Frequently instructed by leading US firms and multinational companies to advise on the Scottish law elements of international projects, Brodies LLP places an equal emphasis on IT disputes and non-contentious mandates, with notable strength in the retail, financial services, entertainment and public sectors. Although the group has seen an uptick in complex data protection issues and projects concerning new technologies, the group - which is jointly led by Grant Campbell and Martin Sloan - excels in commercial contracts, technology procurements and large outsourcing matters. Iain Rutherford has expertise in IT and outsourcing disputes, acting both for customers and suppliers.
IT and telecoms in Scotland
Grant Campbell; Martin Sloan
Other key lawyers:
‘Team has an unsurpassed knowledge of our company.’
‘Truly exceptional team led by our service partner Grant Campbell, who is always available, provides thought through commercial advice and if matters become adversarial in negotiations he has a superb manner to ensure our interests are protected without any escalation of sensitivities.’
‘The Brodies team are great to work with, understand the challenges we face and take a start-up approach to helping us tackle them. By utilising this approach we get to a solution faster and with better outcomes.’
‘Martin Sloan and his team aren’t afraid of tackling big problems or finding solutions that go against the norm. In our industry this is vital to long term success.’
‘Brodies have advised us on a number of commercial contracts over the past 12 months as well as doing a considerable amount of work advising us on data protection matters / GDPR and also some IP matters.’
‘For commercial contracts, data issues etc, we use Grant Campbell. Can’t speak highly enough of Grant and his approach. His advice is pragmatic, commercial and very user-friendly.’
Capgemini UK plc
Rewards 4 Group
- Advised Accel-KKR on the acquisition of Navtor, a world leader in navigational software in the maritime industry.
- Advising City Facilities Management (FL) LLC on extensions to its master services agreements with 7-Eleven Inc and Southeastern Grocers Inc, covering retail stores in the State of Florida.
- Advised Rewards4 on establishing its first club-specific loyalty scheme for English Premiership Club, Everton FC.
Exhibiting ‘excellent knowledge across a range of commercial disciplines’, Burness Paull LLP provides clients with deep expertise in contracting and advisory work, IT disputes, as well as IT-related transactional work. Leveraging the firm’s membership of Lex Mundi, a significant proportion of the group's matters contain complex cross-border components. Particularly active in the financial services, public and utilities sectors, the department is fronted by Callum Sinclair, who shines in high-value technology, sourcing and enterprise cloud deals. Elsewhere, David Goodbrand emphasises financial services and fintech work, advising clients on a variety of digital transformation, data migration, outsourcing and cloud deals, whereas contentious IT specialist Colin Hulme handles software and technology agreement disputes.
Other key lawyers:
David Goodbrand; Colin Hulme; Murray Cree
‘The team members that I have worked with have all been knowledgeable in their key area of focus, accommodating of the changing nature of contract negotiations on a key project, willing to go the extra mile to assist and generally wonderful to work with.’
‘They brought expert knowledge to the project. Their negotiation skills were very good with a great mix of legal expertise but also business savvy. You can always rely on them to meet a deadline and their communication, sometimes daily, was excellent.’
‘Competent and commercial. Good reach internationally despite relative small size (on global terms).’
‘The team at Burness Paull has invested considerably in understanding our growing business, taking a longer-term view where other firms would not have done so. The people in the team are universally highly capable and also human and empathetic enough to understand the pressures my team is under.’
‘David Goodbrand is highly responsive and very adaptable. He has invested in understanding our business and risk posture such that his advice is always pragmatic and well-formed.’
‘Callum Sinclair is incredibly passionate about technology, broader than just being a lawyer. He is very knowledgeable in the developments in his field of expertise which he is more than willing to share to ensure that we are kept up to date.’
‘The team has excellent knowledge across a range of commercial disciplines, and has strength and depth to be able to provide the appropriate resource as and when required.’
‘Callum Sinclair is a very pragmatic individual to deal with, and always provides clear and considered advice.’
Scottish Futures Trust / Scotland 5G Centre
Calnex Solutions plc
Vodafone / Cornerstone
ZPG Group (uSwitch, Zoopla)
Financial Services Compensation Scheme
- Instructed by Scottish Futures Trust (an innovation offshoot of the Scottish Government), to help it to establish the new Scotland 5G Centre with accelerating the deployment and adoption of 5G throughout Scotland.
- Advising Calnex Solutions plc on its £42m IPO on the London AIM market and its associated £6m equity fundraising; this included a full review of the company’s contracts, including customer, supplier and partner contracts.
- Acted for ZPG Group, and its comparison division RVU, on a variety of technology contracting and advisory work, including some cutting edge advisory/contract work on the new Platform 2 Business (P2B / OIS) Regulation.
Renowned in the financial services and the public and education sectors in particular, CMS handles a broad array of IT-related mandates. On the cutting edge of matters pertaining to emerging technologies and data protection, the practice is instructed by a slew of high-profile banks, fintech companies, financial services suppliers, and retailers, as well as the NHS and various universities. It handles an assortment of matters relating to complex commercial contracts, IT procurements, outsourcing projects, acquisitions of IT software, and system and IT service agreements. Alan Nelson and Duncan Turner jointly lead the group, which also includes Douglas Mathie, who demonstrates know-how in IT issues relating to ATMs and the processing of card payments; and senior associate Caroline Connolly, whose practice largely focuses on large, complex transactions with multijurisdictional dimensions.
Alan Nelson; Duncan Turner
Other key lawyers:
Caroline Connolly; Douglas Mathie
‘ Local team operating within a large international network with access to extensive resources.’
‘A real depth of experience in technology and its application to different sectors.’
‘Alan Nelson is a leader in his field. Douglas Mathie is an experienced technology lawyer with a practical approach.’
‘Alan Nelson really knows his stuff and is great at getting a sensible deal that protects us but is balanced. He is always available to provide insight and valuable guidance.’
Scottish and Southern Energy Networks
Quorate Technology Limited
NHS National Services Scotland (NSS)
Cerebreon Technologies Limited
Isio Group Limited
Edinburgh St James
- Advised the City of Edinburgh Council on all IT outsourcing contracts including the provision of a replacement ERP system as it enters into six-year extension with CGI.
- Assisted Scottish and Southern Energy Networks in relation to a contract for the development of new systems for (i) a neutral market facilitator platform and (ii) a whole system coordinator system.
- Advised NatWest on the refresh of its LAN and WiFi Service arrangements, across the whole NatWest (former RBS) group.
Noted for its routine involvement in high-profile deals arising from the financial services, public sector and utility sectors, the team at DLA Piper brings an integrated UK offering to bear on large infrastructure projects. It is spearheaded by John McKinlay, whose 'depth of knowledge and understanding of technology law is excellent'; he advises a spread of corporations and public sector organisations on large outsourcings and complex technology transactions. At senior associate level, Linzi Penman regularly handles global data protection compliance projects, while Catriona Melton has extensive experience advising clients on commercial issues, including regulatory compliance matters.
Other key lawyers:
Catriona Melton; Linzi Penman
‘The team carries, quite rightly, a high reputation for expertise in the Technology space. Led expertly by John McKinlay, whose expertise is widely noted through acting as chairperson for the technology law and practice Committee with the Law Society of Scotland.’
‘DLA Piper are able to tackle technology-related legal issues globally having offices in over 40 countries.’
‘I have worked closely with John McKinlay, whose depth of knowledge and understanding of technology law is excellent. John’s calm demeanour and understanding of the legal nuances of technology law helps clients feel they are being supported by a safe pair of hands.’
‘I instruct people, rather than firms. I use DLA Piper because of the client service and commercial advice I receive from John McKinlay and his team.’
‘We like dealing with John McKinlay. He is hands on, responsive and good to deal with. We also like the fact that DLA has an office in Edinburgh and access to offices and teams throughout the world.’
‘Clear leaders in IT/IP with exceptional knowledge and experience. Very quick responses and they combine commercial, pragmatic problem solving with first class professional skills.’
‘They totally understand how best to support in-house lawyers and the pressures we face.’
‘John McKinlay is our main contract and is extremely impressive. He is unflappable and always available and reliable. He has guided us through some very large outsourcing procurements for IT services, cyber security and mobile communications. He is primarily supported by Linzi Penman who has a lot of experience with our Digital directorate and has an unsurpassed knowledge of our outsourced IT services.’
Scottish Power Energy Retail Limited
The Highland Council
Hyve Group plc
- Advised renowned Scotland-based client, Scottish Water, throughout the competitive procurement for an eight year framework regarding next generation mobile and field connectivity services.
- Leading negotiations with Salesforce on behalf of Scottish Water in respect of its cloud computing service.
- Advising Merlin Entertainments on the implementation and provision of a cloud-based food and beverage point of sale system to harmonise operations across Merlin’s restaurants and cafes in the UK and in Europe.
Pinsent Masons LLP
'Technically excellent and super pragmatic', the TMT offering at Pinsent Masons LLP, which features a dedicated TMT disputes sub-group, flourishes in the financial services, education and energy sectors in particular. Within financial services, practice lead Yvonne Dunn is particularly skilled at handling cloud, open finance and artificial intelligence matters in the fintech space. Data trust expert Chris Martin’s practice centres on the energy and education sectors, in which he regularly assists high-profile energy suppliers, as well as university clients, on large TMT projects. As evidence of the firm’s continued growth in the information law space, the 'outstanding' Kathryn Wynn was promoted to partner in May 2020.
Other key lawyers:
Matthew Godfrey-Faussett; Chris Martin; David Woods; Kathryn Wynn
‘Matthew Godfrey-Faussett has been a consistent collaborator on a major change programme and has been instrumental in ensuring our commercial contract with our principal software supplier was fit-for-purpose and that a wide range of scenarios were applied to its development.’
‘The team are really proactive; this is immensely helpful for an in-house team swept off our feet. They helped us with a particular matter, then frequently and concisely raised relevant updates so we can stay ahead of developments. They are technically excellent and super pragmatic.’
‘Kathryn Wynn is outstanding. Her depth of data protection knowledge is immense; able to distil really complex principles to provide practical and clear guidance that helps cut through to the core.’
‘Deep regulatory expertise combined with commercial and pragmatic insights. All at reasonable rates.’
‘Yvonne Dunn is an expert and pragmatic outsourcing lawyer.’
‘My experience of working with this practice has been very positive – they have great experience with cloud service providers which proved useful in our most recent instruction.’
‘They recently supported two large and complicated IT procurements for us and helped us navigate through the complexity.’
‘Chris Martin is extremely responsive and knowledgeable.’
University of Edinburgh
Nucleus Financial Services
Allied Irish Bank
University of Southampton
PomVom UK Limited
Assurant General Insurance
Nucleus Financial Services Limited
- Advising PomVom on the UK and EU data protection issues associated with the use of facial recognition technology (“FRT”) in theme parks.
- Assisting Assurant with its Brexit plans, namely transferring certain parts of its insurance business where the risk is situated in a European Economic Area “EEA” state to new subsidiaries based in the Netherlands.
- Advised University of Edinburgh on its significant procurement of a new website platform, part of a strategic plan to transition all of the University’s internal and external facing web presence into the cloud.
Noted for its ability to ‘leverage the breadth of expertise in the firm in order to provide a holistic recommendation’, Addleshaw Goddard is increasingly active in digital transformation projects. Fintech expert David Anderson leads the group, which has considerable experience in data protection issues, as well as IT and BPAAS outsourcings, commercial contracts and tech-related litigation. Anderson also handles the IT and technology aspects of corporate investments and divestments, while Helena Brown's practice largely centres on data protection issues emanating from IT projects and contracts.
Other key lawyers:
Helena Brown; Ross McKenzie
‘In-depth market knowledge. Very responsive. Very practical.’
‘Helena Brown is easy to deal with and has knowledge across a number of industries.’
‘Helena and the team at Addleshaw Goddard offer us an invaluable data protection partnership and on-going support to ad hoc privacy issues.’
‘Diverse team with depth and experience in the Scottish market able to respond and react to any requirement or timeframe.’
‘Practical hands on understanding of technology and apply that to deals to focus on the right issues in getting a deal done.’
‘Use of and offers to use technology to drive efficiencies and improve processes ’
‘Dave Anderson understands key issues and acts commercially. Hugely responsive – he is available at any time and is willing to go the extra mile.’
FNZ (UK) Ltd
Boohoo Group plc
Mintra Training Portal
Symphonic Software Limited
CBS Business Consulting Ltd
OBR – Open Banking Reporting
Obashi Technologies Limited
- Advised FNZ on the negotiation of new master services agreements between FNZ and (i) a significant existing customer; and (ii) a new customer for the provision of investment transaction and administration services through its technology platform.
- Advising Boohoo Group on a range of data and IT-related issues.
- Advised Tumelo on all aspects of its ESG technology proposition as it integrates its software with investment and pension providers to help win new clients and increase assets under management by engaging underlying investors with transparency and influence over shareholder voting.
As part of the firm’s vast international network, the Scottish practice at Dentons, which is overseen by Alison Bryce, advises predominantly large multinational corporations on the full gamut of information technology agreements and projects. Key pillars of the group include IT software, hardware and systems procurement mandates, IT outsourcings, technology licensing issues, e-commerce matters and data protection work. Other practitioners to note are IP expert Ross Nicol and senior associate Julie Brown, who regularly handles technology-based contracts, including software licences and service level agreements.
Other key lawyers:
Ross Nicol; Julie Brown
‘The team have taken the time to get to know and understand our business and our team along with aligning themselves with our requirements and objectives. Despite being a third party provider, they now feel an extension of our internal team.’
‘Alison Bryce has been paramount to driving this approach and engaging with our company in such a manner that they feel part of our team. Alison’s counsel is always valued and we are only too pleased to continue working with Alison and the wider team.’
‘They are always extremely professional, proactive and responsive with evident domain expertise and good broader industry knowledge and very pleasant indeed to work with.’
‘We work mainly with both Alison Bryce (Partner) and Julie Brown (Senior Associate) and find them both to be excellent at all times, providing pragmatic and considered advice and drafting on a prompt and reliable timeline.’
Artos Systems Limited
Marks and Spencer PLC
MUFG Securities EMEA plc
STV Group plc
Bank of Tokyo
The John Lewis Partnership (including Waitrose Limited)
The Marsden Group Inc.
- Advised MUFG Securities EMEA plc/ Bank of Tokyo, a leading Japanese financial services institution, on business-critical software licences and cloud platforms.
- Assisted Artos Systems Limited with an innovative deal with FanDragon Technologies, a company which is seeking to reimagine the global ticket distribution business via a Software as a Service platform that brings control and transparency back to ticket rights holders.
- Advising a major UK Retailer on its payment services agreement relating to in-store and online payments.
Overseen by David Gourlay, MacRoberts LLP's practice has carved out a reputation in acting for the Scottish government and central and local public sector bodies, with particular expertise in public procurement rules as they apply to the tender of IT services. The group also advises on outsourcings, software developments, cloud computing issues, software licensings, hardware supplies, service level agreements, open-source software matters and cybersecurity mandates. Other names to note are social media and data protection expert Valerie Armstrong-Surgenor and Euan Duncan, who frequently handles IT-related contracts.
Other key lawyers:
Valerie Armstrong-Surgenor; Euan Duncan
‘MacRoberts’ IT & telecoms team provided support and assistance on all aspects of our IT contracts. The team were highly experienced in this area of law and really understood the details of our complex requirements.’
‘Euan Duncan was involved in all matters relating to IT and telecoms and provided first class legal advice. Euan was always on hand to assist wherever possible and was supported by a team of experts.’
AEGON Asset Management UK plc
Scottish Police Authority/Police Scotland
Vascutek Limited (trading as Terumo Aortic)
AutoRek (API Software) Limited
- Advising the Scottish Police Authority / Police Scotland on its digitally enabled policing project.
- Advised Vascutek Limited (trading as Terumo Aortic) on a number of software procurements and reviewed, drafted and negotiated licensing terms with suppliers.
- Advised Aperta on exit plan arrangements with a key client (Nationwide), escrow arrangements with Central Bank of India, a software integrator agreement with LexisNexis Risk Solutions, a software licencing agreement with RBC Financial and acted in a dispute with the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia regarding a bond related to a software supply contract.
Shepherd and Wedderburn
Paul Carlyle leads the practice at Shepherd and Wedderburn, which acts for clients throughout the UK on IT mandates, e-commerce work, telecoms issues and technology investments. The group also has expertise in technology procurements and outsourcings.
Harper Macleod LLP's team, which is presided over by Tom Thomas, advises key public sector bodies and companies on the adoption and procurement of large-scale ICT services. Additionally, it routinely handles outsourcing transactions, data protection issues, as well as IT-related disputes. Scott Kerr specialises in the food and drink, life sciences and technology sectors, dealing primarily with distribution, agency and franchise contracts. Jill Fryer, meanwhile, focuses on public procurement projects containing IT components.
Other key lawyers:
Scott Kerr; Jamie Watt; Jill Fryer
‘Good understanding of technology and innovation, the team keep themselves up to date with new products and services and the likely impact on our business.’
‘Tom Thomas has been available at anytime, always responded quickly and with detail and sensitive to the pressures that have ebbed and flowed throughout the works. Explained difficult clauses and topics in easy to understand ways, allowing myself to make confident decisions on big items that I would otherwise feel were above my ability to make.’
Historic Environment Scotland
Registers of Scotland
Community Energy Scotland
Oh Polly Ltd
Enduro Sports Organisation Limited
Blackwood Homes and Care
UK Athletics Limited
- Advised Blackwood Homes and Care on the terms of its agreement with the software developer in relation to CleverCogs, including on the data protection issues arising as well as drafting the ancillary end-user licences for residents and care providers.
- Advising the Capital City Partnership on a number of procurement procedures to support initiative aims, including the procurement of a website partner and the procurement of a website to facilitate the achievement of community benefits.
- Advised Scottish Borders Housing Association on the procurement of a cloud-based finance and purchase to pay (P2P) system, including drafting of the underlying agreement between SBHA and the successful bidder.
Thorntons Law LLP
Liam McMonagle leads the team at Thorntons Law LLP, which acts for both sellers and buyers in the deployment of IT projects. It is retained by a variety of software and cloud companies, IT service providers and universities as well as large corporate buyers. Recently, the group has recorded an increase in instructions concerning data protection and information security work; associate Neil Falconer specialises in cybersecurity projects.
Other key lawyers:
Lesley Larg; Alistair Lang; Neil Falconer
‘The team took the time to understand our business and get to know our main service offerings which contributed to a practical approach during commercial negotiations and meaningful input on the actual legal risks involved in our transactions. Proficient in dealing with variety of licensing models and extremely savvy on the data protection front.’
‘The team’s assertiveness and commercial mindset helped us navigate the legal complexity of multi-party negotiations successfully.’
‘The team we use at Thorntons LLP are first class. We have used them for a number of years and will continue to do so.’
‘Liam McMonagle is excellent.’
ECS Europe Limited
Postcode Lottery Limited
brightsolid Online Technology Limited
University of Abertay
ECS Digital Limited
- Advised ThinkAnalytics on key collaborations and partnerships with global content providers including the BBC, Tata Sky, Liberty Global, Deutsche Telekom and others.
- Advising Ionburst on all of its intellectual property and IT matters, including advice on a number of licence agreements, in relation to intellectual property protection and exploitation strategy and in relation to research and development activities.