Firms To Watch: Professional negligence

Following the 2023 closure of Kyriakides & Braier, London firm Freeman Harris took on that firm's professional negligence practice, led by Avi Gordon, who acts exclusively for claimants.
Hill Dickinson LLP made a notable London hire in mid-2023 with the addition of Hamlins LLP disputes head Amanda Burge , whose expertise covers construction professional negligence cases.
Wordley Partnership was founded in early 2019 by a group of ex-HFW  partners; the firm handles claims against professionals including solicitors and brokers.

Professional negligence in London

Clyde & Co

Clyde & Co has an unmatched reputation for professional negligence matters. The firm’s client base includes a number of leading legal and accountancy firms, in addition to numerous property consultants and major contractors. The firm has professional liability specialists on every continent, and regularly works on claims which cross international borders. Richard Harrison heads the firm’s global law firm liability, regulatory, investigations and discipline group, and is the immediate past chair of the IBA’s Regulation of Lawyers’ Compliance Committee. James Roberts is head of the accountants’ liability, regulatory, and disciplinary group, and acts for the UK’s leading accountancy and audit firms. Richard Moody has more than thirty years’ experience in the defence of construction professional indemnity claims and related insurance disputes. Sarah Clover is highly experienced in the practice area, and is the key contact for major domestic and international clients.

Practice head(s):

Richard Harrison; James Roberts; Richard Moody


Other key lawyers:

Sarah Clover; Jonathan Brown; Bryn Hodges; Helen Rowlands; Fergal Cathie; Jane Williams; Tom White; Tim Crockford; Penrose Foss; Rowena Lewis; Rob Crossingham; Niya Phiri; Alexander Traill; Andrew Forsyth; Elizabeth Moore; Lucy Murphy; Jonathan Lawrence; Michael Clark; Simon Casey; Claire Harpur; Laurel Forde; Hannah Merriam; Nick Benson


Testimonials

‘Simply the best: in terms of strength in depth at all levels of seniority; experience; and talent. The Rolls-Royce firm for professional negligence work.’

‘The team has broad expertise across a number of areas.’

‘Helen Rowlands is excellent and on top of the detail. She is also a great team player.’

Key clients

KPMG


Withers LLP


Evelyn Partners


Mott Macdonald


Work highlights


  • Acted for the client in a regulatory and disciplinary proceedings by the FRC over KPMG’s audit failure to notice any problems with Carillion prior to Carillion’s collapse.
  • Acted for Withers in the defence of two related claims brought by property developers in respect of advice from the firm’s real estate team, and a claim brought by a high net worth individual in respect of advice provided to him by the firm’s family law team.
  • Defended Evelyn and four of its partners in relation to their conduct of the administration and sale of a high profile, collapsed Tech Unicorn company.

Herbert Smith Freehills LLP

Herbert Smith Freehills LLP has is instructed on numerous high-level instructions from leading firms. The firm also has a strong financial sector presence, reflected by a client list which includes numerous major banks, including National Australia Bank and UBS. William Glassey is experienced in defending solicitors, barristers, pensions actuaries, and property professionals in diverse subject matters. Paul Lewis specialises in disputes involving solicitors, insurance brokers, and pensions advisors. Sarah McNally regularly advises clients in construction, infrastructure, energy, and so forth. Antonia Pegden specialises in technical pensions and solicitor’s professional negligence.

Practice head(s):

William Glassey; Paul Lewis


Other key lawyers:

Sarah McNally; Antonia Pegden; Alexander Oddy; Tristan Smith


Testimonials

‘The Herbert Smith Freehills professional negligence team are excellent. They’re a pleasure to work with, technically and tactically brilliant, not afraid of the detail.’

‘Will Glassey is technically and tactically brilliant. Proactive, resourceful and quickly gets stuck into the details. Will is an excellent lawyer and a trusted adviser.’

‘Will Glassey is rightly highly rated in professional negligence / regulatory matters, and brings to bear his great experience in the sector for clients. I have complete comfort that there is no waffling, and he brings real authority to the case. He knows the law and regulation (and the nuances), he knows the people (barristers / opposing firm) and the regulator (the SRA).’

Key clients

National Australia Bank


UBS


Marsh


Work highlights


  • Advising National Australia Bank Limited in relation to a group claim brought by over 800 Claimants in 8 separate claims, alleging, amongst other things, fraudulent misrepresentation and deceit.
  • Defending a group of claims which are being case managed together. Around 514 claimants are advancing claims against the Ingenious Media group and financial intermediaries – 51 of these Claimants have advanced claims against UBS.
  • Defending Andrew Thornhill KC in a claim brought by 110 individuals who invested in tax-driven film finance schemes called Scotts Atlantic in 2002 to 2004.

Beale & Co

Beale & Co is a specialist professional negligence boutique, with one of the largest dedicated teams in the UK. The firm receives regular instructions from numerous major professional indemnity insurers, including Aviva, Chubb, and RSA, among others. Peter Sewell is the sole legal advisor to the Lloyd’s Market Association’s International Professional Liability Business Panel, while Antony Smith has an impressive construction related record internationally. Sheena Sood has almost thirty years of diverse experience in the construction sector. Finally, Ross Baker, Martin Jensen, and Jason McNerlin are all impressive practitioners in construction professional negligence.

Practice head(s):

Peter Sewell; Antony Smith; Sheena Sood; Ross Baker; Martin Jensen; Jason McNerlin


Other key lawyers:

Michael Salau; Eileen Pathiraja; Keith Lonsdale; Nathan Modelll; Ian Masser


Testimonials

‘Beale & Co have a very collaborative approach to involving counsel in their cases. They are hard-working and responsive, and it is clear that their young lawyers are well-supported and trained. Dealing with a whole team that can ‘see’ the endgame and doggedly keep looking for answers is a pleasure.’

‘Beale & Co are tough litigators. They leave no stone unturned in achieving the best result for the client. Their legal analysis is second to none. They have particular expertise on the construction side.’

‘In general terms, what strikes the eye in relation to Beale & Co is that every fee earner in the department – from partner to associate – is prepared to give their utmost to seek to secure the best outcome for the client. Their passion and commitment is second to none.’

‘Extensive understanding of the construction industry and a long history of acting for professional consultants. Understand the challenges from a consultant’s perspective. Provision of an in-house disputes service for both contentious and non-contentious work. Always willing to go above and beyond the day to day with training and broader collaborative opportunities.’

‘Their advice is considered and tailored – easy to say yes to. Both work well with our wider business and comes up with creative/out of the box solutions.’

‘Beale & Co is an excellent practice that stands out in the insurance (professional negligence) landscape. What sets them apart is their unwavering commitment to excellence, and their ability consistently to deliver outstanding results. Clients can have full confidence that Beale & Co will navigate any complex legal challenges.’

‘Ross Baker is a standout insurance solicitor who has great knowledge and expertise, and decades of experience in the area. Ross’s advice is always first-rate, no matter how urgent or complex the problem that his client faces. As proactive as they come, Ross’s approach to client care is to be admired.’

‘Incisive and responsive team, whom I find work very well with counsel in a collaborative way.’

Key clients

Aviva Insurance UK Ltd


RSA Insurance Group


Arup Group Ltd


Jacobs UK Limited


AmTrust Europe


Hardy Underwriting Asia Pte Ltd (CNA Hardy)


Kier Group


Chubb Insurance


Atkins Limited


Channel Syndicate


Hamilton Syndicate


Work highlights


CMS

CMS acts in professional negligence matters across a diverse range of industries, including construction, financial services, and insurance, across multiple jurisdictions. Team lead Ed Foss has deep experience in insurance brokers and employee benefit consultant's liability work, as well as litigation of insurance broker’s liability issues. Foss is experienced acting across numerous jurisdictions, including the US, EU, and South America. Martin Fox specialises in construction professional indemnity claims, and acts for clients at all levels in high-stakes claims. Simon Garrett is highly regarded for insurance and reinsurance litigation, and represents clients who are being investigated by the Financial Reporting Council and Lloyds of London. Other standout individuals include Monica Lesny, Tristan Hall, and Thomas Pangbourne.

Practice head(s):

Ed Foss


Other key lawyers:

Martin Fox; Simon Garrett; Alex Denslow; Alaina Wadsworth; Scarlett West; Amit Tyagi; Chris Bradshaw; Andrew Milne; Amy Ramsay


Testimonials

‘They are a relationship practice – they will listen to your needs and adapt their services accordingly. They are also unpretentious and quickly put you at ease.’

‘Expert knowledge comes as standard. Individuals have listened to our needs over time and have adapted their services accordingly. Scarlett West is happy to get on the phone and talk through the proposed strategy – unphased by any queries or ‘challenges’ to the suggested approach – rather than only ever communicating by email.’

Key clients

Antares


Arch


Berkshire Hathaway


HDI Global


WRB


The Griffin Insurance Association


SCOR


Everest Re


QBE


CNA Hardy


Markel


Axis


Hamilton


AXA XL


Beazley


Liberty


Euclid


ANV


Canopius


Riverstone


Premia Re


The Hartford


Allianz


Brockwell Capital


CFC


Aspen


Zurich


Brit


Generali


Talbot


Nexus


Azets


Hays MacIntyre


Novia Financial plc


Rathbones


James Hallam


Seventeen Group


Grant Thornton


Davies Group


Mazars


Embark Group


Faithful + Gould


Burnley Wilson Fish


Mitie


WSP


Spire


Ardmore Construction


Aon


Marsh


Ed Broking


The Ardonagh Group


Lockton


A J Gallaghers


Miles Smith


Work highlights


  • Defended S&S in a case where S&S were accused of acting in breach of confidence – the underlying facts were that part of S&S had acted for the Bank of London in respect of some regulatory work.
  • Acted for Aon in respect of allegations against it of negligence/breach of contract arising from the tragic air accident of 2016, when LaMia flight number 2933 crashed whilst on route from Viru Viru International Airport, Bolivia, to Jose Maria Cordova International Airport, Colombia.
  • Defended Miller Insurance Services in a high-profile and ongoing litigation in respect of the unfortunate death of Argentinian international footballer Emiliano Sala in a plane crash in January 2019.

DAC Beachcroft LLP

DAC Beachcroft LLP has strong teams in a diverse set of areas, including cyber, construction, and technology, as well as niche areas such as event cancellation. The department consistently defends claims against other leading firms, and works for nearly all lead insurers, including Zurich, Chubbs and RSA. Liam O’Connell specialises in contentious insurance matters, including policy coverage analysis and domestic and international dispute resolution, while Patrick Hill has expertise in professional and financial lines, with a focus on cyber. Mark Roach has extensive experience in construction litigation, as well as in arbitration, adjudication, and mediation. Other notable individuals include Hans Allnutt, William Allison, and Richard Highley.

Practice head(s):

Liam O’Connell; Patrick Hill; Mark Roach; Hans Allnutt; William Allison; Richard Highley


Other key lawyers:

Julian Miller; Phillip Murrin; Parminder Badham; Matthew Olorenshaw; Andrew Crocombe


Testimonials

‘A great team. The team have deep knowledge of audit negligence disputes.’

‘Real market experts on all areas of professional negligence. Particularly strong on solicitors claims.’

‘Philip Murrin is outstanding.’

Key clients

Zurich


QBE


Chubb


Travelers


Munich Re


AIG


AXA XL


Beazley


Tokio Marine HCC


Aviva


Work highlights


  • Defended (successfully) a multi-million pound professional negligence claim which was brought against Clyde & Co solicitors in the High Court and in the Court of Appeal, with key judicial guidance given on the interpretation of release clauses in settlement agreements.
  • Representing the accountancy practice Haysmacintyre LLP in a significant professional negligence claim concerning its audit work for Bonnier Books UK and subsidiaries.
  • Defended (successfully) a multi-million pound claim brought against two former partners of Deloitte, concerning allegations of breach of duty by company administrators, following a trial lasting eight days.

HFW

HFW‘s team is composed of insurance, reinsurance, and litigation specialists, and is regularly instructed by the world’s largest insurance and reinsurance brokers. The firm offers expertise in both coverage and defence work. Christopher Foster, who leads the team, and is head of insurance, has a well-established profile in broker E&O claims and professional indemnity matters. Christopher Cardona, who is bilingual in English and Spanish, has a reputation for handling high-value litigation and arbitration in Latin America. Rupert Warren has a particular expertise in professional indemnity insurance, and combines ‘very good legal and technical insurance skills’ with ‘the empathy that is often required to understand what has gone wrong and why.Jonathan Bruce is a leading name for energy and marine insurance matters.

Practice head(s):

Christopher Foster


 


Other key lawyers:

Christopher Cardona; Jonathan Bruce; Rupert Warren


Testimonials

‘HFW’s insurance professional negligence team is one part of their highly respected insurance and reinsurance practice. It is an excellent team, and includes individuals such as Chris Foster and Rupert Warren, who are, in my view, among the best in this field in London.’

‘I have worked with Rupert Warren for many years on numerous insurance-related professional negligence matters. He is superb in this area – has a really strong understanding of how such problems arise, and how to resolve them. Highly recommended in this field.’

‘Excellent, highly capable team.’

‘Rupert Warren – a very clever lawyer.’

Work highlights


Hogan Lovells International LLP

Hogan Lovells International LLP is instructed by both claimants and defendants in professional negligence cases. The firm handles numerous large and highly complex multi-jurisdictional matters, and is well respected for its expertise in relation to pension schemes. These are a particular area of strength for practice head, Nicholas Heaton. Angela Dimsdale Gill is experienced in acting for both claimants and defendants, and is routinely instructed in matters which with the potential to cause serious reputational damage. Matthew Bullen is experienced in advising clients in relation to claims involving alleged negligent pensions administration services, while counsel Nathan Sherlock handles a range of pension scheme and trust fund disputes.

Practice head(s):

Nicholas Heaton


Other key lawyers:

Angela Dimsdale Gill; Matthew Bullen; Nathan Sherlock


Testimonials

‘Outstanding expertise and very charming and decent people. Always a real pleasure to deal with.’

‘Hogan Lovells deals with a wide range of professional negligence cases, many of which involve large sums at risk as well as potential damage to reputation. Working with the team at Hogan Lovells, I have found their approach to be focused, professional and practical.’

‘Angela Dimsdale Gill has extensive experience in acting on professional negligence cases, whether for the claimant or the defendant. Angela is widely recognised as a leading figure in this field. Matthew Bullen also has wide experience in this field, as has Nathan Sherlock.’

‘ The Hogan Lovells pensions team prides itself on being involved in the most complex matters, which is undoubtedly true.’

‘Nicholas Heaton is fantastic. Technically superb, he is equally adept with the detail and the big picture, and never loses sight of what the client wants and what capital the other side might make of certain litigation decisions. Angela Dimsdale-Gill is a doughty opponent and will fight her client’s case tenaciously, while Matthew Bullen is bright and energetic.’

‘Exceptional partner commitment and tremendous attention to detail.’

‘Matthew Bullen is the most hard-working and committed solicitor I know.’

‘The team is comprised of very good litigators, who have great experience dealing with professional negligence cases, and a particular specialisation in relation to professional negligence in a pensions context. Angela Dimsdale Gill is vastly experienced, having handled some of the biggest and high-profile pension disputes in the past couple of decades.’

Key clients

ENRC


BAT Industries


Work highlights


  • Acting for ENRC in the precedent-setting and widely reported proceedings against its former solicitors, Dechert LLP, former Dechert partner Neil Gerrard, and the UK Serious Fraud Office.
  • Representing BAT in high-profile $800m auditor negligence claims against PriceWaterhouseCoopers.
  • Advising the trustee of a UK pension scheme in relation to potential negligence claims against a major international law firm valued in excess of £600m.

Kennedys

Kennedys is an international practice which is particularly renowned for its coverage and defence work, regularly acting for professional insured clients. The firm sits on all major insurance panels, including those of Zurich, Aviva, and Markel. Jeremy Riley heads the firm’s UK PI team, while Christopher Butler and Paul Carter lead the London and wider UK Construction PI practices subgroup. Fleur Rochester focuses on cases involving financial professionals, brokers, and construction disputes. Paul Castellani has over twenty years of experience in handling complex professional negligence claims which involve multiple parties. Other notable individuals include Martin Chesher, Simon Gibson, Tim Hague, and David Robinson.

Practice head(s):

Jeremy Riley


Other key lawyers:

Paul Carter; Paul Castellani; Martin Chesher; Matt Deaville; Simon Gibson; Fleur Rochester; Paul Lowe; Christopher Butler; David Robinson; Tim Hague


Testimonials

The Kennedys team genuinely seem to care, and it makes them stand out. The juniors are content, and that says a lot about the people they are working for.’

‘Simon Gibson is the person I want to instruct when I require coverage advice. Simon is quite unique in his command of coverage principles, application and ability to reach an answer on a point clearly and decisively. Paul Castellani has an astonishing ability to absorb complex factual situations and simultaneously deliver masterful advice and strategy.’

‘Paul Castellani and David Robinson are the best professional negligence lawyers in the country. They are technically gifted, commercial, strategic and their advice is understandable and easy to follow (even in the most complex of claims). I have beyond 100% faith in their ability.’

Key clients

Aegis


AIG


Allianz


Allied World


Aqueous


Arch


Aviva


AXAI


AXA XL


Bar Mutual Indemnity Fund


Canopius


CNA Hardy


Dual Corporate Risks


IGI


Liberty


Munich Re


MS Amlin


Nexus


Pen


QBE


Riverstone


RSA


WR Berkley


Clegg Construction Limited


Colliers


Engie


Howard Kennedy


Irwin Mitchell


ISG Limited


Kane Group


Prater Limited and Lindner Exterior Holdings Limited


RG Carter


Rodgers Leask


Shearer Property Associates Limited


Terence O’Rourke Limited


Work highlights


  • Defended Irwin Mitchell in respect of a widely publicised case involving consideration of scope of duty and retainer arguments.
  • Advising Prater and its PI insurers in respect of a claim of £180M involving issues with the roof of one of the largest corporate office campuses in the world.
  • Defending a development manager in a claim valued at £70M in respect of the procurement and development of a substantial mixed-use project.

Mayer Brown International LLP

Mayer Brown International LLP's team is highly experienced in international and global matters, and has represented clients across North America, Europe, and Asia. The firm’s clients include numerous prominent law firms and accountancy practices. Practice head Jim Oulton is renowned for his work with insolvency practitioners, accountants, and auditors, while co-head Michael Regan is an expert in construction and engineering. Sally Davies specialises in claims in relation to construction and insurance, while Tim Shepherd has expertise in defending complex cases related to transactions.

Practice head(s):

Jim Oulton; Michael Regan


Other key lawyers:

Sally Davies; Jonathan Stone; James Morris; Tim Shepherd


Testimonials

‘An exceptional team, led by Jim Oulton with real class. They have strength and depth and no weak links.’

‘Jim Oulton has superb grasp of the detail and thinks issues through with thoroughness and intelligence. Tim Shepherd is super bright, and super engaged.’

‘The standout attribute of Mayer Brown is the depth of analysis. The fee earners provide a luxury level of service – every time, on every case, for every issue. Clients know that their interests are being fully protected. Equally at home in civil professional liability claims and on the regulatory side.’

‘Tim Shepherd is calm, wise and analytical. He brings passion to his work and fosters a strong team spirit. A great strategist, Tim is always thinking ahead to the move after the next move.’

‘Jim Oulton brings his laser-like focus to all his cases. Opponents know that Jim will not let up in his relentless pursuit of the client’s best interests. One of the best!’

‘A great team. Really personable, responsive and with a great eye for detail. No stone left unturned.’

‘Tim Shepherd is extremely responsive and ensures that matters are dealt with firmly but not aggressively with a view to achieving the best outcome for the client.’

‘Tim Shepherd has been excellent to date. He gave very practical advice, knew instinctively what a client law firm could do internally and what he could provide as an outside adviser (which is not an easy role and they handled it very sensitively and well).’

Key clients

Andrew Thornhill QC; Bar Mutual Indemnity Fund Limited


BDO LLP


HW Fisher


MSR Partners LLP


Standard Life


Work highlights


  • Acting for MSR Partners LLP in respect of a high profile tax claim bought against it and Taylor Wessing LLP. The losses claimed would appear to potentially exceed GBP 16.5 million.
  • Acting on the case for Andrew Thornhill QC and Bar Mutual Indemnity Fund Limited, a comprehensive High Court victory on behalf of a Leading Tax Silk in a claim brought by investors in a tax avoidance film scheme, Scotts Atlantic Distributors.
  • Advising Standard Life (now Abrdn) and assisting it to pursue a substantial claim against its professional team and development manager in relation to the construction of a retail park in Newbury.

Norton Rose Fulbright

Norton Rose Fulbright is a leading firm with an impressive client base, including many leaders in their respective fields, such as PwC, Lloyds Bank, and Markel. The department is experienced at the highest levels of the UK courts, and benefits from a vast global network which covers Europe, the US, Asia, Australia, Canada, Africa, the Middle East, and Latin America. Team lead Michelle George is a ‘highly experienced top-class lawyer’ with thirty years of experience in handling complex, high value commercial disputes. Helen Fairhead and Katie Stephen are key names within the department. Counsel Mike George, a ‘dedicated and client-focused lawyer with excellent attention to detail’, is frequently active on high value matters.

Practice head(s):

Michelle George


Other key lawyers:

Helen Fairhead; Mike George; Katie Stephen


Testimonials

‘Experienced, pragmatic, analytical and commercial approach to claims.’

‘Michelle George is a highly experienced, top-class lawyer. She is unfazed by unexpected events, and strategic in her approach. She approaches her litigation with a realistic view of what can and cannot be achieved. Michelle is always conscious of any relevant commercial considerations which need to be taken into account.’

‘Norton Rose has a strong profile in professional negligence litigation, excellent and commercially astute lawyers and a client-focused and user-friendly approach.’

‘I would particularly recommend Michelle George and Mike George. Michelle George is an excellent and experienced strategic litigator, creative in her arguments and with first class judgment. Mike is a dedicated and client-focused lawyer with excellent attention to detail.’

Key clients

Ward Hadaway LLP and its insurers


Charles Russell Speechlys and Speechly Bircham and their insurers


Bevan Brittan LLP and its insurers


Hyperion


Lloyds Banking Group


Markel International Limited


XL Catlin


PwC


Neon


Osborne Clarke LLP and its insurers


Brit Insurance


Work highlights


  • Acted for Ward Hadaway LLP in defence of a professional negligence claim brought by its former client, Tanfield Group plc in respect of legal advice relating to a corporate transaction subject to AIM Rules.
  • Acted for CRS in connection with High Court proceedings brought by two individuals who sold their IT business to a private equity house and were subsequently held by the Court to have been wrongfully dismissed by the company.
  • Acted for Bevan Brittan LLP and their insurers in defence of High Court proceedings brought by its former client, Cheltenham Borough Council. The case concerned a high profile plot in the centre of Cheltenham that the local authority planned to develop.

RPC

RPC is a defendant-focused firm which covers all areas of professional negligence. The firm has a strong profile in the financial sector, with instructions from numerous major insurers and accountancy firms. Construction is a key area of strength for the firm, with a client list which includes a significant number of major consultants and contractors. Nick Bird acts for leading domestic and multinational insurance clients. Alan Stone has more than twenty years of experience in construction, and currently acts on behalf of the architect of Grenfell Tower. James Wickes specialises in defending complex, high value claims against financial professionals and institutions. Richard Breavington leads the cyber and tech insurance team and regularly advises on cyber breach incidents. Other individuals to note include Tim Bull, Felicity Strong, and Tom Green.

Practice head(s):

Nick Bird; Alan Stone; James Wickes; Richard Breavington


Other key lawyers:

Karen Morrish; Tim Bull; Michael Newham; Davina Given; Graham Reid; Simon Laird; Richard Breavington; Alexandra Anderson; Ben Gold; Tom Green; Eleanor Kilner


Testimonials

‘The teams are run extremely well by the partners and there is evidently good support and development because even junior lawyers are confident in their views and know that their opinions are valid.’

‘Alan Stone must have learned to clone himself because he is “everywhere” on his cases. Brings on teams of young lawyers who very quickly progress to senior associate and partner level. A great cultivator of legal talent.’

‘The professional negligence team is strong. The partner I know and work with most regularly is Nick Bird. Nick and his associates are always technically strong and combine technical excellence with good litigation instincts in order to achieve the best solution.’

‘Nick Bird is intellectually excellent and thoughtful in his approach.’

‘RPC have been my “go to” choice for external advice for 30 years. Their personal qualities along with their professional skills make them easy to deal with on what can be highly sensitive matters’

‘Alexandra Anderson has encyclopedic knowledge of insurance, PI law, surveyors, architects, solicitors and engineers’ negligence. She is a leader in joined up thinking between claims, law and the impact on insurers and the market.’

‘The team has huge experience and knowledge of the law and practice.’

‘Tom Green – excellent sector knowledge, commercial approach.’

Key clients

Kingsley Napley


AXIS


Hiscox


AIG


QBE


Sompo


Arch


CBRE


HDI


CNAH


Amtrust


AXA XL


Folgate


Markel


Liberty


Work highlights


  • Appointed to act for Studio E Architects Limited, the architect appointed in relation to the refurbishment works at Grenfell Tower. The case concerns potentially systemic issues with Building Regulations and the regulations of building products.
  • Acting for architect, Broadway Malyan, in a claim brought by Balfour Beatty in relation to fire safety and allegedly defective cladding, alleged defective ventilation and roofing and windows defects at a mixed-use development of student residences in Bethnal Green, London.
  • Appointed jointly by Zurich and the defendant directors against an allegation that the directors of ESMS Global had personal liability to the employees of the company to ensure that 20% of the company’s shares were put into an Employee Benefit Trust (EBT).

Simmons & Simmons

Simmons & Simmons is an international firm with experience operating in Europe, the Middle East, and Asia, and is known as a leading name in cladding claims. The group has been instructed by cladding consultant Cladtech in a £70 million multi-party cladding dispute. In addition to the construction industry, the firm also represents professional services and financial sector clients. Team lead James Pollock has extensive experience in defending solicitors, construction professionals, and brokers in complex, high-value claims. Emily Monastiriotis specialises in construction and engineering disputes, and is known for her cladding expertise. Jonathan Spencer is highly active in the technology and construction sectors, and, alongside Felix Zimmermann, regularly acts in matters against other leading firms.

Practice head(s):

James Pollock


Other key lawyers:

Emily Monastiriotis; Colin Passmore; Zak Coles; Jonathan Spencer; Steven Kaye


Testimonials

‘Quick to respond, deep knowledge, sound advice, pleasant to deal with.’

Key clients

CNA Hardy


IGI Insurance


MPB Structures Limited


Albemarle


AIG


Cladtech


O’Connell East Limited


Willmott Dixon Construction Limited


Albemarle Asset Management Limited


Pollard Thomas Edwards LLP


Work highlights


  • Instructed by Albemarle Asset Management Limited in the defence of a claim brought by a private individual in the London Circuit Commercial Court.
  • Represented cladding consultant Cladtech in a £70 million multi-party cladding dispute regarding a building in Colindale, London.
  • Instructed on defence for OEA who was appointed as the project architect for the development of Victoria Hall, Wembley.  Following the tragedy at Grenfell Tower, the façade of the building was investigated and found to contain potentially unsafe materials

Stephenson Harwood

Stephenson Harwood has an ‘excellent team which is fully committed to obtaining the best outcomes for their clients.’ The firm takes both claimant and defendant work and boasts a strong client roster, including KPMG, Deloitte, and BDO. Kate Cordery, ‘just the person you want to have by your side’, heads the practice alongside Roland Foord, who has deep experience in the professional services and fine art sectors. Helena Berman ‘combines technical expertise with dedication and supreme commercial judgement’ and has over twenty-five years of experience in both the claimant and defendant side of professional negligence. Adam Culy is another name to note.

Practice head(s):

Kate Cordery; Roland Foord


Other key lawyers:

Helena Berman; Paul Hollands; Jenny McKeown; Adam Culy


Testimonials

‘Kate Cordery is just fantastic, insightful, pragmatic and strategic. Just the person you want to have by your side.’

‘Heavy hitting and well resourced’

‘Great team, with super strength in depth.’

‘The team really understand what is needed for an accountancy firm in terms of the various risk considerations, and they are all very proactive and helpful.’

‘Adam Culy is very easy to work with as he is personable, particularly knowledgeable in relation to in-house accountancy matters, and is a great person to lead the case.’

‘The firm puts together teams of excellent lawyers with the right mix of subject matter expertise for the particular case. Very wide experience of all kinds of commercial disputes.’

‘Outstanding client care from our two relationship partners. I feel this firm treats us as a priority.’

‘An all round excellent team which is fully committed to obtaining the best outcomes for their clients.’

Key clients

KPMG LLP


Deloitte LLP


Mercer Limited


Christie’s


Sedgwick Noble Lowndes Limited


Mark Weiss Limited


BDO LLP


Crowe LLP


Work highlights


  • Defended Deloitte in a complex and high value professional negligence claim for at least £60 million brought by Christopher Rokos in relation to tax advice given by Deloitte concerning Mr Rokos’ participation in an Enterprise Zone Investment Scheme.
  • Defending clients in a negligence claim issued by the employer and trustees of the Honda pension scheme in December 2009 regarding a range of alleged defective amendments to the scheme between 1986 – 1999.
  • Defending a client accountancy firm in multi-defendant high court proceedings against a professional negligence claim relating to inheritance tax planning of a former client’s c.£6 million estate.

Taylor Wessing LLP

Taylor Wessing LLP is known as the ‘market leader for high value audit negligence disputes’, with an accounting and auditing professional negligence team which is described as ‘unsurpassed’ in its area. Practice head Andrew Howell, ‘always capable and assured in his analysis and is always available to give his invaluable input’, specialises in claims and regulatory investigations. Stuart Broom provides ‘invaluable legal advice’ to a client list which includes some of the world's largest professional service firms. Senior associate Stephanie High, described as ‘extremely hard-working and perceptive’, specialises in professional services disputes and investigations.

Practice head(s):

Andrew Howell


Other key lawyers:

Julian Randall; Laurence Lieberman; Stuart Broom; James Bryden; Stephanie High


Testimonials

‘Taylor Wessing’s accounting and auditing professional negligence team are the standout players in the market, with a degree of specific experience and knowledge in the area that is unsurpassed’

‘Market leaders for high value audit negligence disputes, and for a reason. Their knowledge of the industry and ability to deliver a settlement is second to none.’

‘Andrew Howell is the best accountants’ defence litigator in the market as well as a superb person to deal with.’

‘The team has the deepest knowledge of the accountancy sector and its challenges that is available.’

‘Andrew Howell is always capable and assured in his analysis and is always available to give his invaluable input. Stephanie High is also an extremely hard-working and perceptive senior associate.’

‘Taylor Wessing have built a strong reputation in the market and the key partners in this area are well known and highly regarded in the industry. They remain close to emerging trends and collaborate well with their clients.’

‘Andrew Howell and Stuart Broom provide extensive experience in the field of audit regulatory defence. They both demonstrate in-depth knowledge of the industry, providing strategic and invaluable legal advice. I would highly recommend them and their respective teams to anyone in this market.’

‘Julian Randall and Andrew Howell are the market leading partners in accounting professional negligence and discipline. They have been involved in many of the leading cases in this area over the last couple of decades.’

Key clients

Mr Zafar Khan


PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP


Grant Thornton


Work highlights


  • Acting for Mr Zafar Khan in relation to an investigation by the Enforcement Division of the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) into the affairs of Carillion plc.

Browne Jacobson LLP

Browne Jacobson LLP has a strong practice in defending professional negligence claims against legal professionals, surveyors, and financial clients. The firm is the sole English member of the Harmonie Group of independent specialist insurance law firms. Ed Anderson leads the practice, and has twenty-five years of experience in defending claims against legal, financial, and construction professionals. Jonathan Newbold specialises in claims which involve financial services or management liability.

Practice head(s):

Ed Anderson; Jonathan Newbold


Other key lawyers:

Derek Bambury; Tim Claremont; Jim Hobsley; Lisa Henty; Laura Brown


Key clients

Hiscox


HDI Global


Pen Underwriting


International General Insurance Company


Arch Australia


Bar Mutual


Zurich


Generali


Channel Syndicate


PAMIA


DUAL


Am Trust Europe


QIC Europe


Great Lakes Insurance


DWF

DWF has core strength in professional indemnity matters, and is praised for its ‘outstanding legal knowledge, particularly in the financial services sector.' John Bennett is an insurance specialist with a wide range of experience, ranging from professional indemnity to defamation, and co-leads alongside Harriet Quiney, whose specialism is defending claims against financial professionals, and Mark Klimt, who is experienced in defending consultants. Lucy Tolondhas unrivalled knowledge of financial services, particularly pensions’ and regularly defends professional negligence claims in the financial sector. Robert Goodlad is a key contact.

Practice head(s):

Harriet Quiney; John Bennett; Mark Klimt


Other key lawyers:

Lucy Tolond; Ian Welland; Damien McKinnon; Sheona Wood; Robert Goodlad


Testimonials

‘Outstanding legal knowledge, particularly in the financial services sector. Very good client handling skills.’

‘Lucy Tolond is very strong among her peers. She has unrivalled knowledge of financial services, particularly pensions.’

‘The DWF London professional indemnity/insurance team has a great set of very experienced partners and some excellent junior lawyers. They each have diverse experience, which is particularly helpful.’

Work highlights


  • Acted for Mishcon de Reya LLP and its professional indemnity insurers in the defence of a claim by Aurium Real Estate London Ultra Prime Limited for alleged negligent advice in connection with a real estate investment.

Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP

Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP has a ‘well experienced, technically brilliant’ professional negligence team which specialises in defending high value claims and regulatory investigations against accountants, insurance brokers, and pension advisors. The firm regularly draws on its significant international resources, and is frequently instructed by leading professional services firms and their insurers. Team lead Simon Brooks specialises in complex, high value professional indemnity claims. Matthew Allen has expertise in accountancy cases, and acts for key clients such as KPMG.

Practice head(s):

Simon Brooks


Other key lawyers:

Claire Carroll; Jennifer Miles; Naz Gauri; Kari McCormick; Matthew Allen; Paula Gaddum


Testimonials

‘The Eversheds insurance/professional negligence team is well experienced, technically brilliant, hugely experienced, and a long-standing trusted partner and adviser.’

‘Simon Brooks is friendly, helpful, enormously experienced and a long-standing and hugely trusted partner.’

‘Simon Brooks – very good instincts.’

Key clients

Aon Limited


United Insurance Brokers Limited


Lockton Companies LLP


Marsh Limited


Options UK PP


KPMG


BDO


Grant Thornton


Universities Superannuation Scheme


Standard Life Assurance Limited


Standard Life Trustee Company Limited


Keoghs LLP

Keoghs LLP is a fast-growing firm which specialises in defending professionals and companies in the legal and construction sectors. The department has been appointed to the legal panels of multiple prominent insurers, including QBE, Arch, Collegiate and Pen Underwriting. Neil Trayhurn leads the professional and financial risks team in London, and has over thirty years of experience in the practice area. Dragos Stoica specialises in professional negligence insurance, while Andrew Schütte specialises in advising D&O and professional indemnity insurers on coverage issues.

Practice head(s):

Neil Trayhurn


Other key lawyers:

Dragos Stoica; Connie Cobb; Andrew Schütte; Dale Hilton


Testimonials

‘Excellent knowledge of construction law & PI insurance.’

‘Good communication, clear instructions and up-dates on timescales. Generally good knowledge & grasp of technical issues.’

‘The professional negligence team (that have worked with) have a breadth and depth of differing skills that are deployed relevant to the matters at issue – with impressive results.’

Key clients

Arch Insurance Company Limited


Antares


QIC Global


Argenta Syndicate 2121


Argo Global


Axis


Collegiate Underwriting


EC Insurance Company


Enstar


Griffiths & Armour


HDI Global Specialty SE


International General Insurance


MGAM


Nexus Underwriting


Omnyy LLP


Pen Underwriting


Pioneer Underwriting


Precision Underwriting


QBE


Quest Group


RiverStone Management Ltd


Royal & Sun Alliance


Starr Companies


Strategic Insurance Services (“SiS”)


Talbot Underwriting Ltd


Work highlights


Mills & Reeve LLP

Mills & Reeve LLP has a strong team which covers professional negligence matters in a number of key areas, including professional indemnity insurance, construction, and technology. Neil Davis specialises in defending professional indemnity claims against professionals, while Tom Filby specialises in corporate civil liability, cyber, and commercial crime and fidelity. Nicolas Oldham leads the construction team in London, while Claire Roake, who is ‘comfortable with the most complex of situations’ specialises in defending claims against financial professionals and lawyers. Alasdair Dick joined the department from Plexus Law in mid 2023.

Practice head(s):

Nicolas Oldham; Neil Davis; Tom Filby


Other key lawyers:

Eric France; Andrew Tobin; Lisa Taylor; Claire Roake; Andrew McConnell; Alasdair Dick


Testimonials

‘Very strong in claims against solicitors. The team has been through some changes in recent times, but service has remained strong.’

‘Claire Roake is handling an incredibly complicated piece of litigation for me at the moment and I continue to be impressed by her, she is entirely comfortable with the most complex of situations.’

‘Fantastic team who are incredibly personable as well as thorough and attentive with all work.’

Key clients

Pen


Manchester Underwriting Management Ltd


IGI


AIG


Allianz


Axis


PRP


Countryside


Vistry


McAleer and Rushe


Work highlights


Pinsent Masons LLP

Pinsent Masons LLP is a full-service practice with core strength in financial services and construction matters, and is acclaimed for its pensions negligence work. The firm conducts high value claimant and defendant work, with experience in some of the largest matters in the market. Colin Read, described as ‘very approachable and with a great eye for detail’, is head of insurance within the firm. Isabel Nurse-Marsh, Jim Cormack KC, Michael Fenn, and Neil Morris are key individuals.

Practice head(s):

Jim Cormack; Michael Fenn; Colin Read; Isabel Nurse-Marsh; Neal Morris


Other key lawyers:

Stuart McNeill; Ben Fairhead; Michael Fletcher; Chamika Hand; Hayley Goldstone


Testimonials

‘The Pinsent Masons professional negligence team are very impressive indeed, providing an excellent service across a wide range of areas.’

‘Colin Read is a particularly impressive partner who builds excellent relationships with insurers. He is particularly strong on claims relating to sport.’

‘Great depth of excellence’.

Key clients

International Law Firm


Trustees of the Capita Pension and Life Assurance Scheme


Global Law Firm


Mercer Limited


Jardine Lloyd Thomsons (JLT) Benefit Solutions Limited


Work highlights


  • Defending an international law firm in respect of a negligence claim against the firm for an alleged mistake in the 2000s – the error could cost the multinational employer £50m.
  • Defended a major law firm against claims that it failed to advise about how to make changes effectively to reduce pension scheme member benefits.
  • Acted for a global organisation which sued a number of leading law firms – for claims relating to negligent drafting of many pension deeds.

Reed Smith LLP

Reed Smith LLP has an experienced international professional negligence team which specialises in financial, legal, and insurance cases. The firm is regularly active in sensitive cross-border matters, and conducts work for major audit and assurance firms. Practice head Charles Hewetson has twenty years of experience in helping clients with issues concerning government entities, regulators, or third parties in the financial services sector. Jane Howard departed for Keystone Law in May 2023.

Practice head(s):

Charles Hewetson


Other key lawyers:

Mark Pring; Margaret Campbell


Work highlights


Womble Bond Dickinson (UK) LLP

Womble Bond Dickinson (UK) LLP has a ‘superb small team who are making waves.’

Practice head(s):

Sushma MacGeoch


Other key lawyers:

Simon Beckwith; Mark Ratcliff; Tim Barr; James Robins


Testimonials

‘Good strength in depth; unrivalled experience in the sector and value for money. Excellent team-working skills and efficient use of modern document management technology.’

‘Sushma MacGeoch is that perfect blend of robust, yet pragmatic. She knows exactly when to apply the pressure and when to look for the deal. Always keeps her client’s objectives firmly in mind. A charming, courageous practitioner and a very nice person who brings warmth and a collaborative spirit to any team.’

‘Well known and respected in the sector.’

Work highlights


Burges Salmon LLP

The ‘very experiencedBurges Salmon LLP professional negligence team primarily focuses on claimant-side disputes. The firm is one of the leading practices in pensions professional negligence work. The practice is headed by Andrew Burnette, a specialist in significant claims against solicitors, surveyors, auditors, and financial services professionals. Other key names include Justin Briggs, Suzanne Padmore, and Kelly Whittaker, who are described as ‘excellent both in terms of their knowledge and experience, and their responsiveness both to counsel and the clients.’

Practice head(s):

Andrew Burnette


Other key lawyers:

Justin Briggs; Suzanne Padmore; Caroline Brown; Amy Khodabandehloo; Kelly Whittaker


Testimonials

‘The Burges Salmon team has acted in a wide range of professional negligence cases.’

‘The Burges Salmon professional negligence team are very experienced not only in professional negligence work but also the underlying subject matter, e.g., insurance, pensions, etc. They have real strength and depth.’

‘I have worked a lot with Justin Briggs, Suzanne Padmore and Kelly Whittaker. They are all excellent both in terms of their knowledge and experience, and their responsiveness both to counsel and the clients.’

‘Justin Briggs has in-depth knowledge of negligence relating to pensions schemes and is a very experienced litigator. Able to add real value in complex cases through the strength of his legal analysis and attention to detail.’

‘Kelly Whittaker is an excellent litigator who is building up extensive experience of professional negligence actions – she operates well above her years and is totally dedicated to the cases she works on.’

‘They have been involved in the biggest pensions prof neg cases of recent years and so really know what they are doing in this area. Their case load is very prestigious which reflects their standing in the market.’

‘Justin Briggs is a brilliant lawyer and quite an academic thinker which means he adds real value to a case overall.’

‘Kelly Whittaker is a phenomenally hard worker.’

Key clients

PSGS Trust Corporation Ltd


Astrel 1 UK Loan S.A.R.L & Others


Ten Financial


Work highlights


  • Advised Astrel 1 UK Loan S.A.R.L & others on a sizeable surveyor negligence claim against a market leading firm regarding the overvaluation of two neighbouring mansions in St James’ Park, London, which stood as security for a £30 million bridge-to-sell loan.
  • Represented the Trustees to the Robert Horne Group Pension Scheme in a high-value claim against a leading pensions consultancy and an international law firm stemming from errors committed in the closure of a defined benefit scheme to future accrual and in implementing other scheme changes.
  • Instructed by Ten Financial LLP and its principal in connection with claims brought by two former clients in the Commercial Court regarding failed investments.

Edwin Coe LLP

Edwin Coe LLP is a claimant focused London firm which specialises in acting against insurance companies, including brokers’ professional indemnity insurers. Team lead Roger Franklin has acted in a variety of commercial insurance matters in the UK, Europe, and the USA, and is an advisor to the Insurance Brokers’ Standards Council. Nicola Maher, who is described as ‘excellent, charming, a pleasure to work with’, often represents corporate, SME, and high net worth clients in complex insurance coverage disputes.

Practice head(s):

Roger Franklin


Other key lawyers:

Michael Whitton; Nicola Maher; Oliver Pannell; Kate Dwyer; Simeon Gilchrist


Testimonials

‘Michael Whitton, Kate Dwyer, and Oliver Pannell are the stand out individuals.’

‘Switched on, good to deal with, client friendly.’

‘They really know their stuff, have a very focused expertise.’

‘Michael Whitton and Nicola Maher are good.’

‘Excellent breadth of knowledge within the team.’

‘Nicola Maher is excellent, charming, and a pleasure to work with. Michael Whitton has excellent depth of knowledge in the sector. Calm but firm manner.’

Work highlights


Fieldfisher

Fieldfisher has an ‘impressive multidisciplinary approach’ and handles both claimant and defendant cases, including complex cross-jurisdictional and high value matters. ‘Highly intelligent’ practice head Jonathan Ray-Smith has thirty years of experience in resolving corporate and commercial disputes. Matthew Sharp, described as ‘determined, confident, and articulate’, specialises in acting for claimants against solicitors, accountants, and tax advisers.

Practice head(s):

Jonathan Ray-Smith


Other key lawyers:

Antony Phillips; Matthew Sharp


Testimonials

‘Impressive multidisciplinary approach to very complex tax-related professional negligence litigation.’

‘Matt Sharp is highly intelligent, impressive grasp of detail, determined, confident, and articulate. Jonathan Ray-Smith is also highly intelligent, fluent, and thoughtful. Jonathan has good organisational ability and impressive client-handling skills.’

‘The individuals in the professional negligence sphere with whose work I am familiar with, and who have impressed me, are Jonathan Ray-Smith and Matt Sharp.’

‘The team at Fieldfisher are commercial and detail driven, using the specific factual matrix to their clients’ advantage.’

‘Commercial judgment, easy to work with, and always looking for commercial solutions rather than difficulties.’

Key clients

Aurium Real Estate London Ultra Prime Limited


British Pipeline Agency


Hoegh Capital Partners


A group of day nurseries


Mirza Law Limited & Ors


Reaction Engines Limited


Colin Hardman and Finbarr O’Connell as liquidators of The Wine Enterprise Investment Scheme Limited


 


Work highlights


  • Advised Hoegh Capital Partners on a professional negligence claim against a firm of accountants and a firm of solicitors in relation to their respective failures to provide adequate tax advice to ultra-high net worth Scandinavian clients.
  • Advised British Pipeline Agency as agent for United Kingdom Oil Pipelines on a quadripartite property dispute, giving rise to claims in trespass on private land, negligence and breach of contract, in relation to pipelines installed in the wrong location.
  • Advised Reaction Engines Limited in its multi-million pound claim for damages against trustees of a property unit trust for damages flowing from breaches of an agreement for lease, and its contractor’s negligence relating to the client’s new testing facility for its breakthrough space rocket engine technology.

Penningtons Manches Cooper LLP

Penningtons Manches Cooper LLP is a claimant focused firm which specialises in group action claims against solicitors and construction professionals. The firm is praised for its ‘unparalleled sense of team spirit and sense of collaboration and support’. The ‘no nonsenseDavid Niven specialises in high value, multi-party professional negligence actions against legal professionals. David O’Brien is highly experienced in international group actions, including those brought before the High Court, while Kamran Rehman covers the banking, finance, and real estate sectors.

Practice head(s):

David Niven


Other key lawyers:

David O’Brien; Nicole Blakey; Colin Hayes; Kamran Rehman


Testimonials

‘Very attentive and focussed representation. Top-notch.’

‘Solid team. Well able to assess when to incur the costs of instructing counsel and when to handle internally.’

‘Kamran Rehman has good knowledge of latest developments in this area. He works very hard to keep his clients happy and to meet client expectations (including client-imposed deadlines).’

‘They give an unparalleled sense of team spirit and sense of collaboration and support.’

‘Very technically and legally knowledgeable partners and associates who do not simply rely on counsel, but have well-developed and thought out analyses and stratagems on their cases. They are remarkably diligent at getting the evidence that is required, but they are not wasteful with resources.’

‘David Niven and David O’Brien are the partners I have worked with – they are both very pleasant and on the ball. ’

‘Vastly experienced and very capable.’

‘They are all experts in their field and very capable in managing complex group actions.’

Key clients

NPPM action groups


Hope Capital


Cutlers Holdings Limited


Scarborough Group International Limited


Social Money


City and Country Group


Work highlights


  • Acted on various high-profile matters for one of the UK’s largest family-owned property companies, with regard to the sale of Sheffield United Football Club.
  • Acting in a professional negligence valuation claim for a short-term bridging lender, Hope Capital. The Defendant valued a 15th Century Grade II listed property in Cobham owned by the National Trust, which was used as a restaurant and was being converted into a large home, without the National Trust’s consent.
  • Acted for a total of 27 clients in breach of stakeholder contract claims against 174 Law Solicitors Limited in relation to the alleged unlawful release of our clients’ deposits in a property investment scheme.

Stewarts Law LLP

Stewarts Law LLP is primarily active on claimant side matters, and has core expertise in tax disputes and commercial litigation. The department has a strong record of high value and high-profile cases, with experience working across the UK and Europe. Practice head David Pickstone is highly experienced in tax disputes, and is a key name for complex claimant cases. James Le Gallais, described as  ‘great with clients and opponents alike’, handles negligence cases involving tax planning, structuring, and investment advice.

Practice head(s):

David Pickstone


Other key lawyers:

James Le Gallais; Darren Kidd; Alex Lerner


Testimonials

‘The team has unrivalled experience in complex tax-related professional negligence matters, where it combines expertise in both tax and commercial dispute resolution to great effect. The partners combine with energetic and enthusiastic associates to form an effective team with talent at all levels.’

‘James Le Gallais is an absolute star. A brilliant lawyer, he has a sharp intellect combined with a sure strategic touch and an easy-going manner. New partner Alex Lerner’s promotion deservedly reflects his work ethic and ability.’

‘Solid claimant team.’

‘David Pickstone is a sensible operator.’

‘Stewarts have a litigation practice second to none. It runs very complex professional negligence cases e.g., involving tax schemes where rafts of highly skilled professional advisors are in the frame following challenges to those schemes by HMRC. Its analysis of strengths and weaknesses of a claim is absolute, meaning that client’s get detailed, comprehensive, and realistic advice, and the best settlements possible in mediation.’

‘James Le Gallais is great with clients and opponents alike. Very personable and a top drawer talented, strategically focused and extremely intelligent lawyer.

‘Great cross-sector experience and expertise.’

‘James Le Gallais is a rising star in tax litigation matters.’

Work highlights


  • Acted for a group of 110 investors in a ground breaking professional negligence claim against Andrew Thornhill KC.
  • Acted for 300 HNW individuals in the case known as the ‘Ingenious Litigation’.
  • Acted for 177 investors in an investment scheme called “Eclipse”.

Weightmans LLP

Weightmans LLP is a defendant focused firm which specialises in claims against professionals in the real estate, financial services, and insurance sectors. Team lead Quentin Fox has over thirty years of experience in defending claims in the construction sector, while James Denison specialises in the financial services and construction industries. Edward Lewis specialises in digital and data matters, including the area of cyber insurance.

Practice head(s):

Quentin Fox


Other key lawyers:

Edward Lewis; James Denison


Testimonials

‘The insurance team covers the entire spectrum of insurance litigation with great quality in depth.’

‘Quentin Fox: a highly astute insurance litigator who knows the insurance market inside out.’

‘We find the team we deal with understands the nature of the claims we are dealing with.’

‘Exceptional experience in matters of PI related to defence in construction cases.’

‘Quentin Fox is a solicitor of enormous experience and total intgrity.’

Work highlights


  • Acting for and advising a tower crane “thorough examination” specialist company in the defence of a substantial claim arising from a collapsed crane at Dickens Yard, Ealing.

Withers LLP

Withers LLP has a strong record of delivering both claimants and defendants ‘consistently high quality, commercially savvy advice.’ The firm is particularly active in professional negligence cases against insured parties, including legal, financial, and real estate professionals. Eleni Polycarpou has experience in advising complex, high profile, sensitive matters for both claimants and defendants, and jointly leads the team alongside Caroline Thompson, who specialises in actions against legal professionals, particularly concerning tax and finance. Senior associate Joshua Swift is experienced in both domestic and international matters.

Practice head(s):

Eleni Polycarpou; Caroline Thompson


Other key lawyers:

Roberto Moruzzi; Stephen Ross; Joshua Swift; Peter Leckey


Testimonials

‘Eleni Polycarpou gives sound commercial advice.’

‘Consistently high quality, commercially savy advice, and always willing to go the extra mile for a client.’

‘Eleni Polycarpou has great overview of her cases and finds a way to make things work for her clients. Joshua Swift is extremely bright, with a great handle on the detail. Caroline Thompson is very astute and on the ball.’

‘They have a large pool of exceptional associates.’

‘This is a strong team working in difficult cases.’

‘Joshua Swift is a particularly impressive senior associate.’

Key clients

Barrowfen Properties Limited


Bar Mutual Indemnity Fund


Stephane Roland Etroy


RBC Trust Company


Work highlights


  • Succeeded in establishing that our clients’ claim in negligence against their former solicitors is not time-barred at a preliminary issue hearing, at which novel points of law were determined.
  • Obtained judgment in favour of Barrowfen Properties Limited with findings of professional negligence against Barrowfen’s former solicitors, the Second Defendant, and findings of forgery against its former director, the First Defendant.
  • Obtained a security for costs order in favour of one of the Bar Mutual Indemnity Fund’s insureds in respect of claims brought against him in relation to advice given over a four year period encompassing advice in relation to an enforcement notice under s173 TCPA 1990 and criminal proceedings against the former clients.

Carter Perry Bailey LLP

Carter Perry Bailey LLP is a boutique firm which covers a wide range of professional negligence services, including defence and coverage advice for professionals, claimant advice for insurance entities, and professional indemnity advice for corporations and public authorities. The firm benefits from strong relationships with numerous overseas firms, and as such act on a highly international portfolio of matters. Stephen Carter specialises in coverage and reinsurance, and co-leads the department alongside Mark Aizlewood, who has expertise in professional indemnity policies, financial institutions' insurance, and D&O policies.

Practice head(s):

Mark Aizlewood; Stephen Carter


Testimonials

‘Great team with a high degree of partner engagement, and real fight. Routinely hit above their boutique weight.’

‘Mark Aizlewood is simply excellent. A real fighter. Stephen Carter knows everything there is to know about insurance and reinsurance, and associated professional negligence litigation – such as against brokers.

‘Niche Insurance practice which offers a top rate service.’

‘Mark Aizlewood is an extremely competent pair of hands and a very personable approach. You feel he really cares about delivering a good result.’

‘Small boutique outfit who offer a bespoke service.’

‘Simon Thomas and Mark Aizlewood are top-notch. Personable, friendly, and responsive.’

Key clients

Nexus Claims Management


Compre Group


Partner Re Ireland Insurance Ltd


NPA Insurance Company


Work highlights


  • Providing coverage advice to Qualifying Insurers as to the application of the Successor Practice Rules under the Minimum Terms for Solicitors.
  • Defending a £12m claim on behalf of auditors’ insurers arising from alleged fraudulent conduct (ghost employee fraud) of the former finance director.
  • Pursuing a claim for negligence and breach of warranty of authority on behalf of an insurer against its broker arising from the placement of a reinsurance treaty.

Kingsley Napley LLP

'Intelligent, analytical, robust and dedicated', Kingsley Napley LLP stands out among clients for its 'old-school rigour combined with a thoroughly modern emphasis on client care'. Practice head Ryan Mowat is highly experienced in private wealth disputes concerning trusts and estates, often handling matters with a cross-jurisidictional aspect. Other names to note include Richard Foss, who heads up the wider disputes team; Mary Young, praised for her 'endlessly imaginative' practice; and Jemma Brimblecombe - 'a tough, forensic litigator with a no-nonsense approach.'

Practice head(s):

Ryan Mowat


Other key lawyers:

Richard Foss; Mary Young; Jemma Brimblecombe


Testimonials

‘Old-school rigour combined with a thoroughly modern emphasis on client care. The fee earners in the team are intelligent, analytical, robust and dedicated.’

‘Mary Young is endlessly imaginative in thinking outside the box and understanding the client’s commercial imperatives. I have never seen a lawyer so adept at identifying the real issues in dispute and clever ways to resolve those issues.’

‘Jemma Brimblecombe – a tough, forensic litigator with a no-nonsense approach to her cases. Enormous work ethic.’

‘Good knowledge of the professional negligence market’

‘Jemma Brimblecombe is good at distilling the issues into easily understood advice.’

‘I found the team to be helpful, clear and honest. I was able to rely on their judgement and their advice.’

Duncan Lewis Solicitors

Duncan Lewis Solicitors is noted for its strength in professional negligence claims against legal, construction, and financial professionals. The team benefits from broad expertise within the firm, which includes specialists in public law, probate, and tax. Team lead Sobashni De Silva  is highly experienced in acting for clients with connections to the Middle East. Co-lead Anthony Okumah has extensive experience in civil and commercial litigation.

Practice head(s):

Sobashni de Silva; Anthony Okumah


Testimonials

‘Good for long-running litigation with lots of moving parts. Can co-ordinate across a number of areas, which is essential for professional negligence claims.’

‘Hard-working and efficient.’

‘Sobashni de Silva is approachable and has a real determination to help her clients.’

‘Very professional outfit.’

‘Anthony Okumah is a commercially and tactically savvy litigator and highly respected in his field.’

‘Duncan Lewis has been a life-saver. They were there for me when I felt truly helpless. They provided me with someone to talk to, which relieved a lot of emotional strain. I will be forever grateful.’

‘They are good lawyers who go the extra mile for their clients.’

‘Sobashni de Silva is excellent. She cares about her clients and gets on top of the key issues early.’

Work highlights


Hamlins LLP

Hamlins LLP is a claimant focused firm with an emphasis on construction professional negligence. The firm used to defend insurers in professional indemnity cases, which is useful experience for their current focus on acting for claimants against larger defendant panel insurance firms.

Other key lawyers:

Sarah Finch; Laura Daly


Testimonials

‘Laura Daly has extensive experience in relation to lender claims against surveyors and legal professionals.’

‘Hamlins appreciate what matters to a family run property company.’

‘They are known for acting for insureds in professional negligence disputes.’

‘Laura Daly is very efficient and very sensible.’

Key clients

European Land & Property Limited


Triple Point Investment Limited


Westminster Academy


VolkerFitzpatrick Limited


The Pears Group of Companies


FJB Hotels


Fruition Properties


Dobler Metallbau GmbH


 


Work highlights


  • Acting on behalf of joint owners of a property in respect of a claim against a firm of solicitors who gave negligent advice relating to the property which our clients purchased in 2016. The owners only received limited information about a defective licence. The Licence is defective primarily as a result of the definition of “encroachments” which cover the external structural wall of the property and provide that the terms of the licence are such that the licensor can determine the licence at any time on notice which triggers the licensee’s obligation to dismantle the wall.
  • Acting on behalf of an industry regulatory body in respect of multiple clams against one of its members for professional negligence and/or fraudulent activity.
  • Acting on behalf of a property developer on a professional negligence claim against a statutory manager for negligent conduct in the course of his appointment.

Healys LLP

Healys LLP is a claimant focused firm which has an ‘extremely helpful and responsive’ team. The firm bring claims against all professionals, including architects, surveyors, financial advisors and accountants, but have recently demonstrated particular aptitude in bringing claims against solicitors. Team lead Robert Johnson provides an ‘excellent service’ and has particular strength in claims against legal professionals.

Practice head(s):

Robert Johnson


Other key lawyers:

David Bailey; Ben Parr-Ferris


Testimonials

‘The team were extremely helpful and responsive. I was made aware of the situation at all times.’

‘Robert Johnson was very competent. He offered sound advice which provided me with confidence. The advice was clear and concise which ultimately led to a successful claim.’

‘Healys LLP provided excellent service in a clear and open manner. The advice was professional and accurate. All communication was prompt and the billing was open and consistent with original quotes. Highly recommended for undoubted expertise and personalised service at reasonable cost.’

‘Robert Johnson provided excellent service. All communications were clear, prompt and responsive. His technical expertise and advice proved to be remarkably accurate. I was provided with a clear explanation of likely costs, and these were reasonably adhered to. Highly recommended as an expert in his field and for his good communication skills.’

‘My contact has been with Robert Johnson – Robert has an engaging, caring personality and always replied prompt when needed.’

‘Fast, efficient and pragmatic advice. Excellent advice delivered quickly.’

‘Great level of service provided highly recommend! Very professional and prompt with communication.’

‘Robert Johnson handled an extremely complex case in a very sensitive way and I felt very safe in his hands. Apart from being a brilliant lawyer, very clear and thorough, he has the gift of being superb communicator.’

Key clients

Paratus AMC


Monmouthshire Building Society


Landbay Partners Limited


Roskell Lagra Limited (Sheyi Banjo)


Work highlights


  • Acted on a claim against a firm of solicitors arising out of the manner in which they handled our client’s arbitration proceedings in a US $20 million claim against a Chinese company under the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre Administered Arbitration Rules.
  • Acted in a claim against firms of solicitors who acted for clients in the intended purchase of properties but which were subject to identity fraud and hence the clients lost the purchase monies/did not acquire title to the property intended to be purchased.
  • Invested for Paratus AMC nearly 1000 claims against solicitors and valuers, each with a value ranging from between £50,000 and £500,000.