoned trial lawyer with experience in civil and criminal cases across federal and state courts, plays a key role in representing clients in national and international litigations; this includes serving as co-lead and coordinating counsel for defendants in Pfizer’s Zantac multi-district litigation (MDL). Heidi Hubbard and Neelum Wadhwani have significant experience trying cases in state and federal courts, serving as lead trial counsel in multiple MDLs. Experienced in managing MDLs and coordinating proceedings in state courts, Paul Boehm currently serves as trial strategy and motions counsel for Merck in litigation concerning the Zostavax vaccination. All lawyers mentioned are based in Washington DC.
Practice head(s):
Heidi Hubbard; Joseph Petrosinelli
Other key lawyers:
Paul Boehm; Neelum Wadhwani
Key clients
Pfizer Inc.
Hospira
AstraZeneca
Merck, Sharp & Dohme Corp.
Beckman Coulter
Cardinal Health
Work highlights
- Secured a series of victories on behalf of Pfizer in the products liability litigation concerning the antacid medication Zantac.
- Represented Hospira in an MDL in the Eastern District of Louisiana, with plaintiffs alleging they were inadequately warned about the alleged risk of permanent hair loss associated with the chemotherapy medicine Docetaxel.
- Represented AstraZeneca in products liability litigation (MDL and coordinated state proceedings) alleging that a class of gastric acid reduction medicines, including Nexium, purportedly causes kidney injuries.
Bowman and Brooke LLP
Product liability boutique Bowman and Brooke LLP represents pharma and medical device clients in individual and mass tort actions, with ongoing involvement in several multi-district litigations in federal courts and state-coordinated proceedings. The practice is led by Minneapolis-based Kim Schmid, a seasoned trial attorney who has tried multiple cases in both state and federal courts, including bellwether cases in medical device mass torts, and Texas-based first chair trial lawyer Randall Christian, who led the firm’s representation of Daiichi Sankyo as national counsel in the Injectafer litigation. Chris Carton, in the New York, New Brunswick, Philadelphia and Baltimore offices, serves as lead trial and national coordinating counsel for Patheon Manufacturing Services in the federal Zantac MDL. The team recently expanded with the addition of Joan Anderson in Charlotte from McGuireWoods LLP, who focuses on defending high-profile product manufacturers, and Baltimore-based Marisa Trasatti from Cipriani & Werner, bringing significant local and national lead counsel experience.
Practice head(s):
Kim Schmid; Randall Christian
Other key lawyers:
Chris Carton; Joan Anderson; Marisa Trasatti
Testimonials
‘Practical solutions, firm footprint across the country.’
‘Kim Schmid is the entire package, trial prowess, team management and expert solutions.’
‘Kim Schmid takes our litigation goals and makes them her own. She expertly manages a defense team through a mass tort or litigation minefields.’
Key clients
Daiichi Sankyo, Inc.
Patheon Manufacturing Services LLC
CNA Insurance
TM Claims Service, Inc.
3M Company
Work highlights
- Representing Daiichi Sankyo, the second largest pharmaceutical company in Japan, in the Injectafer litigation.
- Representing Patheon Manufacturing Services LLC in the Zantac MDL.
Butler Snow LLP
Butler Snow LLP provides robust defense of pharma and medical device companies in nationwide mass tort litigation, backed by a deep bench of experienced trial lawyers. The ‘stalwart’ firm is particularly skilled at assembling and working collaboratively within ‘virtual law firms’, forming teams with the expertise required to handle each phase of the litigation – from witness preparation and defense to settlement negotiation and implementation. The practice is led by Ridgeland-based Alyson Bustamante Jones, who has extensive MDL experience and currently leads the AbbVie CoolSculpting device litigation, and Birmingham’s Caroline Walker, who represents Johnson & Johnson in the pelvic mesh litigation across the US. Memphis-based Eric Hudson is a ‘solid strategist and manager of litigations’ with vast experience in nationwide MDLs and mass tort settlements at both national and international levels. In the Oxford office, Kari Sutherland focuses on high-stakes personal injury matters and excels in coordinating national counsel and expert teams.
Practice head(s):
Alyson Bustamante Jones; Caroline Walker
Other key lawyers:
Paul Rosenblatt; Eric Hudson; Kari Sutherland
Testimonials
‘Butler remains a stalwart in the product liability space, possessing talent and professionalism from top to bottom.’
‘Paul Rosenblatt is one of the best there is. Eric Hudson is a solid strategist and manager of litigations.’
Key clients
Johnson & Johnson and Ethicon, Inc.
AbbVie Inc
Johnson & Johnson Consumer, Inc.
Publix Super Markets, Inc.
L’Oreal S.A.
CooperSurgical, Inc.
Bayer (Monsanto) Roundup
Exact Sciences Corporation
Exact Sciences Laboratories, LLC
Minerva Surgical, Inc.
Johnson & Johnson
Ethicon, Inc.
Mississippi State Department of Health
Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.
Teva Women’s Health, LLC
Teva Branded Pharmaceutical Products R&D, Inc.
B. Braun Medical, Inc.
Sunrise Medical (US) LLC
Work highlights
- Representing 3M in its nationwide PFAS litigation, including the MDL in South Carolina.
- Representing AbbVie defending litigation involving the use of the ZELTIQ/Allergan CoolSculpting® device.
- Representing Teva defendants in the pending Paragard MDL involving approximately 2,000 cases in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division.
Dechert LLP
Dechert LLP has secured favorable outcomes for pharma and medical device clients in appellate, federal, and state courts, handling complex multi-district and state-court product liability litigations. Notably, the firm has achieved significant victories through persuasive dispositive motions, often reducing or eliminating plaintiff pools. The product liability and mass torts practice is co-chaired by Los Angeles’ Jay Bhimani, an experienced trial lawyer, including in high-stakes bellwether cases. New York-based co-chair Douglas E. Fleming III’s extensive litigation experience includes examining and preparing witnesses for deposition, Daubert hearings, and trial and legislative testimony. New York-based Mark Cheffo, who co-chairs the global litigation practice, leads complex, high-profile pharma litigations, managing all stages from negotiation, through pre-trial proceedings to trial. Cheffo has been a key figure in the firm’s representation of GlaxoSmithKline as lead national counsel in the Zantac mass tort litigation. Also in New York, special counsel Sheila L. Birnbaum has vast experience representing leading pharma companies in complex product liability and mass torts litigation.
Practice head(s):
Jay Bhimani; Mark Cheffo; Douglas Fleming
Other key lawyers:
Sheila Birnbaum; Will Sachse; Hayden Coleman
Key clients
GlaxoSmithKline
Haleon
Work highlights
- Representing GSK as lead national counsel in multidistrict and state-court mass tort litigation concerning allegations that the heartburn medication Zantac causes cancer due to NDMA formation.
- Represented Haleon in a class action in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, where plaintiffs alleged that Robitussin’s labeling misled consumers about differences between children’s and adult products, despite identical formulations.
Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP
Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP has extensive experience defending pharma and medical device companies in product liability and mass tort defense throughout the US and internationally. The firm is recognized for its ‘exceptional ability to manage complex cross-border litigation’ ensuring ‘seamless coordination across jurisdictions’ and developing ‘complex legal strategies’ with a ‘comprehensive understanding of both global and local legal nuances’. The practice is led by James C. Fitzpatrick and Charles Cohen, both ‘technically very astute and able quickly to master complex technical and scientific details at the level of an expert’, as well as skilled in preparing and presenting trial witnesses. William Beausoleil is ‘excellent at briefing and oral argument, as well as overall litigation strategy’, having led the defense of the New York Blood Center. All lawyers mentioned are based in New York.
Practice head(s):
James Fitzpatrick; Charles Cohen
Other key lawyers:
William Beausoleil
Testimonials
‘Hughes Hubbard & Reed’s dispute resolution practice is unique due to its exceptional ability to manage complex cross-border litigation, particularly in pharmaceutical defense. The team, led by partners Charles Cohen and James Fitzpatrick, excels in aligning global strategies with local practices, ensuring seamless coordination across jurisdictions. Potential clients should know that the team is not only highly skilled and knowledgeable but also incredibly responsive and accommodating, providing strategic guidance that leads to successful outcomes. Compared to other firms, HHR stands out for its comprehensive approach to global management, effectively orchestrating international teams to achieve consistent results. The practice has introduced innovative collaboration techniques, leveraging technology to enhance communication and streamline processes. Additionally, their commitment to diversity and inclusive practices enriches their problem-solving capabilities, making them a top choice for clients facing global product crises.’
‘Top expertise in the area, respecting the law, the science and all relevant aspects of the practice. Extensive experience with complex, cross-border product liability, mass tort, and class actions defense work for pharmaceuticals and medical devices. Exceptional responsiveness and capacity to provide practical and strategic advice.’
‘Global leaders who act as trusted advisors for international corporates on their most sensitive issues and global mandates.’
‘The HHR team has extensive experience in pharmaceutical product liability and mass tort defense, having been involved in major cases over the past 20 years. They have individuals with particular expertise in science and overall litigation strategy in this practice area.’
‘Jim Fitzpatrick and Charlie Cohen are technically very astute and able quickly to master complex technical and scientific details at the level of an expert. Able to take a holistic, long term view on a project, identify issues that are key to clients. Successfully build long term working relationships with clients and be valued and trusted advisors.’
‘Jim Fitzpatrick is one of the top lawyers when it comes to science and experts in pharmaceutical litigation. He has a deep understanding of scientific and medical concepts, knows how to develop and present expert witnesses, and how to cross examine opposing experts. Charlie Cohen is an excellent overall strategist, and is also fantastic at preparing and presenting company witnesses. William Beausoleil is excellent at briefing and oral argument, as well as overall litigation strategy.’
‘The individuals I work with at Hughes Hubbard & Reed, particularly partners Charles Cohen and James Fitzpatrick, stand out due to their exceptional expertise and strategic acumen in managing cross-border litigation. Their ability to articulate complex legal strategies clearly and guide international teams through intricate legal landscapes is unparalleled. What sets them apart from competitors is their comprehensive understanding of both global and local legal nuances, allowing them to execute strategies without discrepancies. I have valued their responsiveness, professionalism, and the ability to provide insightful advice that prioritizes client needs. Their collaborative approach fosters a cohesive team environment, ensuring all members are aligned with the overarching strategy. This combination of skills and qualities makes them invaluable partners in navigating complex legal challenges.’
Key clients
New York Blood Center, Inc.
Organon & Co.
Merck Animal Health
Merck & Co.
Work highlights
- Advises the New York Blood Center in personal injury cases.
- Representing Merck Animal Health in a putative nationwide class action concerning its most popular and successful product Bravecto®.
- Representing Merck in nationwide litigation involving two of its most important and successful vaccines, Gardasil and Gardasil-9, both of which provide protection against cervical cancer and multiple other human papillomavirus-related (HPV) illnesses.
King & Spalding LLP
King & Spalding LLP represents clients in every segment of the life sciences industry in high-stakes product liability, class action, and mass torts. Leveraging its cross-practice expertise, the team collaborates closely with appellate, regulatory, and life science lawyers. It regularly serves as national and regional coordinating counsel, and its strategic resolution team has favorably resolved large litigations. The practice is led by Atlanta’s Andy Bayman, who serves as lead counsel for Boehringer Ingelheim in litigation involving Zantac; and Houston’s Tracie Renfroe, who represents clients in federal and state civil jury trials, MDLs, and class actions. TaCara Harris, in Atlanta, chairs the firm's pharmaceutical & medical device litigation practice group. Shaila Rahman Diwan departed the team in May 2025.
Practice head(s):
Andy Bayman; Tracie Renfroe
Other key lawyers:
TaCara Harris
Key clients
Becton Dickinson
Boehringer Ingelheim
Bristol-Myers Squibb
Eli Lilly & Company
GlaxoSmithKline
Johnson & Johnson/Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Kenvue, fka Johnson & Johnson Consumer Inc.
Organon
Walmart, Inc.
Work highlights
- Serves as national coordinating and trial counsel for Boehringer Ingelheim in all litigation alleging its heartburn medication Zantac increases the risk of cancer.
- Served as national counsel for Walmart in litigation alleging that manufacturers of Tylenol and retailers of private-labeled acetaminophen products failed to warn pregnant mothers about the potential risks to their children of prenatal exposure to the drugs.
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP serves as trial and national coordinating counsel to pharma and medical device companies in large-scale litigation, including MDLs. The team also advises clients on product safety recalls, regulatory inquiries, and litigation before regulatory agencies. Pittsburgh’s Wendy West Feinstein is a seasoned litigator and trial lawyer, skilled in developing and executing strategies to navigate and resolve large-scale, high-profile crisis and repetitive litigation, and serving as lead trial and coordinating counsel for Philips RS in the CPAP MDL. Dallas- and Houston-based Nancy Patterson, who has deep trial experience, served as lead counsel for Teva Pharmaceuticals and affiliates in multiple matters concerning the national opioid litigation.
Practice head(s):
Wendy West Feinstein
Other key lawyers:
Nancy Patterson
Key clients
Philips RS North America LLC
Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.
Obagi Cosmeceuticals, LLC
Aurobindo Pharma, Inc.
Merck & Co., Inc.
Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.
Work highlights
- Serves as lead counsel for Philips RS North America LLC on the ongoing MDL resulting from the voluntary recall of certain Philips Respironics CPAP, BiPAP, and mechanical ventilator prescription medical devices.
- Represented Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. and affiliated entities in state and local government opioid litigation against the City of Baltimore.
Morrison Foerster
Morrison Foerster is active on behalf of harma and medical device companies in product liability matters, providing ‘high-level litigation strategy’, such as in mass torts and class actions, and 'efficient day-to-litigation counsel’. The team also provides regulatory compliance guidance, including advising clients on product recalls and how product liability law applies to cutting-edge products, such as those driven by AI. Co-chairing the practice from San Diego and San Francisco, seasoned litigator Erin Bosman defends clients in high-stakes mass tort cases and helps them navigate complex, company-threatening product liability crises. Notably, Bosman represented McKesson in MDL and state court proceedings related to alleged permanent hair loss after breast cancer treatment with Taxotere. A key figure in the practice, Julie Park is experienced in managing complex, multijurisdictional litigation in both state and federal courts, while also guiding clients through product recalls.
Practice head(s):
Erin Bosman
Other key lawyers:
Julie Park
Testimonials
‘Morrison Foerster’s product liability team is our go-to for critical litigation. They provide both high-level litigation strategy and efficient day-to-litigation counsel. They are our first call when we need product liability counsel. Additionally, they are particularly skilled at managing litigation in the larger context of running our business.’
‘Erin Bosman and Julie Park understand our business and our products, which allows them to address issues efficiently. They are also very good at delegating in a productive, efficient way. They are prompt communicators, always available when we need them.’
Key clients
McKesson Corporation
MicroPort Orthopedics Inc.
Prelude Fertility, Inc.
Work highlights
- Representing McKesson in multidistrict litigation and state court proceedings comprising thousands of cases arising out of plaintiffs’ allegations that they experienced permanent hair loss after being treated for breast cancer with Taxotere.
- Advising MicroPort Orthopedics in dozens of product liability cases, nationally and internationally, in which plaintiffs allege injuries from hip or knee replacement implants.
- Defended Prelude Fertility in litigation arising out of a tank failure at Pacific Fertility Center in San Francisco, potentially affecting hundreds of patients.
Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP
Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP’s growing practice defends global pharma and medical devices companies in product liability litigation. With dedicated teams on both coasts, the firm regularly serves as lead trial counsel in bellwether cases and as national coordinating counsel in multidistrict litigation. In South Carolina, David Dukes led the firm’s defense of Merck in the Gardasil HPV vaccine MDL. Atlanta-based Richard North is national lead for Beckton Dickinson and its subsidiaries in litigation regarding C. R. Bard’s inferior vena cava filter, currently handling cases in federal courts throughout the country. Washington DC’s Terri Reiskin brings extensive experience in class action defense and mass torts. The broader litigation group is led by South Carolina’s Mark Jones, who has acted as counsel in nationwide pharma litigation, and Minneapolis-based Alana Bassin, who has served as national and lead counsel for global medical device manufacturers in consolidated actions and mass torts.
Practice head(s):
Mark Jones; Alana Bassin
Other key lawyers:
David Dukes; Richard North; Terri Reiskin; Molly Jean Given; Jenny Covington
Key clients
Becton Dickinson and Company
Boston Scientific Corporation
CooperSurgical, Inc.
The CooperCompanies, Inc.
Endologix Inc. / Endologix LLC
Johnson & Johnson
Janssen Pharmaceuticals
Ethicon
Mentor Worldwide LLC
Merck
NuVasive Inc.
Smith & Nephew, Inc.
Work highlights
- Representing Merck in the Gardasil products liability MDL, including successfully removing six claims from the docket in 2024.
- Serving as national coordinating council for C. R. Bard, Inc. in its inferior vena cava (IVC) filter litigation.
- Represented CooperSurgical, Inc. (and The CooperCompanies, Inc.) as national counsel against claims arising following the recall of several lots of an in vitro fertilization solution, including successfully opposing plaintiffs’ requests for the approval of an MDL to join 30 cases.
O'Melveny
O'Melveny has been at the forefront of defending emerging issues in product liability, mass torts, and class action litigation, including those that pose significant risks to pharma and medical device companies. Washington DC-based Steven Brody, who has extensive experience defending mass torts, class actions, and state attorney general cases involving promotion, labeling, consumer fraud, and false claims, co-chairs the product liability and mass torts practice with Los Angeles’ Sabrina Strong. A seasoned trial lawyer and appellate advocate, Strong represents clients in bet-the-company litigation. Both defended Johnson & Johnson in nationwide opioid litigation, recently securing favorable settlements in Washington and Baltimore. The consumer class actions practice is headed by Hannah Chanoine and Matt Powers, based in New York and San Francisco, respectively.
Practice head(s):
Steve Brody; Sabrina Strong; Hannah Chanoine; Matt Powers
Key clients
Johnson & Johnson
Kenvue
AbbVie
Work highlights
Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath
Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP has a strong track record handling high-stakes, large-scale product liability, and mass torts litigation in the pharma and medical devices space. With offices across the US, the firm often serves as national counsel and nationwide coordinating counsel. Chairing the practice from Minneapolis is Amy Fiterman, a seasoned litigator who has defended pharma and medical device manufacturers from product liability and consumer fraud actions in MDLs and state coordinated proceedings, including representing Boston Scientific in the pelvic repair system litigation. Indianapolis-based Andrea Roberts Pierson acts as national counsel for Cook Medical in an MDL involving its inferior vena cava (IVC) filter products. Also in Indianapolis, Andrew Campbell advises clients on litigation and pre-litigation risk management. In the firm’s newly established Fort Myers office, Traci McKee handles all phases of litigation, from discovery through trial. The team expanded with the addition of Peter Meyer, who joined the Indianapolis team in July 2024.
Practice head(s):
Amy Fiterman; Andrew Campbell; Traci McKee; Christopher Dolan
Other key lawyers:
Andrea Roberts Pierson; Peter Meyer
Key clients
Cook Medical
Zimmer Biomet
Johnson & Johnson
Boston Scientific Corp.
Medtronic
Exactech
Work highlights
- Representing Cook Medical as national counsel in multidistrict litigation involving its inferior vena cava (IVC) filter product.
Reed Smith LLP
Reed Smith LLP advises leading pharma and medical device companies in product liability litigation. With offices spread around the country, the practice offers multi-jurisdictional advice and frequently acts as national counsel in high-profile MDLs and class actions. The team is also skilled in negotiating confidential settlements in highly sensitive cases. Princeton-based Melissa Geist, who co-chairs the firm’s global life sciences health industry group, has extensive experience navigating the technical issues involved in developing company defenses, as well as preparing witnesses to deliver compelling testimony during depositions and at trial. Michael Brown, based in Los Angeles, is a leading trial lawyer with broad experience in complex product liability and is recognized for his expertise in federal preemption in both trial and appellate courts. Other than her extensive experience in defending over-the-counter and prescription drug manufacturers, Philadelphia-based Heather Rich Rocks has in-depth knowledge of the scientific and medical expertise required to defend complex product liability claims, regularly working with medical and scientific experts.
Practice head(s):
Melissa Geist
Other key lawyers:
Michael Brown; Heather Ritch Rocks
Testimonials
‘Heather Ritch Rocks is a highly skilled product liability lawyer, supremely knowledgeable about the technical details, and has excellent communication skills. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her. We collaborated over many years on international mass tort claims, in which Heather coordinated global strategy and provided detailed input, acting effectively as an extended part of our team.’
Work highlights
Troutman Pepper Locke LLP
Troutman Pepper Locke LLP is widely recognized for its strong track record in defending pharma and medical device companies in high-stakes product liability, mass tort, and personal injury litigation involving a wide range of products. The firm has expertise in managing large-scale, multi-jurisdictional cases involving the same product. Philadelphia-based Sean Fahey, chair of the health sciences department, has led numerous high-profile litigation matters, including representing Zhejiang Huahai Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. in the valsartan MDL pending in New Jersey. Ronni Fuchs, based in Princeton, chairs the litigation practice group. Both have been actively involved in the firm’s defense of LivaNova in the remaining federal MDL and parallel state claims related to allegations that the Sorin 3T Heater-Cooler System caused non-tuberculosis mycobacterial infection in patients.
Practice head(s):
Sean Fahey; Ronni Fuchs
Key clients
Abbott Laboratories
Boehringer Ingelheim
Amneal Pharmaceuticals
Zhejiang Huahai Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.
Becton Dickinson
BioSense Webster, a Johnson & Johnson subsidiary
LivaNova USA
Johnson and Johnson
B. Braun Medical
Work highlights
Tucker Ellis LLP
Representing high-profile pharma and medical devices clients in product liability litigation, Tucker Ellis LLP manages both single-plaintiff cases and large-scale proceedings at every stage, from initial investigation, to discovery and depositions, through settlement, trial, and appeals. The firm has secured significant trial and appellate victories, including obtaining numerous favorable rulings on preemption and Daubert in federal district and circuit courts, effectively limiting client liability. The practice is led by Chicago-based Sherry Knutson and Cleveland’s Tariq Naeem, both of whom have served as trial counsel in a pelvic mesh case that resulted in a defense jury verdict for Johnson & Johnson and its subsidiary Ethicon, Inc. Also in Cleveland, Charissa Walker has defended numerous manufacturers in product liability claims across state and federal courts. Diana Katz Gerston and Maha Kabbash joined the Morristown office from Riker, Danzig, Scherer, Hyland & Perretti in February 2024; both have substantial trial experience and fully focus on defending pharma and medical device companies in product liability litigation.
Practice head(s):
Sherry Knutson; Tariq Naeem
Other key lawyers:
Diana Katz Gerston; Maha Kabbash; Charissa Walker
Key clients
Johnson & Johnson
Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Ethicon, Inc.
Ethicon Endo-Surgery, LLC
DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc.
Takeda
Work highlights
Venable LLP
Venable LLP is recognized for its ‘broad, deeply experienced’ pharma and medical device product liability team, with attorneys serving as lead counsel for manufacturers in federal MDLs and statewide coordinated proceedings. The team has also defended clients against international mass tort claims, while similarly representing them in nationwide consumer class actions, frequently defeating class certification in federal courts. The practice is led by Baltimore-based Kathleen Hardway – who is ‘very skilled in the scientific and medical aspects of pharmaceutical litigation, particularly offensive and defensive expert work’ – and Jason Rose, who currently serves as deputy co-national counsel to Takeda in litigation related to its proton-pump inhibitor (PPI) medications. 2024 saw the team expanding with the addition of three experienced litigators from Steptoe LLP – Jeremy Goldkind and Derek Smith in Chicago, and Joo Cha Webb in Los Angeles.
Practice head(s):
Kathleen Hardway; Jason Rose
Other key lawyers:
Craig Thompson; Jeremy Goldkind; Derek Smith; Joo Cha Webb
Testimonials
‘Venable’s capacity to explain the legal process to stakeholders, present pros and cons on any action and share clear visibility of next steps is valued.’
‘Venable has a broad, deeply experienced pharma product liability/mass torts team. They have played all roles (overall national counsel, trial counsel, science/expert counsel, briefing counsel) in major pharma cases over the past few decades.’
‘Craig Thompson is a top-notch trial lawyer. Kathleen Hardway and Michael Hecht are both very skilled in the scientific and medical aspects of pharmaceutical litigation, particularly offensive and defensive expert work.’
Key clients
Takeda Pharmaceuticals U.S.A, Inc.
Merck & Co., Inc.
Laboratory Corporation of America
Venator Corporation
Work highlights
Jones Day
Jones Day handles pharma and medical device product liability matters at all stages, from pre-litigation counseling to discovery, jury trials, and appeals. Its partners are experienced in developing class action strategies, leading MDLs and state-coordinated proceedings, and serving as nationwide coordinating counsel to ensure consistency and efficiency in defense strategies. The firm leads Walmart’s defense in all aspects of the nationwide opioid litigation, managing the MDL, state court cases, Department of Justice civil litigation, and all related appeals. The product liability practice is led by Atlanta-based Stephanie Parker, recognized for her extensive experience trying and leading ‘bet-the-company’ litigation.
Practice head(s):
Stephanie Parker
Other key lawyers:
José Isasi II; Celeste Brecht; Kristina Cercone
Key clients
Indivior, Inc.
Medtronic (MPROC)
Steris Corporation
Walmart Stores, Inc.
Work highlights
Mayer Brown
Mayer Brown represents in high-profile product liability defense for pharmaceutical and medical device companies. New York-based Henninger Bullock, a seasoned life sciences litigator, has great experience in disputes in state and federal courts at both trial and appellate levels. With extensive MDL experience, he defends GlaxoSmithKline against innovator liability claims. In Chicago, Daniel Ring brings experience across personal injury litigation and class actions, while frequently coordinating virtual law firm teams in complex cases and challenging jurisdictions. Co-leading the practice with Bullock and Ring, Chicago-based Michael Olsen is skilled in toxic tort and medical devices litigation.
Practice head(s):
Henninger Bullock; Michael Olsen; Daniel Ring
Key clients
Endo Pharmaceuticals
Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd.
GlaxoSmithKline
Work highlights
- Served as national counsel for GlaxoSmithKline defending numerous cases both pre- and post-suit surrounding the expansive tort theory of innovator liability.
McGuireWoods LLP
McGuireWoods LLP’s seasoned litigators bring decades of success in defending leading companies in complex product liability and mass tort litigation. Recognized for its innovation, the team immerses itself in clients’ products, businesses, objectives, and regulatory landscapes to craft strategic defenses. The practice is co-led by Justin Howard, based in Richmond and Raleigh, with varied experience defending manufacturers and distributors in product liability claims, and Samuel Tarry, in the Tysons and Washington DC offices, who serves as lead trial and coordinating for pharma and medical devices companies in a variety of litigation. Another key team member, Richmond-based Davis Walsh, brings expertise across all phases of medical device litigation, having served in several capacities during trial.
Practice head(s):
Benjamin Hatch; Justin Howard; Samuel Tarry, Jr.
Other key lawyers:
Davis Walsh; Mark Anderson
Key clients
Duke University Health System
Work highlights
- Representing Duke University Health System in a class action filed in the US District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina in which Duke and other health systems are co-defendants with Meta.
Norton Rose Fulbright
Norton Rose Fulbright is renowned for its proficiency in pharmaceutical product liability cases and spin-off economic loss litigations. Dallas-based practice head D’Lesli Davis is vastly experienced leading high-stakes litigation in some the country’s most difficult jurisdictions; indeed, she is a key figure in the firm’s representation of Takeda as lead counsel in a national RICO economic loss putative class action arising from allegations of the company’s failure to warn of side effects, pending in Los Angeles federal court. Along with Houston’s Ellie Norris, Davis also represents McKesson Corporation in the Sartan MDL. New joiner Josh Lee arrived from Riley Safer Holmes & Cancila to co-head the litigation and disputes practice from Chicago.
Practice head(s):
D’Lesli Davis
Other key lawyers:
Ellie N0rris; Josh Lee; Geraldine Young; Alicia Grant
Key clients
Takeda Pharmaceutical Company
McKesson Corporation
Work highlights
- Representing Takeda Pharmaceuticals as lead counsel in a national RICO economic loss putative class action arising from allegations of failure to warn of side effects.
- Representing Takeda Pharmaceuticals and Abbott in the PPI (Prevacid, Prilosec) personal injury MDL within a virtual law firm.
- Representing pharmaceutical wholesaler McKesson Corporation in the 3-pronged Sartan (blood pressure pharmaceuticals valsartan, losartan and irbesartan) MDL.
Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP
With longstanding trial experience, Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP is a trusted defender of pharma and medical device companies in product liability litigation. The firm handles class actions that target entire industries, serves as lead and coordinating counsel in MDLs, and represents clients in bellwether trials and precedent-setting cases. Beyond its trial expertise, the firm’s lawyers employ strategic discovery, pretrial motions and alternative dispute resolution to secure favorable outcomes, supported by in-house research analysts. Both leading trial lawyers with cross-jurisdictional experience, Miami-based Hildy Sastre and William Geraghty co-chair the practice. The team saw significant expansion in 2024, with Steven Weisburd joining the Houston team from Carlton Fields, Alycia Degen arriving in the Los Angeles office from Sidley Austin LLP, and Boston’s Lisa Oliver White arriving from Murphy & Riley.
Practice head(s):
Hildy Sastre; William Geraghty
Other key lawyers:
Steven Weisburd; Alycia Degen; Lisa Oliver White
Work highlights
Sidley Austin LLP
Boasting a team of litigators with ‘deep industry expertise’, Sidley Austin LLP is active in national mass tort litigation, strategic planning and handling of MDLs, and success in high-stakes trials withing the most challenging jurisdictions. Its ‘skilled and knowledgeable’ partners also offer pre-litigation counseling and conduct risk assessments during product development, proactively addressing potential challenges before they escalate into litigation. The practice is led by New York’s Heidi Levine, ‘an experienced lead lawyer’, and ‘talented and tenacious’ Jennifer Saulino, based in Washington DC. Chicago’s Michelle Ramirez is a trial lawyer and litigation strategist ‘with extensive subject matter expertise’.
Practice head(s):
Heidi Levine; Jennifer Saulino
Other key lawyers:
Michelle Ramirez
Testimonials
‘The Sidley team has deep industry expertise that allows them to deliver quality representation in the pharma and medical device space. It has several impressive partners who are very skilled and knowledgeable in the field.’
‘Jennifer Saulino is a talented and tenacious trial lawyer and not afraid of any challenge. Michelle Ramirez is an up and coming trial lawyer who is very easy to work with. Heidi Levine is a strong leader and an experienced lead lawyer in product liability cases.’
‘Michelle Ramirez is a poised courtroom presence, always well prepared, and with extensive subject matter expertise it this sector.’
Key clients
Bayer HealthCare LLC
Grifols Shared Services North America, Inc.
Grifols Therapeutics LLC
Argon Medical Devices
Work highlights
Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP
Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP is a trusted defender of pharma companies in product-related litigation, with extensive experience serving as lead counsel in product liability, class actions, and mass tort cases, often acting as national coordinating counsel. Diane Sullivan, who splits her time between New Jersey and New York, is a seasoned trial lawyer known for handling ‘bet-the-company’ cases in jurisdictions across the US, having defended GlaxoSmithKline in individual plaintiff product liability jury trials related to the Zantac prescription drug. Silicon Valley-based David Singh’s broad experience includes representing a major pharma and healthcare company in Lanham Act false advertising consumer class actions.
Practice head(s):
Diane Sullivan; David Singh; Drew Tulumello; Theodore E. Tsekerides; Arianna Scavetti; Pravin Patel
Key clients
GlaxoSmithKline
Johnson & Johnson