Hall Of Fame

Health and safety in South West

Burges Salmon LLP

Burges Salmon LLP’s health and safety team is noted in particular for its activity in the rail sector, where the firm is regularly called on to assist with major accident matters. The range of sector expertise within the firm remains broad, and covers industries such as food, agriculture, construction, and retail. The ‘extremely knowledgeable’ Ann Metherall heads the team and also leads the firm’s dispute resolution group as well as its major incidents response team; she is frequently sought-out by rail sector clients. Multi-fatality incidents are an area of expertise for Charlotte Whitaker. Sam Aldous is also a name to note in the team. Sian Edmunds left the firm for an in-house position in January 2023.

Practice head(s):

Ann Metherall


Other key lawyers:

Chris Jackson; Guy Bastable; Charlotte Whitaker; Sam Aldous


Testimonials

‘The team are extremely professional and are very efficient and effective in the legal service they provide. They go the extra mile and make sure you understand all the advice and implications of any decision making and impacts therein. They make it easy to understand and have a great track-record in giving the correct advice and support whenever needed.’

‘Ann Metherall is extremely knowledgeable about health and safety and the rail industry. She adds great value and is a great sounding board during difficult times.’

‘Charlotte Whitaker is always available to explain everything that I need to know in a way that is not legalistic and understandable. She is diligent and supportive.’

‘A superb team. Always 100% committed and able to deal swiftly and authoritatively with the most difficult cases.’

‘Ann Metherall is a star of immense experience and peerless judgment. Charlotte Whitaker is a superb lawyer, providing a first-class service in the most complex and sensitive cases.’

‘Burges Salmon have an extremely capable and highly experienced team dealing with incident and crisis management in the health and safety field.’

‘They have a tremendous track-record in transport disaster, as well as in advising and defending corporate bodies in police and HSE investigations.’

‘Any organisation requiring the services of this team will be appreciative of the skillset within it. There are not many firms around that can rival the H&S work undertaken by Burges Salmon as there is a nice mix and interaction with its corporate criminal defence team. It is no surprise that they attract the large corporations in the transport and industrial fields.’

Key clients

The Crown Estate


FirstGroup PLC


John Lewis Partnership plc


Work highlights


  • Advised a client in the transport sector on a multi-fatality incident including advising on the criminal investigations, inquests and prosecution.
  • Advised an energy sector client on a fatality including the interview under caution and inquest proceedings.
  • Advised a client on a corporate manslaughter investigation into a multi-fatality incident.

DAC Beachcroft LLP

Hailed as ‘the go-to firm in the South West for the high-profile and complex cases’, DAC Beachcroft LLP has a strong client base consisting of companies active in construction, insurance, real estate, and the public sector, amongst others. Covering all major areas of health and safety, the practice is also noted for its specialism advising clients on matters relating to environmental law. Chris Baranowski leads the firm’s national offering from Leeds, while regulatory and crime specialist Richard Ottley heads up the South West team. Prosecutions and investigations relating to gross negligence manslaughter and other offences involving fatalities form part of Peter James' advisory portfolio.

Practice head(s):

Chris Baranowski; Richard Ottley


Other key lawyers:

Bridget Sanger; Neil Scott


Testimonials

‘Efficient, clear-thinking and commercial – what more could you want?’

‘The go-to firm in the South West for the high-profile and complex cases. Their massive strength-in-depth means they are ready to deal with everything from minor regulatory matters all the way up to police investigations into gross negligence manslaughter. A favourite for the big corporate companies due to their experience and excellent strategic advice.’

‘Richard Ottley is the lead partner and has seen it all. Clients love him for his ability to understand the main issues quickly, regulators fear him for his in-depth knowledge and strategic approach.’

Key clients

Somerset Council


Covea Insurance


Royal Mail


Unite


Keepmoat


Zurich


NFU Mutual


Network Rail


British Airways


The National Trust


Asda


AXA


Aviva


Chubb


RSA


QBE


AIG


Osborne Clarke LLP

Osborne Clarke LLP regularly handles high-profile inquests and health and safety investigations on a national level, where the firm advises both public and private sector clients. The practice is also active in compliance, assisting companies with wellbeing strategies and in the management of occupational stress, in addition to supporting media and entertainment clients with health and safety matters in film and TV production. Mary Lawrence acts as practice head, specialising in contentious work as well as crisis management, while Matthew Kyle focuses on regulatory crime, particularly in relation to fire and building safety. Georgia Lythgoe complements her health and safety expertise with experience in environmental crime.

Practice head(s):

Mary Lawerence


Other key lawyers:

Matthew Kyle; Georgia Lythgoe; Reshma Adkin; Matthew Vernon


Testimonials

‘Osborne Clarke’s experience in health and safety is unrivalled. The team have facilitated innovative workshops for our group to find synergies in our processes, policies and documentation and to help us take a more strategic view of our risk management and our contractual arrangements. They are thought leaders in their area.’

‘The Rolls Royce of the sector providing outstanding depth of knowledge, experience and client-focused advice to large corporates and group structures.’

‘Mary Lawrence is a stand-out lawyer; sharp technical skills, a very engaging and persuasive manner and she provides concise advice easily tailored to our business with ease. Her presentation style is dynamic and engaging, she holds a room effortlessly and pitches content at the right level for her audience. She is very well-supported by Reshma Adkin, who possesses all of the key qualities noted above too and who has built a great rapport with our business.’

‘The extensive depth of knowledge of the team is unrivalled. The team are responsive and reassuring to the business when incidents of health and safety arise. The team provide effective legal advice not bogged down in legal jargon. They take the time to get to know our business so they understand the impact of the advice they provide.’

‘Technically and practically excellent on building safety, very strong practice and go-to experts.’

‘Matthew Kyle is very strong and gives practical advice and knows the building safety market and regulatory framework inside out.’

‘The Osborne Clarke team are attentive by routine, thorough in both their due diligence and support which is actively experienced during OC pro-active work and client-driven project work but increasingly recognisable during sensitive case management.’

‘My experience is that OC as a team are attentive in every facet of interaction. The quality of service and support is a positive reflection on OC’s culture at the point of staff recruitment, training, competence and employee welfare bolstered by client retention, all leading to service of exemplary standards.’

Key clients

Barratt Developments PLC


RWE


Netflix


ITV


National Grid Electricity Distribution


Wales & West


Danone


Work highlights


  • Advising RWE in relation to the police and HSE investigation into the high-profile Didcot power station collapse.
  • Advising a real estate company involved in the investment, management and development of rental housing on their responsibilities under the Building Safety Act, including the new statutory role of Accountable Person.
  • Advising a UK housing developer to develop a serious of tailored online tools to support compliance with the Building Safety Act.

TLT

The wide-ranging practice at TLT is noted in particular for its sector strengths pertaining to industries such as leisure, food and drink, public sector, and real estate. The practice works closely together with its counterparts in Manchester and London, making it a popular choice for multinational clients and domestic public bodies. Kerry Gwyther leads the team and is well-versed across incident management, investigations, and prosecutions by regional and national regulators. Solicitor advocate Duncan Reed, who is singled out for his ‘balanced and calm approach’, is a key name for clients facing regulatory prosecution.

Practice head(s):

Kerry Gwyther


Other key lawyers:

Duncan Reed; Richard Collie


Testimonials

‘Great specialist knowledge of the process, very pragmatic and sensitive to difficult scenarios when advising and in dealing with external parties.’

‘Duncan Reed’s balanced and calm approach works well with our internal stakeholders.’

Key clients

Iceland Foods


JD Sports Plc


Keolis Amey Metrolink


Greene King Plc


Sports Ground Safety Authority


Department of Health and Social Care


Punch Taverns PLC


Iceland


British Solar Renewables


Pennon Group


DEFRA


SpaMedica


Manchester Airports Group


Argos Limited


G. Network Communications Limited


Bendpak Inc.


Work highlights


  • Advising Greene King in connection with various health and safety and regulatory matters including: Food safety and hygiene, gas and electrical safety, anti-social behaviour, noise, statutory compliance testing and Equality Act compliance.
  • Supported Bendpak Inc in connection with representation at an Inquest in London for 10 days at the end of 2022.
  • Regularly advise Punch Taverns on various compliance issues arising on health and safety.

Womble Bond Dickinson (UK) LLP

Womble Bond Dickinson (UK) LLP excels across the full breadth of health and safety, including risk and crisis management, compliance issues, and enforcement-related matters such as HSE investigations and inquests. Leeds’ Kevin Elliott leads the team jointly with Jon Cooper in Bristol; Cooper has extensive experience in this area, extending to both strategic and governance advice as well as prosecution and defence. Ashley Borthwick regularly handles the investigation of and enforcement surrounding serious workplace incidents, and is also well-versed in matters relating to product safety.

Practice head(s):

Kevin Elliott; Jon Cooper


Other key lawyers:

Ashley Borthwick


Key clients

Babcock


B&Q Plc


Carlsberg UK


Princess Yachts Limited


AIG


IBI Group (UK) Limited


Sir Robert McAlpine Limited


Siemens Energy


Local Authority Building Control (LABC)


Work highlights


  • Advised Sir Robert McAlpine following a fatal accident during the refurbishment of the St Enoch’s Shopping Centre Glasgow.
  • Advised Princess Yachts in respect of a prosecution arising from a serious accident in November 2021.
  • Advised Local Authority Building Control in the Grenfell Tower Inquiry.

Ashfords LLP

Praised as a ‘very capable firm that is arguably punching above its weight’, Ashfords LLP acts for a wide-range of clients including regional healthcare trusts, water companies, and international food businesses, which call upon the firm for advisory and defence purposes. Ian Manners, who specialises in health and safety risks, leads the Bristol and Exeter-based team. Clients in the marine sector turn to Lara Moore for her expertise pertaining to harbour revisions and marine regulations, while Zoe Hunt regularly advises on inquest matters.

Practice head(s):

Ian Manners


Other key lawyers:

Lara Moore; Zoe Hunt; Rhian Gravell


Testimonials

‘Personal service from a very capable firm that is arguably punching above its weight.’

‘Ian Manners takes the time to really understand our business and he feels like an extension of our own team when he is supporting us. Ian is skilful, strategic in his thinking and works collaboratively with his client. He is highly recommended by us.’

‘This team has established itself in the South West as the go-to firm for SME’s in the West Country. It has shown a particular understanding of the issues facing SME’s when facing a regulatory investigation and provides specific and focused advice to reflect the make-up of the organisation.’

‘Ian Manners is the lead partner and brings a wealth of experience to the firm. His down-to-earth manner makes him popular with clients, but he has the talent and expertise to make him a formidable adversary. A leading light in the South West.’

‘The Ashfords team is small and therefore they can offer a highly personalised service, which is of huge value in the highly pressurised and emotional cases inherent in health and safety work. They strive to fully understand the client’s needs and work tirelessly to ensure the most favourable outcome.’

‘Ian Manners is an excellent team leader. He exudes calm and thoughtful leadership in the most stressful of situations and always displays excellent judgment. You would always want him in your corner in any difficult case.’

‘Very client-centric approach. They ensure understanding of processes and contexts.’

‘Ian Manners, Zoe Hunt and Rhian Gravell were fantastic from start to finish. They took a holistic approach ensuring clients understand what is happening, what might happen next and why. Their client care was fantastic.’

Key clients

Cappagh Group


Harbour Authorities


Work highlights


  • Acting for a core participant in the Grenfell Tower Inquiry and in the ongoing met police-led investigation.
  • Representing the former CEO and CFO of an IV Diagnostic Testing Company being investigated in their individual capacity by HSE in respect of COSHH and health and safety offences.
  • Instructed in the ongoing investigation and Inquest concerning the death of an individual on the Bibby Stockholm barge.

Browne Jacobson LLP

Browne Jacobson LLP covers a wide array of health and safety matters, ranging from due diligence on corporate transactions to complex investigations relating to corporate manslaughter and fatal incidents. The practice acts on the side of both public and private sector clients, including those active in healthcare, education, and agriculture. Andrew Hopkin leads the firm’s national offering from Nottingham; key contacts in the South West are Dale Collins who is adept at handling regulatory investigations, and Nigel Lyons whose practice centres around criminal law.

Practice head(s):

Andrew Hopkin


Other key lawyers:

Dale Collins; Nigel Lyons


Testimonials

‘This team’s commitment to client interests is second-to-none. They bring huge experience with an undiminished enthusiasm for the case and finding the best route to the best outcome for their clients.’

‘The client feels well looked after and for good reason.’

‘Andrew Hopkin and Nigel Lyons are a formidable team. Their personal commitment to the client is deeply impressive and the way they immerse themselves in the case, sift strengths and weaknesses and win against impossible odds makes them the go-to individuals in the South West.’

Key clients

Natural England


The Coal Authority


Foot Anstey

Foot Anstey assists clients in the prevention of health and safety risks on the one hand, while also representing them before such regulatory bodies as the HSE. Nathan Peacey, who also heads the firm's wider risk advisory group, is the key contact, adept at handling matters relating to corporate governance, regulatory investigations, and corporate crime. Tim Williamson complements his expertise in health and safety with a focus on the sports sector.

Practice head(s):

Nathan Peacey


Other key lawyers:

Tim Williamson


Testimonials

‘A very friendly team, who box well above their weight in terms of the calibre of the work they undertake.’

‘Tim Williamson is a clever and enthusiastic solicitor. Tim has very strong interpersonal skills and is forever trying to find a positive outcome for his clients. He has a good knowledge of H&S law, and shows excellent judgement when applying it to solve problems.’

Work highlights


  • Advising an individual involved in the Grenfell Tower Inquiry and the related Metropolitan Police investigation.

RPC

RPC excels in insurance law, with a strong track-record in liability and professional indemnity policies and in regularly handling fatalities arising from gross negligence and corporate manslaughter. The practice is part of the firm’s wider regulatory offering, and works closely with its corporate, construction and commercial disputes departments in particular. Led by Gavin Reese and Fiona Hahlo, the group’s comprehensive expertise covers both contentious and regulatory matters.

Practice head(s):

Gavin Reese; Fiona Hahlo


Other key lawyers:

Steven Aitken


Testimonials

‘A very strong regulatory team with huge experience in dealing with high-profile and sensitive health and safety cases.’

‘There is no case too difficult that the RPC team cannot handle with aplomb.’

‘Provide a seamless and first-class service in all aspects of fatal accident cases including inquest representation, civil claims and health and safety prosecutions.’

‘Gavin Reese is an outstanding lawyer. His tactical judgment is unmatched in the profession and he is an asset in every case in which he is instructed.’

‘Focused and comprehensive approach and always pragmatic.’

Work highlights


  • Providing a client with ongoing advice relating to a number of health & safety matters, most recently helping them navigate a Freedom of Information request from the HSE.

Bevan Brittan LLP

Praised for its ‘deep knowledge and understanding of a wide-range of topics’, Bevan Brittan LLP fields a broad health and safety practice, handling both contentious and non-contentious matters from a prosecution and defence angle. Birmingham’s Adam Kendall, London-based Stuart Marchant, and Hannah Taylor in Bristol jointly head the group, with Taylor counting regulatory scrutiny and intervention amongst her areas of expertise.

Practice head(s):

Hannah Taylor; Adam Kendall; Stuart Marchant


Other key lawyers:

Carlton Sadler; Louise Mansfield


Testimonials

‘The team have a deep knowledge and understanding of a wide-range of topics and have a wealth of training experience, particularly immersive learning.’

‘This firm has provided pragmatic legal advice, on a potentially complex situation. The time allocated and the billing have been timely and transparent and the quality of work was excellent. The phone calls and counsel given have allowed us to quickly define a useful product for the situation.’

‘Louise Mansfield has provided excellent service to time and within budget. She has supported ad-hoc queries, communicated on timelines and challenges well, and delivered a quality product. This good service is combined with a personable and professional approach making the client feel supported.’

‘Highly professional and approachable, always quick to respond to queries and deliver over and above expectations.’

‘A very professional team that is capable of providing legal advice on a range of topics when needed. The use of data hubs to upload information into rather than emailing is a huge help. They have a wealth of knowledge across a broad-range of subjects and access to unique specialists where required.’

‘From a personal perspective, the ability to have direct access to a partner at all times is of immense benefit and makes them unique in my opinion.’

Work highlights


  • Advised the client on its successful prosecution for breaches of health and safety offences following the death of a 10-year-old boy.

Michelmores LLP

Led by Andrew Oldland KC who splits his time between Exeter and London, Michelmores LLP excels in crisis management with a focus on workplace fatalities, serious injuries, and marine safety. The practice counts a number of clients active in the public sector amongst its portfolio, while also being a popular choice for companies active in agriculture, manufacturing and construction.

Practice head(s):

Andrew Oldland KC


Other key lawyers:

Jayne Clemens; Scott Love


Testimonials

‘The team is very well run, and goes the extra mile to ensure that all avenues are explored in order to provide the best possible representation for clients. The team has a wealth of experience in this area.’

‘Andrew Oldland KC is an exceptional team leader with the gravitas and experience to reassure clients and pursue a comprehensive and highly effective case strategy.’

‘Scott Love is hardworking and bright, with excellent communication skills with clients, experts and counsel.’

Key clients

Clinton Devon Estates


W Stevenson & Sons Ltd


Saba Park Services


Work highlights


  • Advising Clinton Devon Estates following a fatal accident on one of its farms, advising and representing CDE from the outset of the police and HSE investigations into the case.
  • Representing W Stevenson & Son Ltd. in respect of investigations by the police, HSE, MCA & MAIB into two separate incidents where fatalities occurred.
  • Advising Saba Park Services following a fatality at one of its NHS car parks leading to an investigation and inquest.