Commercial litigation: Hampshire in South East
Blake Morgan LLP's commercial litigation team focuses on the healthcare, IT, manufacturing and retail sectors, where it advises public and private sector entities alike. Practice head Jill Bainbridge is the name to note for complex IP disputes and has significant experience of working on cross-border matters. Susie Dryden, who 'picks out the key issues and gets to the heart of the matter', has a longstanding role as intervention agent for the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Legal director Michael Colledge joined from Russell-Cooke LLP.
Other key lawyers:
Susie Dryden; Ben Evans; Dan Geddes
‘A friendly and approachable team that works well with in-house lawyers‘.
‘Deeply experienced and highly committed‘.
‘Jill Bainbridge is a stand-out partner and expert in her field. She is great with clients and always ready to discuss and progress the matter at hand‘.
‘Ben Evans is excellent, helpful, knowledgeable and approachable‘.
‘Dan Geddes succeeds in ‘boiling down’ his advice into clear options and a recommendation. This makes it far more straightforward for us to make the best decision and get on with running the business‘.
Solicitors Regulation Authority
CSC Computer Sciences
Sutton and East Surrey Water
- Representing NHS England in a judicial review challenge by a provider of screening services claiming that commissioned services cannot deviate from service specification.
- Acted for Ace Hosting as defendant in a multi-media and copyright infringement claim regarding streaming of content.
- Representing Shard Financial Medial as claimant in an IP professional negligence claim.
- Advising Sutton and East Surrey Water on issues ranging from contracts and negligence to IP.
- Advising Sail Week Croatia on a longrunning dispute with a competitor in both UK and EU IPO proceedings.
Womble Bond Dickinson (UK) LLP's commercial dispute resolution practice takes a 'no-nonsense and hands-on approach'. In addition to having a full-service litigation offering, the firm has a specialist arbitration arm, which features in high-value international arbitrations. The retail industry is an area of activity for the team, as are the media, technology and manufacturing sectors. Ian Newcombe is a specialist in the energy sector. Gavin Matthews leads the firm's retail focus group and is recommended for trading disputes. Andrew Parsons is an expert in data protection and IT issues.
‘The team’s knowledgeable lawyers offer pragmatic advice and understand in-house dynamics and requirements‘
‘A no-nonsense and hands-on approach is accompanied by a strong eye for detail‘
‘Truly understand the client’s business needs‘
‘Ian Newcombe offers a pragmatic perspective on a variety of commercial issues; his advice is never purely theoretical and is risk-sensitive‘
‘Ian Newcombe and Andy Parsons are very impressive‘
B&Q and the wider Kingfisher Group
- Defending Post Office against a group action brought by over 500 claimants alleging that the client’s IT accounting system, Horizon, is defective.
- Acting for Endeavour Energy in a £9m dispute with its joint venture partner Hess concerning which company is liable for paying the costs of a rig undertaking decommissioning works in the North Sea.
- Acting for Old Mutual International in the recovery of a loan of over £1m lent to Thomas Fewtrell and International Financial Services.
IT and technology-related disputes are major growth areas for Coffin Mew LLP; the firm handles a significant number of multijurisdictional trade mark infringement cases, passing-off claims and domain name disputes in this space. With the firm being able to work across offices, the 'highly motivated and committed' Southampton team regularly handles construction and property disputes originated elsewhere. Team head Ian Dawes specialises in European and international disputes.
Other key lawyers:
Imperial Car Supermarkets
The British Society of Echocariography
Hungry House Holdings
James Hay Partnership
Irwin Mitchell, which is highly active in matters with a cross-border component, is highly regarded by high net worth individuals, multinational companies and other household name clients. It has a notable focus on the sports, media, manufacturing, technology and financial services sectors. Hannah Clipston is an expert in breach of contract cases and associated complex tortious matters, with an industry specialism in sport and leisure. Associate Stephanie Reeves is also recommended.
Other key lawyers:
Rob Coleridge; Stephanie Reeves
‘The team were very dedicated and went the extra mile to ensure a successful outcome‘.
‘Simply excellent service‘.
‘Stephanie Reeves is thorough and thoughtful‘.
‘Stephanie Reeves negotiates in a calm and authoritative manner; her tenacity was vital to our success‘.
Id Verde UK
- Supported a US owned technology company with a multi-million pound complex breach of confidence claim in the Business and Property Courts of England and Wales.
- Acting for a limited company in respect of a multi-party, multi-jurisdictional contractual dispute.
- Acted for a limited company in respect of a difficult shareholder dispute involving allegations of underpaid dividends by the Company in excess of £1.6m by an individual shareholder.
- Acting for a large group of companies in relation to their dispute risk management issues and strategies on an ongoing basis.
- Acting for a limited company in relation to various claims brought against it by a former officer.
Paris Smith LLP has had a significant increase in debt recovery mandates recently, with the firm having added a number of new asset-based lenders to its client roster. Another key growth area has been recruitment sector work; the firm acts for over 140 recruitment agencies. Team head Christopher Holliss has extensive experience of complex commercial litigation at the High Court. Former Slater Heelis LLP litigation head Helen Brown joined the firm in January 2019.
David Eminton (head of department and head of property litigation); Christopher Holliss (head of commercial litigation); Mike Pavitt (head of insolvency); Cliff Morris (head of regulatory litigation); Jason Oliver (head of contentious tax and probate)
Other key lawyers:
Nicola Davies; Christina Spiers
ABP (Port of Southampton)
Corporate Asset Solutions
Neyland Yacht Haven
Halo Corporate Finance
The Co-Operative Group
Smith & Williamson
Collas Crill (Jersey)
- Advised Gattaca on the pursuit of a disputed claim against a defendant company in Singapore with a quantum exceeding £120k.
- Assisted Neyland Yatch Haven with an appeal to the Welsh Minister to overturn Natural Resources Wales’ strict conditions that are imposed on the client’s marine dredging licences.
- Instructed by Corporate Asset Solutions to pursue corporate guarantors in the Republic of Ireland following the termination of a Master Lease Agreement.
- Successfully acted on behalf of a multinational recruitment agency in an action threatened by an outgoing board member and shareholder for alleged breaches of a consultancy agreement and unfair prejudice.
- Represented Quba in a dispute with a groundwork and construction company regarding works carried out by Quba’s client.
Shoosmiths LLP's risk and litigation services team was strengthened by the arrival of associate (and contentious insolvency specialist) Shelley White from Paris Smith LLP in November 2018. A large number of the group's contentious commercial mandates arise from the technology and financial services sectors. The automotive industry is another area of strength; newly promoted partner Jonathan Smart, who heads up the the Solent office's dispute resolution and compliance team, has a longstanding reputation in this space. Also notable is that the firm has a niche in high-value international civil fraud and conspiracy cases.
Other key lawyers:
Shelley White; Luke Coleborn; Ian Nobbs; Steven Eastley; Jade Souch
‘The team are straight to the point and respond in a timely manner’.
‘Very knowledgeable and always willing to assist’.
‘Jonathan Smart and Harry Warren provide an incredible service’.
‘Jonathan Smart is my go-to person; he is straight to the point and responsive’.
‘Solicitor Luke Coleborn is confident and communicative’.
‘Jonathan Smart is very knowledgeable, efficient and a joy to work with. He is incredibly approachable and gets to the key points quickly’.
‘New hire Shelley White has settled in quickly and strengthened the team’.
Thomas Cook Group
Royal Bank of Scotland
Honda Motor Europe
The White Company
British American Tobacco
British Car Auctions
Associated British Foods
- Acting for a leading insurance company in the defence of a £40 million claim alleging bribery, fraud and corruption claims at the High Court Commercial Court which arose from the bribery of a South Korean government official.
- Representing a leading PLC in its $22 million claim against a leading US technology company related to a business-critical loss of data.
- Acting for a leading software company in a £56 million IT dispute with IBM.
- Representing a leading mobile network operator in pursuing £2.3m in damages from a rival network operator.
- Defending a leading car manufacturer against a £1m multijurisdictional breach of contract claim.
A cornerstone of BDB Pitmans' practice involves handling insurance litigation; the firm has niche technical expertise in subrogated property damage claims for insurers, and it is also active in fraudulent insurance claims. Elsewhere, the team also regularly works on contentious commercial property matters and professional negligence cases. Insolvency litigation expert Rick Munro is the practice head. Alan Davies has more than 35 years of litigation experience.
Other key lawyers:
Alan Davies; Claire Collings; Sylvia Yendall
Red Funnel Group
CPJ Field & Co
- Represented SAGA as property insurer in a claim made against a statutory water undertaker arising from an escape of water causing a sinkhole to open up partly in the claimants’ driveway.
- Acted for Generali as the insurers of an Italian hotel in a lawsuit relating to the claimant sustaining a fall in a guest bathroom.
- Representing HCR in a possession claim concerning an agreement which purported to be a licence to occupy but was in fact an assured shorthold tenancy.
- Acted for SAGA as property insurer in a claim against the neighbor of the claimants’ property for extensive damage to the property by a fire caused by a discarded cigarette.
- Represent Generali as the insurers of an Italian cycle manufacturer of a bicycle which was subject to a product recall.
Clarke Willmott LLP's commercial disputes work includes complex contractual disputes, shareholder and partnership disputes, contested debt work, restrictive covenant disputes and professional negligence claims. Areas of sector expertise include retail and financial services. Greg Hughes acts for the likes of Sony, Bandai and Wiggle. Hughes co-heads the practice with experienced solicitor advocate Owen Williams. Associate Cathy Harris is another key figure in the group.
Owen Williams; Greg Hughes
Other key lawyers:
‘The team was friendly and truly passionate about understanding my business‘.
The Student Room Group
Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA)
- Successfully acted for Sony Europe in contest contesting the wrongful seizure of the client’s good by Brighton & Hove City Council from the premises of one of its franchised stores.
- Defending Chambers Design & Build from a £50k contractual claim brought by Travis Perkins seeking payment of goods supplied on account.
- Successfully acted for John Roffey as defendant in the strike out of a claim for the conversion of a premium Bentley car.
- Acting for a leading British watch retailer in pursuing claims for breach of contract and breach of confidence against the client’s website provider.
- Advising Marina Developments following the arrest of a vessel in its marina.
Rob Evans leads the commercial litigation department at Moore Blatch LLP. The team primarily handles commercial and IP-related disputes for larger SMEs, owner-managed businesses and entrepreneurial private clients. Disputes arising from corporate transactions are a key area of expertise, specifically warranty claims and restrictive covenant disputes. Claire Haverfield is recommended.
Other key lawyers:
Mark Osgood; Claire Haverfield; Andrew Reid; Marina Clinnick
‘The team is led by particularly strong commercial and highly technical lawyers in the shape of Mark Osgood and Sarah Watley along with Rob Evans. They are supported by a number of equally excellent technical more junior lawyers. They also have a relatively unique litigation funding offering called Escalate’.
‘Mark Osgood is a good technical lawyer, extremely commercial and brilliant at dealing with clients and opponents alike’.
‘Sarah Watley is a very good technical lawyer, also very robust and commercial’.
‘Andrew Reid is one of the brightest and most technically able solicitors I have come across. A real details person. Also good tactically, in litigation’.
- Representing Creative Flooring in a contractual dispute arising from a joint enterprise with a national supplier of construction materials; the claim is worth over £3m.
- Asssisted Swiftime with recovery of significant debt paid by the client to a property developer, where the property developer then suffered significant losses following the crash in 2008.
Having joined Trethowans LLP from Blake Morgan LLP in January 2018, Karl Cameron now heads up the firm's commercial litigation department, which has a 'strong reputation in Hampshire'. It regular collaboration with the firm's corporate practice provides a steady flow of transaction-derived litigation. There has also been a notable increase in property litigation mandates. Elsewhere, the group works on construction disputes, professional negligence cases and contentious insolvency matters. Richard Cook is recommended for contract claims and shareholder disputes.
Other key lawyers:
‘What makes them different is the city experience they have at partner level combined with their approachability and and commercial common sense. They are my first port of call for referring clients when there is a conflict of interest‘.
‘Richard Cook is excellent and boasts extensive experience in the city and at national firms. He has a strong gut feel for the strength of a case and the right way to play it. He rarely, if ever, loses at trial. I refer conflicts to him with complete confidence‘.
‘The litigation team, headed by Richard Cook, has exemplary performance, solving issues in a timely and professional manner’.
Industrial Cleaning &Equipment
The Taylor Cocks Partnership
Ministry of Defence
- Acted for GreatStar Europe in a dispute with Edge Tools & Equipment over the alleged breach of a contract to source and supply JCB-branded blades and other tools.
- Representing a Southampton-based taxi company in a defamation claim brought by a former shareholder.
- Acting for a firm of insolvency consultants in two connected disputes concerning monies due in respect of professional fees.
- Representing Halo Corporate Finance in issuing a claim against Design Venue and Mr Moseley for breach of contract and fraud.
- Acting for Berry Telecom Limited as a part 20 defendant/claimant to a claim by Salar and Mimosa Food for breach of contract.