Firms To Watch: Patent prosecution

GOTTSCHALD Patentanwälte's patent advice focuses on electrical engineering, process engineering and biotechnology and is frequently complemented by expertise in future-oriented areas such as AI, digitalisation and automation.

Patent prosecution in Germany

Bardehle Pagenberg

Bardehle Pagenberg continues to be considered one of the leading addresses for patent law advice and impresses with a wide-ranging sector expertise that includes the automotive, life sciences, electrical engineering and medical technology industries. Based on its set-up as a mixed law and patent law firm, the group is able to assist clients with matters ranging from portfolio building to nullity actions and infringement proceedings. In addition to computer and electrical engineering, Johannes Lang  focuses on semiconductor technology and medical technology, while Christof Karl frequently assists companies in the hardware and software sectors with non-contentious and contentious matters. Other key contacts include Joachim Mader (mechanical engineering, electrical and process engineering), Tobias Kaufmann (telecommunications and mobile communications) and Georg Anetsberger (patent and design law).

Practice head(s):

Johannes Lang; Christof Karl; Joachim Mader; Tobias Kaufmann; Georg Anetsberger


Other key lawyers:

Patrick Daum; Axel Berger; Johannes Heselberger; Martin Hohgardt


Testimonials

‘Excellent understanding of technology and business, very professional way of working, excellent lawyers with a high level of competence.’

‘Georg Anetsberger: Outstanding patent attorney with outstanding expertise in the areas of physics/mechanics/electrical engineering/software/algorithms.’

‘Bardehle is able to present options for action regarding patent granting processes, which take into account the entire pending patent family and are “self-contained”. This means that as a patent applicant you are able to follow one of these recommendations without having to re-study the grant file(s) in their entirety.’

Key clients

4Web Medical


adidas AG


Abu Dhabi National Oil Company


Apple Inc.


Aptiv


Ascom


ATS


AusBio Laboratories


Biotronik


Bosch


Bridgestone


Carl Zeiss SMT GmbH


Cognex


Dell


Dropbox Inc.


Eissmann Automotive Deutschland GmbH


EJOT


Emerson


Fotona


Gerresheimer Regensburg GmbH


Hyster-Yale group


Henniges Automotive Sealing Systems


Jaguar Land Rover


Johnson Matthey


IVIS


Japan Tobacco International


Leica Biosystems


Mitsubishi Heavy Industries


Nemotec GmbH


Occhio


Qualcomm


SHL Medical


Signode


Nintendo


Wago Kontakttechnik GmbH


Work highlights


  • Advising Qualcomm on extensive EP, DE and PCT filing activities in the telecommunications sector (SEP), including on employee invention rights, cooperation agreements and SEP strategies.

  • Advising Apple on extensive and ongoing EP, DE and PCT filing activities in the areas of computer technology and IT as well as representation in opposition and nullity proceedings before the EPO, the DPMA and the BPatG.

  • Advising Adidas in the context of exclusive EP, DE and PCT registration activities in the areas of sports and materials technology as well as representation in opposition and nullity proceedings before the EPO, the DPMA and the BPatG.

Cohausz & Florack

Cohausz & Florack impresses with an established prosecution practice that, in addition to traditional registration and administration matters, also covers freedom-to-operate reports and cooperation agreements. Coupled with in-depth experience in disputes, the team is a one-stop shop for patent law called upon by both German medium-sized companies and global corporations. At patent lawyer level, clients benefit from several highly specialised individuals, including Arnd Ziebell, who is experienced in renewable energies and metal production, and mechanical engineering and mining technology expert Andreas Thielmann. Gottfried Schüll is regularly instructed to set up and enforce SEP patent portfolios, while Arwed Burrichter primarily assists clients from the life sciences and chemistry sectors.

Other key lawyers:

Mathias Karlhuber; Arwed Burrichter; Philipe Walter; Christoph Walke; Henning Sternemann; Johannes Simons; Jan Ackermann; Jochen Kapfenberger; Gottfried Schüll; Arnd Ziebell


Testimonials

‘High success rate in obtaining patent grants. High success rate in patent law cases. Good search engine for patents.’

‘Cohausz & Florack stands out as an uncomplicated and professional partner. Even as a small medium-sized company, we are taken seriously and advised with enthusiasm. Free training courses on international patent law are always at high professional level.’

‘Our collaboration with Jochen Kapfenberger also shaped our inventive spirit in a way that now makes us recognise our potential early on.’

‘The team has a broad range of expertise, is well connected both nationally and internationally. The team conveys the impression of a balanced diversity within the team. Very good and professional marketing and communications department.’

Key clients

Ascensia Diabetes Care


Autokabel


Bayer AG


Bayer Crop Science


Beijing BOE Optoelectronics Technology Co.,Ltd


Bilfinger Noell


bio-tec Biologische Naturverpackungen GmbH & Co. KG


Bombardier


Brillux GmbH & Co. KG


Carl Zeiss SMT AG


Deutsche Post DHL


DIRAK GmbH


Elanco, Inc.


EWM AG


Ferdinand Lusch GmbH


FIBRANT


FOGTEC Brandschutz GmbH & Co. KG


Francotyp-Postalia AG & Co. KG


Fraunhofer Gesellschaft zur Förderung der angewandten Forschung e.V.


Goldbeck


innogy SE


KAMAT GmbH & Co KG


KOBIL GmbH


Kyowa


LECO Corporation, US


Lhoist SA


natsu Foods


Otto Junker GmbH


PCC SE


Plasmatreat GmbH


RWE SE


Scheidt & Bachmann


SIG Technology AG, SIG Combibloc Systems GmbH


UPM


Viega GmbH & Co. KG


Vinventions


Vorwerk & Co. Interholding GmbH


Eisenführ Speiser

Traditionally experienced in the prosecution sector, Eisenführ Speiser also has a good reputation in contentious matters, which include the management and coordination of proceedings before German and European authorities as well as high-profile opposition proceedings. On prosecution level, day-to-day matters span license negotiations, IP applications and innovation processes among other matters. Both forensic and advisory work focus on civil engineering, chemistry and electrical engineering, while the team also assists with issues related to mechanical engineering, life sciences and IT. Key contacts include Ludger Eckey, who predominantly advises technology companies on the whole array of technical intellectual property rights, Fabian Fegers, who assists German and US corporations, and the life sciences-experienced Manuel Söldenwagner.

Other key lawyers:

Ludger Eckey; Lars Birken; Uwe Stilkenböhmer; Holger Veenhuis; Manuel Söldenwagner; Klaus Göken; Fabian Fegers; Markus Schulz; Stefan Wiethoff


Key clients

BASF


Edwards Lifesciences


Enercon


Hüttenes-Albertus Chemische Werke


Philips


KWS Saat


Nordson


Panasonic


Symrise


ZF Friedrichshafen


Work highlights


  • Successful representation of Dr. Pfleger Pharmaceuticals in opposition to Janssen’s cancer treatment patent for abiraterone acetate in combination with prednisone for the treatment of prostate cancer; the patent in dispute was revoked.

  • Defending Philips against objections from several competitors regarding AI surgical robots.

  • Representation of ThyssenKrupp Steel Europe on the patent holder and opponent side in oppositions and opposition appeal proceedings against ArcelorMittal and Tata Steel IJmuiden regarding high-tech special sheets for the automotive industry.

Grünecker

Grünecker has one of the most active filing practices in the market and further acts in numerous opposition and complaint proceedings; this combination makes the practice one of the leading mixed patent law firms. The group assists a client base consisting of medium-sized companies, international corporations and start-ups with portfolio development and management and acts in opposition and appeal proceedings before the EPO. Reinhard Knauer, who is experienced in electrical engineering and IT, frequently advises on SEPs, while Martin Dropmann's expertise includes patent as well as trade mark and design law. Thomas Schuster (physics) retired in January 2023.

Other key lawyers:

Martin Dropmann; Reinhard Knauer; André Nickel; Jens Koch; Andreas Kayser; Christian Meisinger; Moritz Höffe; Dietmar Kuhl; Jens Hammer


Testimonials

‘Professional and efficient.’

‘The team provides professional services of highest quality. A quality that is second to none.’

‘Moritz Höffe is one of the best European patent attorneys I have ever worked with.’

Key clients

Alpine Quantum Technologies


Drivenets LTD


Eberspächer Catem GmbH & Co. KG, DE


Edwards Lifesciences


fruitcore robotics GmbH


Fuji Corp.


Gebr. Pfeiffer SE


Globalfoundries


GS Yuasa International Ltd.


Identy Inc.


JFE Steel


Kinaxis Inc.


Knowles Corporation


Krones AG


Lenovo


Marvell Technology Inc.


Menlo Systems GmbH


Microsoft


MULTIVAC Sepp|HaggenmüllerSE&Co.KG


Munich Electrification GmbH


NetApp


Panasonic


Rivian


Roche Diabetes Care


Rockwell Automation


Sami-Sabinsa Group


Samsung Electronics


SEDA International Packaging Group SpA


SiCrystal GmbH


TE Connectivity


United Robotics Group


Vestas Wind Systems


Yokogawa Electric


Work highlights


  • Advising Microsoft on numerous European and German patent proceedings, including opposition and appeal proceedings, as well as advising on portfolio management aspects such as expert opinions, employee invention law and patent transfer matters.

  • Advising Samsung Electronics on patent and trade mark matters, including complaint and opposition proceedings as well as infringement and invalidity proceedings.

  • Advising Krones AG on its global patent and trade mark portfolio, including representation in contentious proceedings as well as advice on contractual matters/employee invention law and expert opinions on IP issues.

Hoffmann Eitle

As one of the largest practices on the market, Hoffmann Eitle is well equipped to manage patent portfolios and assist with litigation before European and German authorities, with a particularly good reputation in the chemistry and biotechnology sectors. With offices in London, Barcelona, Amsterdam and several others, the team can rely on its internal cross-border network as well as on close contacts with other international IP specialists, for example in China and the US. Matthias Kindler, Peter Klusmann and Klemens Stratmann focus on the chemistry field, while Leo Polz and Joseph Taormino primarily act in biotechnology matters. Key contacts also include electrical engineering specialist Georg Siegert and Christopher Furlong, who is experienced in mechanics.

Practice head(s):

Matthias Kindler; Peter Klusmann; Klemens Stratmann; Leo Polz; Joseph Taormino; Christopher Furlong; Georg Siegert


Other key lawyers:

Thorsten Bausch; Thomas Becher; Andreas Stefferl; James Ogle; Anne Katrin Schön; Dominik Scheible; Volker Tillmann; Kei Enomoto; Stephan Klaus


Key clients

Essity


Allergan


Medtronic


Moderna Therapeutics


Toshiba


NTT Docomo


Novo Nordisk


Match Group


Vossius & Partner

Vossius & Partner divides its technical patent expertise into three basic pillars, namely chemistry and pharmacology, biology and biotechnology as well as physics, technology and IT. In combination with a broad legal coverage, which ranges from portfolio management and litigation to strategy consulting and contract drafting, the group is a popular address for scientific institutions and start-ups as well as for German medium-sized companies and large international corporations. The firm's broad offering is also reflected by the team's individual specialisations: Elard Schenck zu Schweinsberg is experienced in mechanical engineering, automotive engineering, physics and medical technology, while Christian Sandweg has expertise in patent granting as well as opposition and nullity proceedings among other matters.

Other key lawyers:

Elard Schenck zu Schweinsberg; Rainer Viktor; Arnold Asmussen; Raphael Salzer; Hans-Rainer Jaenichen; Jürgen Meier; Friederike Stolzenburg; Natalia Berryman; Dirk Harmsen; Andreas Heiseke; Philipp Marchand; Stefan Müller; Ulrich Sentner


Testimonials

‘Top skills in patent litigation.’

‘A one-stop shop for all patent needs, including freedom-to-operate advisory, patent prosecution and patent litigation services. This is a unique offer.’

‘Elard Schenck zu Schweinsberg is really impressive. He really understands the technology and is very quick to understand how law interacts with technology. He gets straight to the point and implements them very effectively in written and oral arguments.’

Key clients

BioNTech SE


BioNTech AT


Boston Scientific Corporation


CRISPR Therapeutics AG


Echo Pharmaceuticals


Galenicum Health S.L.U.


Hitachi Energy


Hyundai Mobis Co., Ltd.


IMC Group


ISCAR Ltd.


Taegutec


Tungaloy et al.


Max-Planck-Gesellschaft


Morinaga Milk Industry Co., Ltd.


Nestlé


NIO


Nippon Steel Corporation


ResMed


Roche Group


Sartorius


Starkey Hearing Technologies


ZTE


Work highlights


  • Representation and advice to Boston Scientific Corporation on its IP portfolio, including its management.

  • Representing and advising CRISPR Therapeutics AG in numerous opposition and complaint proceedings.

  • Advising and representing Max Planck Society in grant, opposition and complaint proceedings.

Boehmert & Boehmert

As one of the most active practices in the patent filing and administration sphere, Boehmert & Boehmert has developed a reputation as a leading IP entity that covers an extremely broad range of technologies and sectors, ranging from robotics and publishing to physics and environmental technology. In addition, thanks to an extensive Best Friends network and its offices in Alicante, Paris and Shanghai, the group is an attractive choice for globally active clients. Markus Engelhard, who focuses on life sciences, pharmaceuticals and biotechnology, regularly acts in nullity and opposition proceedings and is particularly well versed in matters pertaining to active pharmaceutical ingredients and therapeutic biomolecules, while Daniel Herrmann primarily assists with establishing and defending patent portfolios in the technology sector. In September 2022, mechanical engineering specialists Nils Schmid, Florian Malescha and Paul Schieler as well as David Kuttenkeuler and Jan Krauss, who both specialise in biotechnology and life sciences, left the team to found IP boutique SKM-IP. Furthermore, Dennis Kretschmann was appointed judge of the UPC in June 2023.

Other key lawyers:

Markus Engelhard; Daniel Herrmann; Karl-Heinz Metten; Heinz Goddar; Dennis Kretschman


Key clients

NovaTec GmbH


Friedhelm Loh Group


Biocopy GmbH


Beumer GGroup


BAUERandMORE GmbH


Naber GmbH


Gira Giersiepen GmbH


Borgers SE


Samsung Bioepis


King Faisal Specialist Hospital & Research Centre


Qurient Co., Ltd.


Ise Individuelle Software und Elektronik GmbH


Mikron Tool SA


M. Neemann OGH


Polytech Health


wallPen GmbH


QVC


Lupus-Electronics GmbH


Fraport AG


Ab Initio


Wacom Co. Ltd


SZ DJI Technology Co., Ltd.


Aptar Freyung GmbH


AptarGroup


Antpool Technologies Ltd.


Bitmain Technologies Ltd.


Matthews International GmbH


Silicon Laboratories


Proline Systems GmbH


Aphria Deutschland GmbH


RWTH Aachen University


Blink AG


Novo Nordisk A/S


AiCuris AG


Nucleus Medical GmbH


Work highlights


  • Advising FRAPORT on patent applications before the EPO, the DPMA and abroad.

  • Advising Raylase GmbH comprehensively on all IP matters and patent applications.

  • Management of the BAUERandMORE GmbH portfolio as well as EP registrations and PCT subsequent registrations.

Maikowski & Ninnemann

As a pure patent law firm, Maikowski & Ninnemann's highly specialised unit acts on both a forensic and prosecution level and is predominantly instructed by global technology corporations. The group covers a broad technical spectrum, including mechanical engineering, communication and electrical engineering, physics, life sciences and chemistry. Gunnar Baumgärtel is experienced in contentious proceedings, particularly regarding standard-essential patents, and one of the team's key contacts; he also regularly assists with patent application procedures and license agreements. Felix Gross frequently handles matters relating to process engineering and software-based inventions.

Other key lawyers:

Gunnar Baumgärtel; Andreas Tanner; Ralf Emig; Fabian Sokolowski; Christoph Schröder; Matthias Hoffmann; Frederick Kramer; Felix Gross


Testimonials

‘Christoph Schröder masterfully understands how to protect and enforce our innovations through broad and easily enforceable patent claims and how to train and support our consultants, especially in China, intensively and very cooperatively.’

‘Ralf Emig is characterised by his willingness to intensively discuss and optimise the patent drafts with us as clients and is available at any time.’

‘Fabian Sokolowski patiently and creatively finds ways to ensure that our trade mark applications are granted as comprehensively as possible, especially in Asian countries.’

Key clients

Arnold Richter (ARRI)


Biomet


Biotronik


Borealis


Broadcom


Brose Fahrzeugteile


Commscope


Continental


Fenwal Inc.


Fitbit


Fraunhofer Gesellschaft


Fresenius Kabi


FU Berlin


Garmin


GE Healthcare


Google


Heidenhain


HTC


Infineon Technologies


Joyson Safety Systems


Kronotec


Lenovo


LG Electronics


LR Health & Beauty


Magna International


MD Elektronik


MSA Auer


NTN


Oppo


Phoenix Contact


ProBiodrug AG


Rolls Royce


Solar Edge


Suzlon


TollCollect


TU Berlin


TU Dresden


Vestel


Viessmann


Vodafone


Xiaomi


Maiwald GmbH

With a team consisting of solicitors and patent lawyers, Maiwald GmbH is a one-stop patent shop and also provides seamless advice on other IP areas, including trade mark and copyright law. The group's technical cornerstones include engineering, medical technology, biotechnology as well as chemistry and pharmaceuticals, while its geographical focus rests on the US, China, Switzerland and the United Kingdom. Eva Ehlich (polymer chemistry, drug delivery, formulation technology), Dirk Bühler (drugs, molecular chemistry, biology, diagnostics) and Derk Vos (chemistry and pharmacy) are among the team's key contacts.

Other key lawyers:

Eva Dörner; Andreas Ledl; Christian Pioch; Alexander Ortlieb; Alexander Schmitz; Lutz Kietzmann; Dirk Bühler; Martin Huenges; Angela Zumstein; Eva Ehlich; Sophie Ertl; Naho Fujimoto; Christian Schäflein; Annelie Wünsche; Derk Vos


Testimonials

‘Excellent understanding of technology and business, very professional modus operandi, excellent lawyers with a high level of competence.’

‘Alexander Schmitz: Outstanding patent attorney with outstanding expertise in the areas of physics/mechanics/electrical engineering/software/algorithms.’

‘What is special is their technology-oriented handling of matters, without having to excessively deal with formal issues.’

‘Partners at eye level, patent issues are always viewed against the background of our business and research development. We know that Maiwald’s advice does not come from an external consultant, but from someone who puts themselves in our shoes.’

‘Andreas Ledl and Eva Dörner are not only top-class experts, but also have a particular instinct for the employees involved.’

‘The team is very well organised, very responsive and always of very good quality.’

‘Very good understanding of legal trends, very good advice.’

‘Very good, sound and at the same time pragmatic advice. Derk Vos has extremely good industry knowledge, knows all current international parallel and ECJ proceedings and is very well connected. His responsiveness combined with excellent thematic quality is impressive. It is a great pleasure to work with him.’

Key clients

ABB AG


Acadia Pharmaceuticals


Biotheryx


Borealis


Brainlab AG


CureVac AG


Formycon/ bioeq


Fraunhofer


Gedeon Richter


Heraeus


Numaferm


PepsiCo


Proxygen


Reebok International Ltd.


Spectroplast


United States of America, as represented by the Secretary – Department of Health and Human Services


Unity Biotechnology Inc.


United Grinding and related company IRPD


VEGA Grieshaber KG


Volvocar


Work highlights


  • Advising CureVac AG on RNA-based medicines (including production and medical use).

  • Advising Borealis on its global patent portfolio.

Meissner Bolte Patentanwälte Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB

Meissner Bolte Patentanwälte Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB predominantly advises on matters in the mechanical and electrical engineering fields, but also has expertise in the biotechnology and process engineering sphere. It further assists players in the telecommunications industry as part of its designated department for computer-implemented inventions and also fields a practice that is focused on chemistry and pharmacy. Its broad technical offering is complemented by an array of individual focuses: Jasper Werhahn and Ole Trinks are experienced in physics-related patents, Felix Letzelter covers chemistry, pharmacy and medicine and Jochen Kilchert assists with matters relating to medical technology, mechanics and materials science. Markus Schlögl, who specialises in electrical engineering and environmental technology, and mechanical engineering and construction expert Nils Ellberg are other key contacts.

Practice head(s):

Jochen Kilchert; Felix Letzelter; Jasper Werhahn; Ole Trinks; Markus Schlögl; Nils Ellberg


Other key lawyers:

Gernot Schröer; Tilman Pfrang; Florian Meyer; Julian Würmser; Stephan Held; Stefan Zech; Kay Rupprecht


Testimonials

‘Thanks to the large number of competent specialist lawyers, the firm covers a wide range of areas.’

‘Very good knowledge that always results in practical solutions. The team always looks for solutions rather than simply pointing out problems.’

Key clients

Brita GmbH


Cybex GmbH


Howmet Aerospace Inv.


Rockwool AS


Villeroy & Boch AG


Emmerson Process Group.


Koki Holdings


CommScope Technologies LLC


Mitsubishi Electric


Illinois Tool Works


Prinz & Partner

At Prinz & Partner, domestic and European clients benefit from its broad expertise in patent applications, which includes areas such as telecommunications and mechanical engineering. The practice is further experienced in defending and enforcing intellectual property rights, including opposition and nullity proceedings, as well as in freedom-to-operate research and due diligence. Jochen Sties and Thomas Kitzhofer, who both specialise in materials science and mechanics, jointly head the practice.

Practice head(s):

Jochen Sties; Thomas Kitzhofer


Other key lawyers:

Werner Sulzbach; Jürgen Strass; Tim Hülsheger; Ute Feldmann


Key clients

Nike


Kennametal


ZF Group


Valeo


Rational


European Central Bank


Faurecia Emissions Control Technologies


Faurecia Interior Systems


Bürkert


BMW AG


Rohde & Schwarz


Inteva / Roof Systems Germany GmbH


Süss Microtec


GB Boucherie NV


Dehn SE


Delo Industrieklebstoffe GmbH & Co. KGaA


Langmatz GmbH


Ohrmann Montagetechnik


Schill + Seilacher


Sartorius Stedim Biotech GmbH


Jochen Schweizer


Metrona Union GmbH


easE-Link


Tintometer GmbH


Galata Chemicals


BCS Automotive Interface Solutions GmbH


ABB Schweiz AG


Schischek GmbH


Curiosity Diagnostics Sp. z o.o.


micro resist technology GmbH


Alfred E. Tiefenbacher GmbH & Co. KG


medac GmbH


Tianma Group


Automotive Artificial Intelligence (AAI) GmbH


Uexküll & Stolberg

Patent grant procedures and patent applications form the core of Uexküll & Stolberg's advice portfolio, which is predominantly called upon by German and international medium-sized companies and large corporations. This expertise is complemented by a strong litigation practice which is experienced in opposition and nullity proceedings before German and European authorities and courts. The technical focus rests on three pillars: chemistry and pharmacology, with Peter Franck and Bernd Janssen as key contacts, biotechnology and life sciences which are covered by Albrecht von Menges and André Guder, as well as electronics and mechanical engineering; matters related to the latter areas are frequently handled by Johannes Ahme and Lars Manke, among others.

Practice head(s):

Peter Franck; Bernd Janssen; Albrecht von Menges


Other key lawyers:

Johannes Ahme; André Guder; Lars Manke; Helmut van Heesch; Bernd Christian Janssen; Ulrich Maria Gross


Testimonials

‘Professional expertise, years of experience, a good, discreet network, empathy, comprehensive advice and years of trustworthy cooperation.’

‘Uexküll & Stolberg delivers high quality advice. Most importantly, they produce positive outcomes for the client and are particularly good at relating to materials science and chemistry-related technologies.’

‘Uexküll & Stolberg is able to realise projects in the shortest possible time.’

‘In-depth project knowledge and technical know-how, international network and reasonable prices.’

‘Practical, timely and strategic advice.’

‘Bernd Janssen is an excellent practitioner who works creatively and methodically.’

Key clients

Ferring Holding B.V.


Tiny Technologies


Johnson & Johnson


Monsanto/Bayer


Chr. Hansen


ExxonMobil


Amgen Inc.


Janssen Pharmaceutical


Tchibo


Seald Air


Amcol Intern. Corporation


Beiersdorf AG


Microjet Technology


Big Ben SA


ABB K. K.


Albermale


Chinese University of Hong Kong


Desitin


W. R. Grace & Co.


Ivoclar


Komori Corporation


Kongsberg Automotive


KRKA


Medac


Ohly GmbH


Poly-med


TuTech Innovation Hamburg


Heitkamp & Thumann KG


Work highlights


  • Ongoing strategic advice to Ferring Holding SA on portfolio management and the drafting of European and international patent applications.

  • Advising ExxonMobil on the drafting of European and international patent applications.

  • Advising Chr. Hansen on the drafting of European and international patent applications as well as representation in patent grant proceedings and opposition proceedings before the EPO.

Gulde & Partner

Gulde & Partner focuses on advising clients in the Asian region; the group is known for their expertise in digital communication, while forensic assistance and advice is also rendered on matters in the medical technology and automotive sectors among others. With the opening of an office in Düsseldorf in March 2023 and its two locations in Munich and Hamburg, the team further expanded its presence in UPC cities. The practice is jointly spearheaded by Diane Reinstädler, who leads the mechanical engineering and automotive group, head of electrical engineering and telecommunications Sönke Lorenz and Jens Glienke, who is responsible for the life sciences area.

Practice head(s):

Diane Reinstädler; Sönke Lorenz; Jens Glienke


Other key lawyers:

Marco Scheffler; Nicolas Haße


Testimonials

‘The team has a strong ability to summarise a case in succinct terms. This makes in-house work much easier.’

‘Sönke Lorenz is deeply able to anticipate a case right from its early stages, which proves itself time and again. After decisions are made, Dr. Lorenz teaches the case according to relevant laws, and provides internal staff with a better understanding of EU laws, which is really helpful for internal work.’

‘The team is professional in prosecuting EP patents and EU designs as well as their litigation.’

Key clients

Volkswagen AG


Audi AG


Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.


Samsung SDI Co. Ltd.


Samsung Display Co. Ltd.


Siemens AG


Robert Bosch GmbH


Reemtsma Cigarettenfabriken GmbH


Imperial Tobacco Group


Mando Corporation


Nerudia


Carl Zeiss AG


Thyssenkrupp AG


SITECH Sitztechnik GmbH


ELMOS Semiconductor SE


Gira Giersiepen GmbH & Co. KG


Rolls-Royce Motor Cars Ltd.


Danfoss GmbH


Insta GmbH


Eppendorf SE


Work highlights


  • Advising Samsung Group on patent applications.

  • Advising Volkswagen AG on patent applications.

Jones Day

Jones Day houses a specialist patent attorney unit that has established a strong reputation in the healthcare, pharmaceutical and life sciences sectors. Embedded within the firm's global network, the group is also well equipped for cross-border matters and large disputes. Olga Bezzubova, who acts as co-head of the firm's global patent prosecution practice as well as head of the German team, has particular experience in the life sciences sector. Dorothée Weber-Bruls is responsible for physics and is further adept in mechanical engineering matters.

Practice head(s):

Olga Bezzubova; Dorothée Weber-Bruls


Other key lawyers:

Andreas Holzwarth-Rochford; Sven Rihm; Gerd Jaekel; Christian Paul


Testimonials

‘Dorothée Weber-Bruls is knowledgeable.’

‘Very good understanding of the subject matter in terms of content and technology.’

‘Gerd Jaekel: Very good understanding of content and technology. Can assess risks pragmatically and make according recommendations to the client.’

Key clients

Akebia Therapeutics, Inc.


Keryx Biopharmaceuticals


Genentech, Inc.


Rational AG


Motherson Group


Sunrise Medical


Blickle Räder + Rollen GmbH u. Co. KG


MSA Dafety


Convex Universal Limited


CYLANCE Inc.


Ensyn Renewables


Tektronix


Blickle Räder + Rollen GmbH u. Co. KG


Quarkstar


Samvardhana


Work highlights


  • Advising Keryx on its patent portfolio for products in the field of chronic kidney disease.

  • Representing Genentech in patent applications and opposition proceedings as well as advising on contractual issues relating to German and European patents in connection with a collaboration agreement with BioNTech.

  • Advising a semiconductor manufacturer and provider of mobile communications products in patent grant proceedings with regard to potential future infringement proceedings.

Lorenz Seidler Gossel

Munich-based IP boutique Lorenz Seidler Gossel assists large corporations, medium-sized companies and start-ups with patent litigation and prosecution and demonstrates special technical expertise in the automotive, medical technology, process engineering and mechanical engineering sectors, among others. Wolfgang Behr, who is primarily active in opposition proceedings before the EPO, is considered a key contact, as is chemical sector expert Robert Frick.

Other key lawyers:

Wolfgang Behr; Robert Frick; Dieter Laufhütte


Testimonials

‘Thanks to decades of collaboration, there is a very good mutual understanding of respective structures and business or matter processes, which makes the organisation of our collaboration much easier.’

‘Due to a small number of personnel changes and having the same contact for many years, the firm has developed a deep knowledge of our products and, as a result, we have a great deal of trust in its consulting services. The control effort is therefore also low.’

‘Dieter Laufhütte: Very experienced, pleasant collaboration, well connected, sound and practical advice.’

Key clients

Liebherr Group


Fresenius Medical Care


Mazda Motor Corp.


Marantec Antriebs- und Steuerungstechnik


Ford-Werke GmbH


Murata


GE Transportation Systems


SK-Group


Alois Pöttinger Maschinenfabrik


Fibertex Personal Care


Fibertex Nonwovens A/S


Contemporary Amperex Technology


CRRC Changung Railway Vehicles


ProSiebenSat1


Gebrüder Martin GmbH & Co.KG


Kwon KG


Komptech GmbH


bulthaup


Maag


Tanos GmbH


KSB SE & Co. KGaA


Faun


Windmöller und Hölscher KG


dy-pack Verpackungen


Geox S.p.A.


Varian Medical Systems


Allianz Konzern


Amoena Medizin-Orthopädie-Technik


Asis GmbH


Binderholz Bausysteme GmbH


Braun GmbH


BUK Management GmbH


Carl Zeiss Optotechnik GmbH


DSM Nutritional Products Ltd.


Entrotech, Inc.


Bartenbach Lichtlabor


Braun GmbH


Gebrüder Martin


KLS Martin Group


Metasys Medizintechnik GmbH


Michalski - Hüttermann & Partner Patentanwälte

From its offices in Düsseldorf, Essen, Munich and Frankfurt, Michalski - Hüttermann & Partner Patentanwälte assists German and international clients with patent applications, portfolio management and forensic matters. Nullity and infringement proceedings represent additional strengths. Life sciences, particularly in relation to therapeutic antibodies, are a focus for Ulrich Storz, while Stefan Michalski offers experience in chemistry, pharmacy and materials science.

Other key lawyers:

Dirk Schulz; Stefan Michalski; Guido Quiram; Ulrich Storz; Wasilis Koukounis; Deborah Meyer; Kevin Lamberts; Rolf Claessen; Dirk Schulz; Andreas Gröschel; Uwe Albersmeyer


Testimonials

‘Ulrich Storz: Friendly, competent, creative, effective.’

‘Experienced and cost-optimised law firm with a lot of practical experience, which flows directly into the consultation, but is also brought into written and oral proceedings. ‘

‘Patent lawyer Guido Quiram, always very well-informed and a massive source of support in disputes, and his additional qualifications in business administration make him an excellent contact when it comes to cost optimisation.’

Key clients

Immatics


Hitachi Power Grids


Deutsche Post


DHL


Ecolab


Novaled


Philips


Bayer


Wilo


CLASSEN Group


Flender GmbH


TK Elevator


General Motors


Heye International


ThalesAlenia Space


Quanta Computer


Universitäten NRW


Miele


dSpace


Aumund Gruppe


FLSmidth


Work highlights


  • Advising Immatics Biotechnologies GmbH on all patent attorney matters, including the global management of patent grant procedures.

Prüfer & Partner

Opposition and audit proceedings form just as much a part of Prüfer & Partner's daily case load as does the preparation of patent applications for the German and international markets; here, the team is particularly active for clients from the US, Japan, China and South Korea. Dorothea Hofer (physics, medical technology, electronics), Jürgen Feldmeier (vehicle technology, medical technology, sports equipment) and Andreas Oser (chemistry, pharmaceuticals, life sciences, biotechnology) jointly head the practice.

Practice head(s):

Dorothea Hofer; Jürgen Feldmeier; Andreas Oser


Other key lawyers:

Christian Einsel; Christian Gärtner; Susanne Sonnenhauser


Testimonials

‘Collaboration at eye level, courteous, experts in every area that affects us.’

‘Excellent cooperation, well-trained and efficient team.’

‘Collaboration at eye level, which is very valuable. Abstract topics are explained in a way (and several times with great patience) that we always find a way to protect an innovation appropriately or to be able to enforce an intellectual property right.’

‘The overall level of service is excellent. Response is always very quick and appropriate and the ability to understand and analyse legal and technical issues is sufficiently high.’

‘The team around Jürgen Feldmeier and Dorothea Hofer is highly qualified and very agile. Dealing with colleagues is also very pleasant on a human level. Communication is fluid and very transparent both in terms of cost structure and in terms of practical feasibility and next steps. We are very satisfied with the collaboration with our colleagues.’

‘Jürgen Feldmeier is technically strong, very practical, and offers regular follow-ups on the status.’

‘Dorothea Hofer: Very well versed in technicalities, very complete assessments of legal issues.’

‘I really appreciate Jürgen Feldmeier because he has exceptional professional expertise and is always solution-oriented and very friendly in his direct client contact.’

Key clients

EOS GmbH Electro Optical Systems


Biedermann Technologies GmbH & Co. KG


Brother Industries, Ltd.


Multipond Wägetechnik GmbH


Hymmen GmbH Maschinen und Anlagenbau


Freiberger Compound Materials


Knorr Bremse AG


Heidolph Instruments GmbH & Co. KG


Toray Industries


Terumo Corporation


Knauf Insulation


BHS Technologies


Nipro Corporation


Heusch GmbH


QRSkin GmbH


CloudMinds (Shanghai) Robotics Co. Ltd.


Everspin Corp.


SK On Co., Ltd.


SK Innovation


SK Inc.


Webasto SE


Industry-University Cooperation Foundation Hanyang University


LOESCH Verpackungstechnik GmbH + Co. KG


SANDEN CORPORATION


ASAHI SEIKO CO., LTD.


Tsann Kuen (Zhangzhou) Enterprise Co., Ltd


Evomedis GmbH


ViiV Healthcare UK (No. 3) Limited


Novartis Group


Korea Research Institute of Chemical Technology


Toppan Printing Co., Ltd.


Suzhou Abogen Biosciences Co., Ltd.


A.L.M.T. Corp.


Microbium D.o.o.


Japan Aviation Electronics. Ind. Ltd.


Abestype Ltd.


Qubig GmbH


Work highlights


  • Advice from SK On Co., Ltd. in patent applications in Europe as well as on strategic and portfolio issues.

  • Advice and support for Hymmen GmbH Maschinen- und Anlagenbau on global patent strategy, including invention research, opposition proceedings and active and passive dispute proceedings.

Simmons & Simmons

Not least due to the firm's global reach, Simmons & Simmons is considered a popular address for large international corporations seeking advice on patent prosecution, although it also has experience in proceedings before German and European offices. Stephanie Nottrott's expertise reflects the practice's internal focus on pharmaceuticals and life sciences; she jointly leads the practice with Fritz Lahrtz, who focuses on biotechnology, chemistry and pharmaceuticals and frequently advises on matters relating to antibody technology.

Practice head(s):

Stephanie Nottrott; Fritz Lahrtz


Key clients

Roche Diagnostics


Chugai


Beam Therapeutics


Celanese


Pohl-Boskamp


Agenus


ImmunoGen


Fujifilm Cellular Dynamics


Magforce


Merus N.V.


Cellectis


PROvendis


c-LEcta


Genomatica


Dizal (Jiangsu) Pharmaceutical


Molecular Health


Work highlights


  • Advising and representing Roche Diagnostics and Chugai in various patent audit proceedings before the European and international patent offices.

  • Advising Celanese on the prosecution of its polymer chemistry IP portfolio, including opposition proceedings.

  • Representation of Beam Therapeutics in audit proceedings before the European Patent Office.

Weickmann & Weickmann

Weickmann & Weickmann, one of the oldest patent law firms in Germany, specialises in patent advice related to mechanics, electrical engineering, IT and life sciences. In addition to traditional proceedings and registrations, the practice also assists with protection certificates and utility models. Markus Herzog, who is experienced in the field of mechanical engineering, jointly leads the team with Wolfgang Weiß, who frequently acts in opposition proceedings and patent grant procedures before the DPMA and the EPO.

Practice head(s):

Markus Herzog; Wolfgang Weiß


Other key lawyers:

Frank Feller; Brigitte Böhm; Hans Weickmann; Manuel Millahn; Volker Jordan; Christian Heubeck


Testimonials

‘Excellent support from the law firm, especially from Christian Heubeck! Technological understanding.’

‘Christian Heubeck is extremely knowledgeable and efficiently helps to protect technology through worldwide patents.’

‘We found the W&W team to be very experienced and complementary; we noticed excellent team dynamics, particularly in the area of ​​chemistry/life sciences. W&W is also heavily involved in the start-up scene and holds seminars and events.’

Key clients

Algoriddim


Amistec


Apogenix GmbH


Beijing Baidu Netcom Science and Technology Co., Ltd.


BHS Sonthofen GmbH


DYWIDAG-Systems International GmbH


Emergence Therapeutics AG


Evanium Healthcare


Goldhofer AG


Heidelberg Pharma


Honda Motor Co., Ltd


Invitris


Kemijski Institut


Lilium


MAB Discovery


Max-Planck-Innovation


Media Pharma


Oberalp Gruppe (Salewa, Dynafit)


Otto Bihler Maschinenfabrik GmbH & Co. KG


Peter & Traudl Engelhorn-Stiftung


Rapitag GmbH


SERDAR PLASTIK


Serum Institute of India


SOMIC Verpackungsmaschinen GmbH & Co. KG


Work highlights


  • Advising Amistec GmbH on the complete takeover of a portfolio and supervision of all applications to the EPO.

  • Advising Honda Motor Co. Ltd on patent applications nationally and abroad as well as applications before the EPO.

  • Advising AMG Lithium GmbH on strategic issues and registrations worldwide.

Zimmermann & Partner Patentanwälte mbB

Zimmermann & Partner Patentanwälte mbB particularly impresses with its forensic expertise, but also offers competencies in portfolio management and registration procedures. The group is regularly instructed by large international corporations and German medium-sized companies; central members of the team include Frank Steinbach (medical devices, energy technology, materials science), Jan Hornung (semiconductor technology, automotive technology, electronics) and Gerd Zimmermann and Dominique Gobert, who both specialise in physics.

Other key lawyers:

Dominique Gobert; Frank Steinbach; Benedikt Neuburger; Gerd Zimmermann; Joel Nägerl; Jan Hornung; Christian Ginzel


Testimonials

‘Due to his practical experience, Christian Ginzel has unparalleled technical knowledge in the field of network and computer technology. Thanks to his balanced and calm nature, he can argue very convincingly before authorities.’

‘The team at Zimmermann & Partner is great when it comes to strategic portfolio management. The granting process is managed so skillfully that granted patents have great value for our company.’

Bals & Vogel

Bals & Vogel's patent advice strongly focuses on engineering sciences, while the team also houses expertise in other fields such as medical technology, IT and life sciences. Key contacts include patent lawyers Andreas Vogel, Rüdiger Bals and Kai Kuhlmann, who all specialise in mechanical engineering, chemistry and biotechnology expert Katharina Klasen and Kai Klein, who is adept in mechanical engineering, electrical engineering and software.

Practice head(s):

Andreas Vogel; Rüdiger Bals; Kai Kuhlmann; Katharina Klasen; Kai Klein


Testimonials

‘The cooperation with the firm is excellent. Urgent patent applications are prepared and submitted in short amounts of time. On administrative level, the firm adapts ideally to the client’s circumstances – thus digital correspondence and invoice processing are tailored to the needs of our company. Accessibility is always guaranteed by representative regulation.’

‘Circumstances are quickly grasped. Interaction with inventors is also impeccable.’

‘The team demonstrates a remarkable attention to detail and always offers our clients viable solutions, especially when dealing with complex issues.’

Key clients

EON AG


Windmöller & Hölscher KG


Siemens Healthineers


Huf Hülsbeck GmbH


Vorwerk & Co. Interholding GmbH


Oerlikon Surface Solutions AG


Drägerwerk AG & Co. KGaA


Ardex GmbH


ASM Assembly Systems GmbH & Co. KG


Robert Bosch GmbH


Piller Blowers & Compressors GmbH


CARIAD SE


Evident Technology Center Europe


Work highlights


  • Advising Huf Hülsbeck GmbH in the context of DE, EP and PCT filing activities in the automotive sector, including representation in opposition proceedings and appeal proceedings before the EPO and the DPMA; also advice on various issues such as the assessment of patent competition situations, infringement analyzes and FTOs.

  • Advising EON AG, in particular on new applications, opposition proceedings before the German and European Patent Offices as well as infringement analyses and litigation matters.

  • Advising Oerlikon Surface Solution AG on the preparation of patent applications and managing the patent portfolio in more than ten different jurisdictions; also FTOs and assessment of third-party property rights.

BRAUN-DULLAEUS PANNEN EMMERLING

In addition to its strong dispute resolution practice, BRAUN-DULLAEUS PANNEN EMMERLING is also active on prosecution level, where it assists with applications and represents clients in nullity and infringement proceedings before authorities such as the DPMA and EPO. Karl-Ulrich Braun-Dullaeus, who has longstanding experience particularly in the telecommunications sector, jointly heads the practice with Friedrich Emmerling, whose technical focus includes semiconductor technology, mobile communications and software. Further support comes from Dirk Müssig, who is experienced in patent grant procedures and opposition proceedings.

Practice head(s):

Karl-Ulrich Braun-Dullaeus; Friedrich Emmerling


Other key lawyers:

Franck Klein; Markus Kreuzberg; Dirk Müssig


Testimonials

‘For me, BDPE stands for quality work that we can always rely on. For me, quality is not only defined by convincing arguments in terms of content, but also by very good service, the firm’s good technical equipment and fast response times.’

‘We experience real team players at all levels who are pleasant to work with. It is difficult to find such a good team of patent attorneys, particularly in the areas of telecommunications, video and audio coding and semiconductor technology.’

‘Friedrich Emmerling can provide actual strategic advice due to his excellent technical understanding and wealth of experience. In my opinion, having an eye for the “bigger picture” while simultaneously knowing the details is what sets him apart from many others.’

‘Karl-Ulrich Braun-Dullaeus can also explain very complex technological contexts in a generally understandable way. In my experience, he was often able to develop decisive arguments, especially when working together in large joint defense groups.’

Key clients

Deutsche Telekom AG


Hochland SE


Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.


VVG-Befestigungstechnik GmbH & Co. KG


Honsel Umformtechnik GmbH


Rhodius Schleifwerkzeuge GmbH & Co. KG


SICAT GmbH & Co KG


Systec POS-Technology GmbH


Systec Controls


Conradi + Kaiser GmbH


Adidas AG


Shenzhen Goodix


SMART BATTERY SOLUTIONS GmbH


JANOVA GmbH


Work highlights


  • Advising Deutsche Telekom AG on patent applications (PCT, DPMA and EPA).

  • Advising SMART BATTERY SOLUTIONS GmbH on patent applications (PCT, DPMA and EPA).

  • Advising Hochland SE on patent applications (PCT, DPMA and EPA).

HGF Europe LLP

HGF Europe LLP manages and defends patent portfolios, particularly within the electrical engineering, materials and life sciences and software sectors, for a client portfolio consisting of medium-sized and international companies. Markus Zoller is primarily active in the life sciences sphere, while Jan Robert Naefe focuses on materials science and Bernhard Ganahl on physics and engineering.

Practice head(s):

Markus Zoller; Bernhard Ganahl; Jan Robert Naefe


Testimonials

‘Great and easy to use.’

‘Wide area of ​​technology covered. International focus with colleagues from many different jurisdictions.’

‘Patent attorney Bernhard Ganahl has outstanding technical knowledge in his field and can use this excellently to assess the state of the art. He is very well connected, including with technical institutions such as the Technical University of Munich. He is able to convey technical conditions clearly, very structured and reliable, also with regards to informing the client.’

Key clients

Emporia Telecom GmbH & Co. KG.


voestalpine AG


SIAG


Agraferm GmbH


Aalberts Advanced Mechatronics


Syntrac GmbH


TPI Technologies Inc.


Kurtz GmbH


Work highlights


  • Ongoing advice to Voestalpine on the filing of numerous patent applications and oppositions.

  • Advising Emporia on patent applications and FRAND license negotiations.

Karo IP

In addition to extensive support of German and European clients, Karo IP has a strong geographical focus on Japan and China. Matters relating to mechanical engineering as well as automotive and vehicle technology are some of the main areas of expertise of Matthias Rößler and Justus Kreuels, both of whom advise on portfolio management as well as on IP enforcement and defense.

Other key lawyers:

Justus Kreuels, Matthias Rößler; Dietmar Haug; Tobias Stelzer


Testimonials

‘Reliable and quick handling of topics. Very well structured law firm.’

‘As a patent attorney, Justus Kreuels has a very high level of technological, legal and economic expertise.’

Key clients

Clyde Bergemann Power Group


GKN Driveline


GKN Sinter Metals


Baumot Group AG


RWTH Aachen University


Volkswagen AG


Hanza GmbH


Vaillant GmbH


Atlas Copco Holding GmbH


Tesona GmbH


ZWILLING J.A. Henckels AG


Lixil Group Corporation


Shandong Lianfa Medical Plastic Products Co., Ltd


Ventinova Medical B.V.


Ardagh Metal Beverage Europe GmbH


Hongyun Honghe Tobacco (Group) Co., Ltd.


Nantong Ant Machinery Co., Ltd.


China Petroleum & Chemical Corporation


Shandong Caiju Electronic Technology Co., Ltd


Wear Future Technologies Co., Ltd


DELCOTEX Delius Techtex GmbH & Co. KG


Bucher Hydraulics AG


WBH Wachenhausen

WBH Wachenhausen demonstrates expertise in the development and defense of portfolios and places a particular focus on engineering patents. The practice is headed by a trio of experts: Marc Wachenhausen and Thorsten Haslinde are primarily experienced in medical technology and mechanical engineering, while Benjamin Bubendorfer mainly advises on information and communication technology.

Practice head(s):

Marc Wachenhausen; Benjamin Bubendorfer; Thorsten Haslinde


Testimonials

‘Pragmatic and hands-on, they can take on big challenges at any time.’

‘Marc Wachenhausen is a clever strategist.’

‘Excellent patent law firm with partners Marc Wachenhausen, Thorsten Haslinde and Benjamin Bubendorfer. High-end patent law advice with outstanding expertise, particularly in the areas of medical devices, mechanics, software and sensor technology. Very service minded.’

Key clients

Crown Equipment Corporation


Neovasc Inc.


AVEVA Group plc.


ZTE Corporation


HTC Germany GmbH


Thule Sweden AB


MB Digitalprint GmbH & Co. KG


Optical Imaging Ltd.


Syntace GmbH


Procept Biorobotics Corporation


U-Shin Deutschland Zugangssysteme GmbH


Rheinisch-Westfälische Technische Hochschule


Biolase Inc.


TQ Systems GmbH


GoPro, Inc.


Neural DSP Technologies Oy


Work highlights


  • Strategic advice to Crown Equipment Corporation with regard to application procedures, new product launches and risk management as well as coordination of individual country-specific proceedings (Germany, EU, USA, Asia).

  • Advised Neovasc Inc. on all intellectual property matters, including building an IP portfolio, clearance issues and representation in over 30 opposition and appeal proceedings before the EPO.

  • Advising AVEVA Group plc. in connection with software patents and their patentability as well as the adaptation of cases for the European Patent Office (EP) taking into account current case law, for example in the area of ​​simulation.