Firms To Watch: Dispute resolution

BHSM LLP has an established team of senior dispute resolution specialists that have landed a series of headline engagements, including insolvency cases and judicial review matters. Brian Baily leads the team and Mark Homan is noted for contentious insolvency matters.
Dentons Ireland is building its standing in the dispute resolution field, having hired Karyn Harty  as head of the team from McCann FitzGerald LLP in September 2022. She links up with Gareth Steen , an insolvency and restructuring specialist, who has broader experience in a variety of litigation matters.
DLA Piper Ireland LLP is making an impression in big-ticket disputes, including regulatory matters, product liability cases and judicial review proceedings. A team led by Caoimhe Clarkin recently acted for Greencoat Capital in challenging a decision by the State energy regulator on the implementation of a regulation under the EU’s Clean Energy Package.

Firms in the Spotlight Dispute resolution

Anne O'Connell Solicitors

Anne O'Connell Solicitors logo

Anne O’Connell Solicitors (AOC Solicitors) is a leading and award-winning Irish specialist Employment Law firm which was established in 2017 by our Principal, Anne O’Connell.

View Profile...

Dispute resolution in Ireland

A&L Goodbody LLP

A&L Goodbody LLP has one of the largest teams in the market, which incorporates a large group of investigations specialists. The firm has particular strength in representing financial services clients in regulatory investigations. Along with major regulatory investigations, the firm continues to be active in big-ticket tax disputes, antitrust damages actions and real estate cases, among others. Enda Hurley  heads the litigation department and co-heads the disputes and investigations group. Dario Dagostino leads the regulatory risks and investigations group and Joe Kelly  co-heads the fraud and white-collar crime team. Tom Casey has a fine reputation in financial services, commercial property and shareholder disputes, and Sarah Murphy is another emerging talent. Eileen Roberts  became a High Court judge in July 2022.

Practice head(s):

Enda Hurley; Dario Dagostino


Other key lawyers:

Joe Kelly; Tom Casey; Ciarán Ó’Conluain; Sarah Murphy; Linda Collins


Testimonials

‘Working with A&L Goodbody’s dispute resolution practice was a pleasure. The team is extremely efficient and thorough. Additionally, the team is made up of young lawyers who work well with their partners.’

‘Sarah Murphy – an exceptional leader and mentor. Linda Collins – promising young lawyer.’

Key clients

Perrigo Company


MAN Truck


Mercer


Irish Airlines Pensions Trustee


Via Medica International Healthcare LLC


CBRE


ED&F Man Liquid Products (Ireland) Limited


Development Bank of South Africa


Castlethorn Construction Unlimited Company


SafeCharge Card Services Limited


Leslie Buckley


Permanent TSB Plc


Volkswagen Group


Irish Aviation Authority


Work highlights


  • Advised Perrigo on its challenge of a €1.6bn tax assessment by the Irish Revenue and on its successful settlement of that assessment for less than 19% of the demand.
  • Advised AIB and EBS on the settlement of long-running regulatory investigations into the banks’ historic withdrawal of tracker mortgage products and ongoing defence of customer litigation relating to the same issues.
  • Acted for MAN Truck, in its defence of over 60 Irish High Court claims seeking damages for losses arising from alleged cartel activity following a European Commission finding that MAN and other truck manufacturers shared pricing information with each other for an extended period between 1997 and 2011.

Arthur Cox

Arthur Cox is a long-term leader in litigation, dispute resolution and investigations. This includes banking and financial services, real estate, tax and white-collar/corporate crime matters. It has continued to take a leading role in many regulatory investigations and statutory inquiries, and has a well-developed arbitration practice. Eve Mulconry heads the litigation, dispute resolution and investigations team, and is noted for commercial and financial services disputes. Andrew Lenny is another senior practitioner who has landed a series of big engagements in antitrust cases and financial regulatory investigations. Joanelle O’Cleirigh is co-head of the white-collar crime and compliance group. Keith Smith continues to impress in real estate disputes. Amelia Walsh was promoted to of counsel in 2021.

Practice head(s):

Eve Mulconry


Other key lawyers:

Andrew Lenny; Joanelle O’Cleirigh; Richard Willis; Keith Smith; Michael Twomey; Deirdre O’Mahony; Ryan Ferry; Amelia Walsh; Sean Carroll; Michael Egan; Kate O’Donohoe; Andrew Lenny; Conall O’Shaughnessy; Tara Roche; Naoise Cosgrove


Testimonials

‘Keith Smith’s experience shows through his excellent judgement of a situation, incorporating legal issues but also the assessment of softer issues in his advice and conduct and management of a case.’

‘Strongest team in the Irish market. Strength across the partner group with a number of standout practitioners and also exceptional associates. The go to firm for bet the ranch cases. Full back up of technology and subject matter experts throughout the firm. Also very progressive in terms of diversity and csr/esg.’

‘Eve Mulconry’s team is the top litigation team in the country. Quite simply they are the go-to team for large scale commercial disputes. Go to Eve and you will get results. Its that simple. Incredibly hardworking and willing to challenge the system and accepted thinking to pursue clients’ objectives.’

‘Eve Mulconry is very diligent and available to her clients. Cutting edge advice and very respected by her peers.’

‘Excellent team, rapid response, excellent advice, strong team continuity, extremely well-organised, excellent business partner’

‘Andy Lenny and Conall O’Shaughnessy – Outstanding individuals, excellent in depth advice, breadth of vision, work in partnership with the business.’

‘Arthur Cox stand out. Eve Mulconry and her team’s ability to acquire in-depth understanding of our commercial and operational requirements is exceptional. They are incredibly responsive, appreciate that commercial and operational challenges must be factored into any legal solutions proposed, and have a proven ability to deliver practical, straightforward, objective driven legal advice.’

‘Tara Roche and Naoise Cosgrove should be commended on their responsiveness, in particular in recognition of their ability to advise a fast-paced company like ours. They have worked very well with us and have applied strategic solutions where required.’

Key clients

AB Volvo


Bank of Ireland


Central Bank of Ireland


Chanelle Pharma


CRH plc and Roadstone Limited


daa


Davy Target Investments PLC


Dawn Meats Ireland Unlimited Company


Facebook Ireland Limited


Hines Real Estate


The Clunetech Group


Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Limited (In Special Liquidation)


Island Capital Management Limited


KBC Bank plc


Marlet Property Group


McKesson Corporation


Ulster Bank DAC


MCD Productions


Green Property Group


Davy Hickey Properties


Religious Sisters of Charity


Ryanair DAC


Work highlights


  • Represented Ryanair in a range of cases including multi-jurisdictional screen scraping litigation and Forsa litigation.
  • Represented Hines Real Estate Ireland in defending three cases challenging the planning permission for over 1,100 residential units in Dublin city centre.
  • Acted for Volvo and Renault Trucks in defending competition law damages actions in Ireland.

Mason Hayes & Curran LLP

Mason Hayes & Curran LLP has a prestigious history in dispute resolution with a huge market share of litigation cases before the Irish courts. While its depth of resources has allowed the firm to develop specialist expertise in a wide range of cases, and it remains particularly known for financial services, technology, life sciences, real estate and energy disputes. Public law cases are another forte for the firm that is also noted for investigations and white-collar criminal law. Maurice Phelan is a senior figure in commercial disputes and insolvency cases. Liam Guidera  heads the investigations and white-collar crime team, while Colin Monaghan is an emerging talent in technology and other disputes. Peter Johnston is another ‘stand out‘ partner. Sinéad Power has left the firm.

Practice head(s):

Maurice Phelan


Other key lawyers:

Liam Guidera; Colin Monaghan; Colm Farrell; Peter Johnston; Frank Flanagan; James Morrin; Niall Michel; Aoiffe Moran; Gearoid Carey


Testimonials

‘The MHC Dispute Resolution team has an expert to match every type of dispute and you will always be well looked after. They will know your business and prioritise your commercial needs. Advice will be focused and clear.’

‘Maurice Phelan is a go to lawyer in Ireland for restructuring and insolvency work. Liam Guidera has the nous, skill and temperament to deliver a favourable solution in shareholder disputes and investigations. Colin Monaghan is an astute and energetic advisor who will guide you to your goal in a commercial manner. Gearoid Carey is very effective in delivering results in a calm and understated manner.’

‘Colin Monaghan has been an exceptional external counsel for the business over the years – his deep understanding and appreciation of what we want to achieve (along with an emphasis on finding workable solutions) has allowed him to become a trusted adviser to us.’

‘The Dispute Resolution team operates in a very collaborative manner with us as clients. They work hard, are responsive and communicate very well throughout each case. Professionally they demonstrate a deep understanding of the technical facts of the cases. They are also very approachable and personable in their dealings with our organisation. Working together has been an enjoyable experience and I have no hesitation in recommending them to others.’

‘It is a pleasure to work with partner Niall Michel, associate Aoiffe Moran and their team. They are readily able to pick up difficult, technical points of environmental and regulatory law and analysis. They take time to understand our perspective and to provide commercial advice.’

‘Colin Monaghan is approachable and available at all times to go through cases he’s involved with on our behalf. His advice is exceptional and practical which is needed in my industry.’

‘James Morrin, in particular, goes the extra mile. Always contactable and willing to provide our business with a clear and concise overview of the case. His recommendations set out the risks associated with the various approaches and always puts his preferred route forward.’

‘Maurice Phelan is a leader in the insolvency field and as head of the department, he demands and maintains a consistent service level from all the team. Peter Johnson is a stand-out partner, extremely knowledgeable and responsive and always calm in the face of complex and urgent commercial demand. His assistance to me on a particular matter was timely and managed to cut through the legal technicalities, getting quickly to the root of the issue and an appropriate solution for us.’

Key clients

WhatsApp Ireland Limited


Coolmore Stud and Ballydoyle Racing


EBS DAC


Morgan Stanley & Credit Suisse


Commission for Communications Regulation


Meridian Global VAT Services


Roots System Holding Company Limited


Ardstone Homes Limited and Ardstone Partners ICAV


West Pharmaceutical Services, Inc.


Bank of Scotland plc


Lidl Ireland Gmbh


Work highlights


  • Advised WhatsApp on its various appeals following the decision of the Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC) to impose a fine of €225m and certain other measures against it at the conclusion of an inquiry into its compliance with GDPR transparency requirements.
  • Acted for EBS in its successful defence of an alleged wrongful termination of contracts claim brought by Betty Martin Financial Service.

Matheson LLP

Matheson LLP has a substantial team of senior, middle-ranking and junior practitioners. It remains at the forefront of financial services disputes, regulatory enforcement and investigations. It is further building its presence in technology, data and privacy disputes, and is a leader in insurance coverage cases. It is also making an impression in competition damages actions. The firm has a significant market share of cases before the Irish commercial court. The commercial litigation group is led by Nicola Dunleavy SC, along with Julie Murphy-O’Connor, who impresses in asset recovery, insolvency and other commercial disputes, and Tony O’Grady . Karen Reynolds specialises in financial services disputes and regulatory investigations. April McClements is an expert in insurance disputes and Michael Byrne is prominent in TMT cases.

Practice head(s):

Julie Murphy O’Connor; Nicola Dunleavy; Tony O’Grady


Other key lawyers:

Angela Brennan; Karen Reynolds; April McClements; Michael Byrne; Ruadhán Kenny


Testimonials

‘Full engagement from the team over many years. The continuity of staff also saves time and energy in every new situation and at the same time ensures that prior experiences are fully used and taken advantage of. That several individuals are involved also give needed back-up when the relationship lasts for many years.’

‘Nicola Dunleavy has been a key person for us for many years. Her engagement and high knowledge and smart thinking is very valuable.’

‘Ruadhán Kenny, has been very involved the last years. His engagement, commitment and knowledge is very important for us.’

Key clients

Mediahuis Ireland Group Limited (formerly Independent News and Media)


Opel Automobile GmbH, Vauxhall Motors Limited and Opel Ireland Limited (now Leeson Motors Limited) (all part of or related to the Stellantis Group)


Snowsports Association of Ireland


Revolut Limited


Citibank NA and Citibank Europe Plc


Aviva


Discord


Iveco Group N.V., CNH Industrial N.V. and Stellantis N.V


AbbVie, Inc.


Deal Partners Logistics Limited and Thomondview Trust Limited


Work highlights


  • Acted for a number of aviation businesses in claims for coverage in relation to irrecoverable aircraft.
  • Defended Iveco Group, CNH Industrial and Stellantis in a significant number of High Court Irish claims following on from the European Commission’s decision to fine truck producers €2.93bn for participating in a cartel.
  • Advised Mediahuis Ireland Group (formerly Independent News and Media) in its defence and resolution of multiple sets of proceedings issued by high profile former senior executives, journalists and employees arising out of the ODCE and DPC Investigation into a data security incident and the subsequent inspection by High Court appointed inspectors to the company.

McCann FitzGerald LLP

McCann FitzGerald LLP has an established and large team of dispute resolution professionals that continue to impress in financial services and insurance disputes, regulatory enforcement and investigations, and other commercial disputes. It has extensive experience in commercial court litigation and is also noted for its expertise in public law cases. The highly acclaimed Helen Kilroy and financial services disputes leader Rosaleen Byrne are at the top of the profession, with Catherine Derrig  also making an impression in regulatory matters and competition damages actions. Brian Quigley  is highly rated for insurance disputes, and Ciara Ryan is noted for real estate cases. Roddy Bourke  is recommended for product liability litigation. Senior associates Bébhinn Bollard and Amy Brick are also praised by clients.

Practice head(s):

Michael Murphy; Ciara Ryan


Other key lawyers:

Michelle Doyle; Rosaleen Byrne; Helen Kilroy; Brian Quigley; Audrey Byrne; Catherine Derrig; Michael Coonan; Amy Brick; Bébhinn Bollard; Marie-Alice Cleary


Testimonials

‘The McCanns team working on our client’s high profile and significant commercial litigation has been consistently innovative, hyper-responsive/accessible and focused in moving the matter forward. They are head and shoulders one of the best commercial litigation groups I have encountered over years of working in Ireland.’

‘Amy Brick is a rising star. Exceptional ability and huge commitment to her clients.’

‘Brian Quigley is not only a leading authority in his field, but he takes the time to sit with you as a client, to explain the nature of the problem, sets out clearly the pitfalls and weakness in your case, sets out the roadmap to take, and gives you a great sense that the decisions taken are your decisions and are taken with all the relevant facts.’

‘Rosaleen Byrne, Brian Quigley and Catherine Derrig are stand-out partners in this area. Rosaleen Byrne is the leader in her field of competition law, in particular. Marie-Alice Cleary is a talented and exceptionally dedicated associate.’

‘Ciara Ryan (Partner) is an excellent tactician, who always has an impressive command of the detail of tricky cases.’

‘Audrey Byrne has a comprehensive knowledge of difficult commercial litigation, and has a strong established expertise in cross border matters. She is a strong strategic thinker and works very well with clients and counsel to build an overall response to challenging situations. For Audrey, the client always comes first and she provides a really comprehensive level of care and service. Michael Coonan is an extremely impressive lawyer, combining a huge ability to command detail with a very thoughtful consideration of overall strategy and objectives. Michael has very strong interpersonal skills and has a real dedication to working with clients to identify and achieve best outcomes. Bébhinn Bollard is an extremely hard working associate who has a wealth of experience in commercial litigation. She has acted in some of the most complex commercial disputes, particularly in cases with a cross border element. She combines very strong legal skills with a commitment to clients, and maintains a cool head in the most demanding situations.’

‘Rosaleen Byrne – fights every corner for client – very savvy and commercially astute – 100% first pick for banking and telecoms regulation. Catherine Derrig – always gets it just right – sound judgment on the big and small issues and excellent team motivator – goes the extra mile for her clients. Helen Kilroy – steady hand on tiller particularly for commercial mediation. Always gets a result.’

‘Michael Coonan–always creative, focused and responsive, he has been a great leader on the MF team on this matter. Whenever we have needed him, whether during the business day, the evening or a weekend, he has made himself available and provided guiding expertise. On a personal side, Michael is a wonderful colleague to work with on such an interesting and challenging matter. His associate team is equally good.’

Key clients

Altum Capital Management LLC


Central Bank of Ireland


Commission for Communications Regulation


DAF Trucks NV and DAF Trucks Deutschland GmbH


Davy Hickey


Dublin Airport Authority plc


Galway County Council


General Motors


Grunenthal GmbH


Hypertrust Limited (part of the Loyola Group), Aberken Limited (part of the Chris Kelly Group)


Irish Bank Resolution Corporation (in Special Liquidation)


Malin Corporation plc


Marlet Property Group


Mediahuis Ireland Group Limited


National Transport Authority


Ronan Real Estate Group Limited


Sea-Fisheries Protection Authority


The Sellers of Barracuda FX Limited


The Voluntary Health Insurance Board


Trafalgar Trafhold Limited, Instantania Holdings Limited, Kamara Limited and Bairiki Incorporated


Transport Infrastructure Ireland


Twitter


Work highlights


  • Acted for the plaintiffs in two of the four test cases heard by the Commercial Court relating to policy holders’ entitlements to business interruption cover under policies held with FBD Insurance following the outbreak of Covid-19.
  • Acted for Mediahuis Ireland Group in a range of regulatory challenges, including an investigation by the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, the appointment of Companies Act Inspectors to the company by the High Court, an investigation by the Office of the Data Protection Commission and a series of large data subject access requests.
  • Acted for the National Transport Authority on its role as a National Enforcement Body and in connection with a resolution of Commercial Court proceedings taken by Irish Ferries against a decision made by the NTA under the Maritime Regulation.

William Fry LLP

William Fry LLP has a prestigious history in the dispute resolution field and continues to act for clients in numerous landmark and high-value disputes. The firm is also a growing force in contentious regulatory and investigations matters, and is building its name in planning and environmental disputes; Conor Linehan now leads the environmental litigation team. Garrett Breen remains one of the top names in the market, notably acting for clients in major real estate development disputes. Owen O’SullivanPaul Convery and Lisa Carty are also key members of the team. Laura Murdock is an emerging talent.

Practice head(s):

Garrett Breen


Other key lawyers:

Owen O’Sullivan; Lisa Carty; Paul Convery; Fergus Doorly; Laura Murdock; Deirdre O’Donovan; Derek Hegarty; Laura Scott; Colette Brady; Alice O’Connor; Hilary Rogers; Margaret Muldowney; Mary Cooney


Testimonials

‘Fergus Doorly is a market-leading partner. He is shrewd, calm and an excellent strategist. Now that Owen O’Sullivan has taken over as managing partner of the firm, Fergus Doorly is visible in many of the firm’s bigger cases in the Commercial Court. Alice O’Connor is an excellent Senior Associate.’

‘Laura Scott is a brilliant litigator. She has enormous experience of public and private law litigation and quickly becomes an expert in the topic of the litigation in a way that would put even specialist practitioners in the areas to shame. She is tough on the client’s behalf but is a strong builder of consensus within a team and has a wonderful client touch. Would recommend her without hesitation.’

‘Lisa Carty  and Hilary Rogers – pragmatic, business-focused advice delivered with a cool head when dealing with contentious matters of huge value. Lisa and Hilary have stepped beyond the traditional client/solicitor relationship and are considered to be true partners over the course of navigating issues.’

‘Paul Convery is a stand-out lawyer and his understanding of clients’ business and needs leads to solution based results. He is totally ‘hands on’ and commercially minded providing practical and strategic advice to clients. Paul is totally in command of matters providing his clients with a super service.

‘Margaret Muldowney is extremely experienced and expert in the medical negligence and product liability areas. She is extremely responsive and always available providing sound advice to clients. A superb lawyer.’

‘Mary Cooney is an exceptional lawyer – extremely expert in the medical negligence area. Mary provides comprehensive and practical advice to clients and is totally focussed on providing a top-class service to clients.’

‘Owen O’Sullivan – Extremely practical and client user friendly. Garrett Breen – Can be tenacious when the situation calls for it.’

Key clients

GlaxoSmithKline (GSK)


Eirgrid PLC


Fingal County Council


Boots Ireland


Nordic Aviation Capital DAC


Kieran Wallace, KPMG (As liquidator)


Investor Compensation Company DAC


Just Eat Ireland


Skyscanner


Hines / King Street Capital


Hines GREIT II Ireland Fund ICAV


Zimmer & Peacock AS /Zimmer & Peacock Limited


Boehringer Ingelheim


Synopsys Inc


Suzuki GB plc


Fingal County Council


Mazepin, UCCU, Uralchem, Bolotnikova & Konyaev


Department of Finance (Government Department)


Kilsaran Concrete


Dr Edmond Harty


Andrena Moynihan


RSM Ireland


PwC Ireland


RSM Ireland


Valeo


Ava Trade (EU) Limited


Ava Trade Limited


Uniphar


Work highlights


  • Acted for Hines / King Street Capital in Commercial Court proceedings against Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council in relation to a dispute over common infrastructure in Cherrywood, a designated strategic development zone.
  • Represented Fingal County Council in the defence of injunction proceedings brought by the Dublin Airport Authority relating to a dispute over title to lands required for the construction of a new runway at Dublin Airport.
  • Acted for Ineltek in a dispute with Microchip Ireland relating to the supply of microchips and semi-conductors.

Addleshaw Goddard

Addleshaw Goddard has a wide-ranging practice with particular strength in professional negligence, financial services, media, and product liability and personal injury cases. The firm is also a growing force in financial regulatory and competition cases, especially with the arrival of Stephen McLoughlin from Beauchamps LLP in January 2022. It continues to appear in a range of high-value and landmark cases, including Court of Appeal hearings. Ronan O’Neill is rated for banking litigation and Maura Connolly is noted for employment disputes and contentious regulatory matters. Caoilfhionn Ní Chuanacháin  is a key figure for financial services, real estate and professional negligence litigation, while David Cantrell is also an experienced practitioner in professional negligence and commercial disputes. Rachel Shanley  and Paul Dempsey  are highly rated by clients.

Practice head(s):

Maura Connolly


Other key lawyers:

Rachel Shanley; Caoilfhionn Ní Chuanacháin; Ronan O’Neill; Paul Dempsey; David Cantrell; Terry Leggett; Jonathan Lynch; Niamh O’Brien


Testimonials

‘The team have been a great support to me in my role as in house counsel. They are readily available and provide practical no nonsense advice that is accessible to both lawyers and non-lawyers when relying on it.’

‘Paul Dempsey is a stand out partner. He is detail orientated and solution based. An ability to resolve matters by way of compromise or through litigation. Well versed in all elements of the Superior Courts and particularly commercial matters. He shows a real interest in all matters he is engaged in from first instruction to successful resolution.’

‘Paul Dempsey is a very capable litigation attorney who I use for all of my Irish work. Very client focused and responsive.’

‘Quality throughout the team commencing with the partner, Maura Connolly, which guarantees a strong service and valued partnership in mostly difficult circumstances.’

‘Rachel Shanley – practical commercial approach. Astute and realistic in terms of outcomes.’

‘Caoilfhionn Ni Chuanachain is a key external advisor to our organisation. She is always available to me and I rely on her to not just deal with the immediate problem but to consider the overall impact on my business and our strategic goals. She is really easy to deal with and has been invaluable in helping to sell decisions to key stakeholders.’

‘I worked with Rachel Shanley on a complex and challenging matter. Rachel Shanley is an exceptional partner. Excellent on both detail and strategy, extremely hands-on, solution-focused, collaborative, responsive and an all-round pleasure to deal with.’

‘Jonathan Lynch and Niamh O’Brien are both very reliable, highly recommended dispute resolution solicitors. They are both excellent communicators, who always respond very quickly to my queries. Both are very tactically astute and also very alive to client concerns, including minimising costs as much as possible and providing regular detailed billing/costs updates which are very important to us. Terry Leggett provides excellent oversight of the team and manages our relationship with the firm very effectively.’

Key clients

Grant Thornton


JD Sports


Vodafone Retail (Ireland) Limited


BMW (Automotive (Ireland) and BMW (AG))


Takeda Pharmaceutical Ireland


Bank of Ireland


Marks and Spencer (Ireland) Limited


Hugh Dickson and Steve Akers, Joint Official Liquidators of Insolvent Cayman Island hedge fund DD Growth Premium Master Fund (In Liquidation)


Sky UK Limited


Bank of Scotland Plc


ACC Loan Management Limited


Capita Asset Services


Zurich Bank


Investec Bank


KBC Bank Ireland


Danske Bank A/S


Allied Irish Banks, plc


Red Flag Consulting Limited


Whirlpool SSC Limited


Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland


Karshan (Midlands) Limited


Irving Picard, Trustee for the Liquidation of the business of Bernard L Madoff Investment LLC


Kepak Group Unlimited Company


Susquehanna International Group


Havbell DAC


Health Products Regulatory Authority (HPRA)


Work highlights


  • Acted for the Health Products Regulatory Authority in a variety of claims brought against it, including personal injury claims relating to the authorisation of vaccines and judicial review proceedings in relation to the authorisation of generic medicines for both human and veterinary use.
  • Acted for the appellant in an appeal to the Court of Appeal of a decision of the High Court relating to the employment status of pizza delivery drivers.
  • Acted for Havbell, which acquired a substantial portfolio of loans from Permanent TSB, in connection with a large volume of contentious High Court and Circuit Court proceedings against both commercial and individual borrowers.

Beauchamps LLP

Beauchamps LLP has continued to make its mark in business interruption cases linked to the Covid pandemic and has experienced further growth in real estate disputes. Cases connected to ESG obligations and initiatives are now part of the practice. More broadly, the firm is frequently engaged in headline and landmark disputes, including acting for the Premier League in an injunction application to block the illegal streaming of live Premier League matches for the 2021/2022 season. Thomas O’Dwyer is making a further impression in big-ticket disputes, as is financial services and commercial disputes specialist Emma Keegan. Barry Cahir is rated for commercial cases and insolvency disputes, and Sharon Delaney is also noted.

Practice head(s):

Emma Keegan


Other key lawyers:

Thomas O’Dwyer; Barry Cahir; Sharon Delaney; Edward Lyons


Testimonials

‘Practical timely advice and easy access to partners.’

‘Beauchamps Dispute Resolution practice always delivers an excellent service to clients. With a breadth and depth of expertise, they are client focused and bring a wealth of experience which gives me a lot of confidence when working through complex and challenging situations.’

‘Barry Cahir is a leading dispute resolution lawyer in Ireland who brings huge experience, knowledge and commercial acumen to any engagement. Barry is a trusted adviser who always gets behind difficult and complex issues but then brings it back to key issues, offering his valued opinion on potential options and likely outcomes.’

‘The partner-led approach in Beauchamps is what sets it apart from other firms. Partners manage the case from start to finish supported by exceptionally talented solicitors and associates. The team has an unrivalled ability to understand the practical realities as well as the legal issues and I have no difficulty recommending them. The entire team is solution orientated and always strive to deliver a solution that fits the client’s needs.’

‘Thomas O’Dwyer is the full package – very knowledgeable, strategic thinker, super-responsive and calm under pressure. He is constantly looking around corners so clients don’t have to.’

Key clients

Law Society of Ireland


IDA Ireland


daa (Dublin Airport Authority)


Dublin Port Company


City Jet


Dublin City Council


Ulster Bank (owned by RBS Group)


Allied Irish Banks plc


HIQA (Health Information and Quality Authority)


The Premier League


The Perfume Shop


KBC Bank Ireland plc


Danske Bank


Respond


Lotus Investment Group


Link Group


Colony Capital


Cerberus


Everyday Finance


DigitalBridge Inc


Shelbourne Park Stadium


Kenmare Property Finance (Goldman Sachs entity)


Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC


Chief Inspector of Social Services


Kildare County Council


Wealth Options Limited


Leinster Overview Concepts Limited t/a Sean’s Bar


Seniors Money Mortgages


Amhola James Street Limited


Ennis Property Finance DAC (Goldman Sachs entity)


Same Deutz Fahr


Mondofix Inc


Dengrove DAC


Work highlights


  • Acted for the Premier League in an injunction application to block the illegal streaming of live Premier League matches for the 2021/2022 season.
  • Advised Leinster Overview Concepts t/a Sean’s Bar in a test case against FBD Insurance over business interruption policies.
  • Represented Lotus Investment Group in defence of proceedings by an international investor.

ByrneWallace LLP

ByrneWallace LLP is highly rated for cyber-crime and data breaches, white-collar criminal law and investigations. It remains at the forefront of representing public sector bodies and agencies in the health and education sectors. The team has worked on some of the largest cyber crime cases in the state and continues to represent government entities, universities and credit unions in large-scale investigations. Jon Legorburu heads the litigation and dispute resolution department, and has a strong background in public sector disputes, regulatory investigations and white-collar criminal law cases. Mark O’Shaughnessy is also prominent in white-collar crime and investigations. Mona Costelloe is noted for real estate and construction disputes. Sean O’Donnell is another key partner for data protection and cyber-crime matters, and Valerie Hourigan is an experienced figure in real estate disputes.

Practice head(s):

Jon Legorburu


Other key lawyers:

Mona Costelloe; Seán O’Donnell; Valerie Hourigan; Mark O’Shaughnessy; Helen Gibbons; Grainne Murphy; Robert McDermott


Testimonials

‘The practice would seem to have a strong cross section of skills and a willingness to put in time to get things right.’

‘I have found Mona Costelloe, Grainne Murphy and Robert McDermott diligent and careful in their advices which will hopefully leave us in good stead when the issues come to be resolved.’

‘This multidisciplinary team brought far more than basic advice to our process. The team got involved with the matter by acquiring a true understanding, applying analytical thinking and using game theory to support our decisions. The consistent and clear demonstration of capabilities created real confidence for us. Regardless of the outcome we believed during the process we were optimised with this team.’

‘Mark O’Shaughnessy demonstrated relentless commitment, energy and confidence throughout. This rare combination shored up our energy when we most needed it.’

Key clients

Tullow Oil Limited and Tullow Oil plc


Association of Secondary Teachers, Ireland


Parcel Connect t/a Fastway Couriers


The Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman


Ballymore Group/Ballymore Residential Limited


Beaumont Hospital


Be-Spoke Capital A.G.


Environmental Protection Agency


Inland Fisheries Ireland


M7 Real Estate


Work highlights


  • Acted for a state health agency in a dispute with a private hospital provider which arose in the national response to the Covid-19 pandemic.
  • Advised Parcel Connect t/a Fastway Couriers in connection with a cyber-attack affecting its customer data.
  • Acted for Ballymore Group/Ballymore Residential in High Court litigation involving one of Ireland’s largest developers against CRH and its subsidiary Roadstone as well as other construction product suppliers.

DAC Beachcroft Dublin

DAC Beachcroft Dublin has a big presence in contentious insurance matters and is building its standing in defamation and IP/brand protection. It is also experienced in insolvency, real estate and TMT disputes, along with contentious regulatory matters. Although known for high-value litigation, it has an impressive record in arbitration, mediation and other forms of ADR. Lisa Broderick heads the Dublin office and co-leads the commercial litigation and dispute resolution team along with Rowena McCormack.

Practice head(s):

Lisa Broderick; Rowena McCormack


Other key lawyers:

Julie-Ann Binchy


Testimonials

‘I have found DAC Beachcroft to be extremely efficient, knowledgeable and approachable in all my dealings with the firm. All of the dispute resolution cases I have been involved in with DAC has had a very positive outcome and on that basis I would highly recommend DAC to anybody or firm who is seeking a very professional and successful company to represent them.’

‘I would say the ability to speak to an individual and receive an almost immediate response is particularly impressive. Another trait I have found with DAC and in particular Julie-Anne Binchy is their attention to detail which is extremely important in the dispute resolution process.’

‘I find DAC very client focussed with a high degree of attention to detail. Always put the client first and get to grips with the issues very quickly.’

Key clients

Wealth Options Trustees Limited


Carlos Fernandez Casado, S.L.


BT Communications Ireland Limited


Kiernan Homes


Carlson Wagonlit Travel


Large International Industrial Manufacturer and Supplier


Tata Steel UK Limited


Large Financial and Pensions Advisory Firm


The Medical Council


Work highlights


  • Instructed by Wealth Options Trustees in relation to the ongoing liquidations of two companies MUT 103 (In Liquidation) and Dolphin MUT 116.
  • Acted for BT Communications Ireland in Commercial Court proceedings issued by Eircom against the Commission for Communications Regulation in respect of a direction made by the regulator.
  • Defended Carlos Fernandez Casado in proceedings brought in the Commercial Court by Dragados and BAM in connection with the Rose Fitzgerald Kennedy Bridge over the River Barrow.

Dillon Eustace

Dillon Eustace is at the forefront of funds, banking and financial services litigation. It deals with an especially high volume of insurance cases. The firm is also active in commercial litigation, fraud and asset recovery cases, shareholder disputes and real estate litigation. John Doyle leads the department, which includes Peter Bredin, defamation and media expert David Kavanagh and John O’Riordan.

Practice head(s):

John Doyle


Other key lawyers:

John O’Riordan; Peter Bredin; Rachel Turner; David Kavanagh


Testimonials

‘Good people with a willingness to deliver for their clients.’

‘Not driven by the fee, but for the desire to deliver for the client.’

‘Great team surrounded the lead partner John O’ Riordan.’

‘John O Riordan is exceptionally good at his job.’

‘The team was excellent, very professional, we were able to conduct our business over video call and this was not a problem and I found it efficient and effective.’

‘John O’ Riordan was professional, efficient, and most importantly effective. He provided much needed reassurance and I felt confident that he had my best interests at heart and was committed to resolving the situation even in the face of significant challenges posed by the other side.’

‘Peter Bredin and the team are very dedicated and as communicative as is required/requested by the client(me).’

‘Peter Bredin spent a lot of time walking through the timelines and likely costs – which is hugely important before any warranty claim which can take a long time to resolve. Obviously, he gave sage advice on the value of our claim also.’

Key clients

David Kelly


Graiguearidda Limited


Amaranthine Parnters I, LLC


Principal Logistics Technologies


Waystone


KPMG


Balbec Capital


Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC


Cogs & Marvel


CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang


DID Electrical


AIB


Zurich


Odyssey Validation Consultants Limited


Gradual Investments Limited


Deloitte


RSA


Travelers


AXA


National Asset Management Agency


Sunday Business Post


Investors in Toshiba


Motor Insurers Bureau of Ireland


Havbell DAC


Irish Daily Mail / Irish Mail on Sunday


American Airlines


Grant Thornton


Work highlights


  • Acted for a shareholder and former director of Web Summit, David Kelly, in a series of disputes before the Irish Commercial court against both Web Summit and another shareholder.
  • Acted for Principal Logistics Technologies in Commercial Court proceedings seeking damages for breaches of warranties.
  • Acted for a number of investors in ongoing litigation before the Japanese courts in relation to the value of Toshiba stock.

Eversheds Sutherland

Eversheds Sutherland has a large team and a broad-based practice, including financial services disputes and regulatory investigations, commercial litigation, public law and insurance cases, and professional indemnity. The firm is also noted for healthcare disputes. The Dublin office has achieved further growth in investigations and risk management with Pamela O’Neill and Stephen Barry to the fore, the former is also noted for financial services litigation. Norman Fitzgerald is another senior litigator with an established record in shareholder disputes, audit negligence cases and regulatory investigations, amongst other matters. The highly rated Graham Kenny joined the firm with a team from Kenny Solicitors in June 2022. Eoin Mac Aodha is also rated. Aisling Gannon left the firm.

Practice head(s):

Pamela O’Neill


Other key lawyers:

Norman Fitzgerald; Neil O’Mahony; Dermot McEvoy; Stephen Barry; Graham Kenny; Eoin Mac Aodha; Cillian Hunter McGowan; Claire Higgins; Thomas Costello


Testimonials

‘The level of personal service from a large law firm is amazing. I have had extensive experience with other similar firms and none compare to the way all staff in Eversheds Sutherland are able to make you feel as if you are their only client. The ability of their staff to be able to answer questions relating to my account instantly on a call without having to call me back is something that has to be experienced. Being an Eversheds Sutherland client gives you instant access to a full service firm, who can deal with any question you might have without the waiting sometimes found at other firms. I am very glad I, my family and businesses made the move to Eversheds Sutherland.’

‘Graham Kenny is by far the most dedicated legal professional I have ever had the pleasure of working with. He is available to his clients whenever required. No matter how how small the issue, Graham realises that it may seem large to those with little legal experience.’

‘Cillian Hunter McGowan in my opinion deserves the highest honour available, his dedication and care for his clients I find I can not find the correct words to describe. 12 out of 10.’

‘Norman Fitzgerald. Effective, calm, thorough.’

‘Graham Kenny has represented us on business and personal matters over the years and has always steered us in the right direction. His dedication and knowledge is exceptional and his ability to make a call on the most appropriate course of action to take on each matter has always proven correct from a man who always puts himself in his client’s shoes.’

‘We had to complete a very difficult e-discovery project and the team were very adept at using the latest technology and advising in relation to the rules of the Courts in relation to discovery’

‘Claire Higgins was particularly good on discovery and Norman Fitzgerald and Thomas Costello provide sound advice and good judgement.’

‘Surprisingly good availability and efficiency – prompt and comprehensive responses to queries and extremely knowledgeable about all aspects of law relating to the matter at hand.’

Key clients

AIB


AIG


Allianz Insurance plc


Bank of Scotland


Breedon Group and Lagan Asphalt and Cement


Cairn Homes


Ciaran and Colum Butler, Starbucks and Leisureplex


CNG Europe Energy SAS


CyrusONE


Dublin Cinema Group


Doyle Shipping Group


Dublin Port


Dunboy Property & Construction Limited


Earlsfort East Point Limited


Financial Services Ombudsman


G4S


Gefion Finans A/S Limited (in bankruptcy)


Gembira & Richmond Homes


Hammond Lane Metal Company and Clearway Disposals Limited


Hibernia Reit


HID Global


John Sisk (Holdings) Limited & Wilton Works


Johnson Controls


KBC Bank


Killeen Engineering


Kingspan plc


Krispy Kream


L. Behan Aggregates and Recycling Limited


Musgrave plc


Musgrave plc


Nexus and PHP Group Limited


Orla Costelloe


Passive Windows Limited


Payzone


Pensions Ombudsman


Pepper Finance


PIAB


Rockwell Automation Limited


Ronan Group Real Estate


RTB


Schindler Lifts


Stena Line


Suir Engineering


Tetrarch Capital


Ulster Bank


Vantage Data Centres Europe


Viterbi Limited


Walls Construction Limited


Waterman Moylan


WeWork


Word Perfect Translations


Yellow River Windfarm Limited


Work highlights


  • Advised RGRE as landlord, in relation to a dispute with its tenant at Bewley’s Café, Grafton Street, Dublin.
  • Represented Kingspan in an investigatory review of compliance and governance in the UK Insulation Boards business arising from its participation as a core participant in the UK’s Grenfell Tower Inquiry and identifying recommendations for implementation.
  • Acted for DAF Trucks in minority shareholder oppression proceedings instituted in the Commercial Court, including allegations of fraud.

Hayes Solicitors LLP

Hayes Solicitors LLP remains best known for healthcare matters, including a high volume of personal injury claims and clinical defence engagements, though has a broad and varied dispute resolution practice. It has also grown its presence in financial services disputes, construction cases and general commercial litigation. Mary Hough is head of healthcare and an experienced figure in medical negligence claims. Experienced litigator Joe O’Malley is managing partner and head of litigation and dispute resolution. Caroline Crowley has retired.

Practice head(s):

Joe O’Malley; Mary Hough


Other key lawyers:

Matthew Austin; David Phelan; Robbie Slattery; Jeremy Erwin


Testimonials

‘Strong specialist team in insolvency and litigation. Highly accessible and responsive. Sound practical and commercial advice.’

‘All the team members in the practice which I have dealt with are professional in their dealings, are very knowledgeable and most of all, very approachable. The practice provides an excellent and efficient service.’

‘Stand-out Partners and Associates. They continually provide an excellent and efficient service. They are very professional in their dealings and are always available to assist.’

‘Excellent experienced team with a clear focus on client’s needs in the most cost efficient manner.’

‘Matt Austin and Joe O’Malley are excellent, intuitive and insightful.’

Key clients

AIB


Arabic Computer Systems and National Technology Group


Baker Tilly Chartered Accountants


Bank of Ireland


Bord Gais Energy


Clare Civil Engineering


Conor MacGuill


Country Manor Hotels Limited


Dental Protection (Healthcare)


EFG Bank AG


Gary McGuinness and David McGuinness


Hickey’s Pharmacy Group


Investec


Kirby Healy Chartered Accountants


Medical Protection Society (Healthcare)


NAMA


NCPS


OHM Group


Primark


Robert Stöllinger (former Managing Partner KPMG Budapest)


Royal Institute of Architects in Ireland (RIAI)


State Claims Agency (Healthcare & EL/PL)


The Irish Times


Tony Kilduff


Unilever


Veterinary Defence Society


Willis Towers Watson


Work highlights


  • Represented the State Claims Agency in proceedings relating to the HPV vaccine and Thalidomide claims.
  • Acted for NAMA in relation to three significant cases.
  • Acted for Arabic Computer Systems and National Technology Group, Middle Eastern Microsoft software reseller clients, in the defence of a commercial court claim by Microsoft Ireland for breach of contract.

LK Shields Solicitors LLP

LK Shields Solicitors LLP has a wide-ranging dispute resolution practice with an especially strong record in construction disputes, restructuring and insolvency cases, and insurance litigation. It has achieved further growth in landlord and tenant disputes, shareholder disputes, regulatory cases and construction bond claims. Jill Callanan heads the litigation and dispute resolution department, and is noted for insolvency disputes. Ian Lavelle has made an impression in insurance and construction bond claims

Practice head(s):

Jill Callanan


Other key lawyers:

Eamon Jones; Ian Lavelle; Jennifer Clarke; Redmond Arigho


Testimonials

‘LK Shields and the dispute resolution team work collaboratively with their clients to understand the situation and devise practical and intelligent strategies which achieve results’

‘From my introduction, I felt the people dealing with my case were informed, thorough, and all communications were open and clear. I felt they looked after my interests in a professional, informed and thorough way. My barrister and senior counsel appointed by the firm were excellent. From start to resolution, their performance was excellent.’

‘My solicitor Eamon Jones and his assistant Redmond Arigho were start to finish, always available, kept me informed and their advice and knowledge and communication were excellent.’

‘LKS are very responsive and commercial in their outlook. Jennifer Clarke is our principal contact in the firm and nothing is too much trouble. Very accessible and we have had very good client feedback and outcomes.’

Key clients

Scania AB, Scania CV AB and Scania Deutschland GmbH


Various Directors of Oviedo Limited


Veon Limited, Trevor McHugh, Paul Brosnan (former director of Irish Forestry Fund Companies), IFS Forestry Services Limited


Pepper (Chargeholder), Duff & Phelps (Receiver), Anne O’Dwyer (Receiver – Duff & Phelps) and Declan Taite (Receiver – Duff & Phelps)


Millstreet Equestrian Services


Universal Music Ireland Limited


Garrett McCarthy, Liquidator of C&F Automotive (Ireland) Limited, of Hughes & McCarthy Accountants


Six by Nico


McDonalds Restaurants of Ireland


Coface UK


Work highlights


  • Advised Scania on the defence of multiple civil actions brought in the High Court, and subsequently admitted to the Competition List of the High Court, in Ireland claiming damages following a European Commission competition/antitrust infringement decision.
  • Acted for various directors of Oviedo in oppression proceedings issued by a shareholder, Fulman Holdings, pursuant to the Irish Companies Act.
  • Acted for Veon Limited, Trevor McHugh, Paul Brosnan (former directors of the Irish Forestry Fund Companies) and IFS Forestry Services in relation to proceedings brought by the preference shareholders of the Irish Forestry Funds.

Maples Group

Maples Group expanded its senior ranks with the promotion of Eugene McCormick and Karole Cuddihy to the partnership in January 2022. The enlarged team is recognised for its expertise in financial services and banking disputes, real estate cases, professional liability, tax disputes and regulatory investigations. The firm has an excellent record in financial services cases and cross-border tax disputes, and has experienced further growth in commercial property litigation. Brian Clarke is noted for regulatory investigations, Commercial Court cases and arbitration. Alan O’Sullivan  is an experienced figure in banking litigation, insolvency disputes, commercial litigation and real estate cases. Enda O’Keefe and Kevin Harnett  have left the firm.

Practice head(s):

Robin McDonnell


Other key lawyers:

Eugene McCormick; Karole Cuddihy; Brian Clarke; Alan O’Sullivan


Testimonials

‘Highly capable partner team particularly in the area of debt resolution, insolvency, litigation etc.’

‘Accessibility, responsiveness with sound, grounded and commercially practical advice.’

‘Expert knowledge and very strong relationship management.’

‘Attention to detail, commerciality and availability.’

‘Alan O’Sullivan in the litigation team is an excellent solicitor but has sound commercial sense, which makes him stand out from competitors. He is efficient, measured in high pressure situations and fast in his responses.’

‘Fights strongly for the best interests of their clients and always on top of the detail. Quality team from top to bottom.’

Key clients

Michael McAteer and Paul McCann of Grant Thornton, Joint Administrators of Quinn Insurance Limited


Michael McAteer and Paul McCann of Grant Thornton, Joint Official Liquidators of the Treasury Holdings group


Grafton Group plc


KC Capital Property Group DAC


Belfry Investment Funds


Energoinvest Reach Active Limited


Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC


The Caffé Nero Group


Mars Capital Finance Ireland DAC


RediResi Isen Limited


Susquehanna International Group


Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Mallinckrodt plc


Work highlights


  • Represented Michael McAteer and Paul McCann of Grant Thornton (joint administrators of Quinn Insurance) in a professional negligence action against PwC.

Philip Lee LLP

Philip Lee LLP has expanded its practice beyond its traditional focus on public sector-related disputes. With the intention of bolstering its standing in commercial litigation, real estate, banking and insolvency disputes, it hired the highly-rated Gerald Byrne as a partner from Brown Rudnick LLP. It then followed this by recruiting senior litigator Eimear Collins from DWF at the end of 2022. The expanded group continues to be active in the public sector, notably representing the Data Protection Commission in numerous cases and the Health Service Executive in a range of healthcare cases, including procurement disputes. Damien Young  and Clare Cashin are experienced practitioners in procurement and construction disputes.

Practice head(s):

Damien Young


Other key lawyers:

Gerald Byrne; Leonora Mullett; Marie Kinsella; Clare Cashin; Eimear Collins


Testimonials

‘Gerald Byrne is an incredibly hard-working, thoughtful and incisive lawyer who fights hard for his clients.’

‘I have worked with Gerald Byrne on a number of large-scale pieces of complicated litigation and he has an outstanding ability to think through all the issues in a case.’

‘The Philip Lee team bring a level of wisdom to dispute resolution; managing client hubris and ambition and balancing that with what is right and fair. Then they back their advice with excellent teamwork and knowledge.’

‘Clare Cashin shows us how it is done – to manage the processes for the client fairly and wisely, and achieve best outcomes.’

Key clients

Data Protection Commission


Health Service Executive


Transdev Ireland


Office of the Information Commissioner and the Office of the Commissioner for Environmental Information


An Bord Pleanála (Irish Planning Board)


Dublin City Council


Trinity College Dublin


Work highlights


  • Represented the HSE in the majority of its commercial and healthcare disputes, including matters linked to the Covid pandemic.
  • Advised the Irish Data Protection Commission in all its litigation matters in Ireland, including challenges to its decisions.
  • Acted for An Bord Pleanala, including judicial review defence litigation.

Kennedys

Kennedys remains best known for its insurance expertise, both nationally and internationally. It acts for insurers and insureds, in major and headline cases. Its insurance expertise brings it exposure to a wide range of industries, notably construction, healthcare, maritime, hotels and leisure, and more recently it has represented clients in Covid-19 business interruption cases. With six partners operating in this field, it has specialist expertise in financial lines and environmental insurance claims through Andrew McGahey and healthcare experience through Joanne O’Sullivan. Hugh Kennedy stands out for maritime matters and Noel Devins for professional indemnity and business interruption.

Practice head(s):

Andrew McGahey


Other key lawyers:

Joanne O’Sullivan; Hugh Kennedy; Noel Devins; David Strahan; Martina O’Mahoney


Testimonials

‘Very responsive to request for expert opinion on foreign (Irish) law for use in Australian proceedings.’

‘Hugh Kennedy – Very responsive and authoritative on a novel question of Irish shipping law.’

‘The solicitors in Kennedys are all extremely well informed. The firm obviously has a real commitment to continuous professional development. The partners and other solicitors are always well aware of the latest legal developments in their specialist areas.’

‘Noel Devins is a specific stand-out partner. He is an extremely well informed lawyer. He is also an astute tactician and a clear communicator. He always seems to achieve remarkable results for his insurers and insured clients.’

Key clients

Aegis


AIG


Allianz


Aviva Life & Pensions dac


Berkshire Hathaway


Chaucer Insurance


Chubb


Cornmarket Financial Services


COSCO & China Shipowners Mutual Assurance Association


CPL Management Solutions


Drogheda Port


Elk Fertighaus AG


Electric Insurance Company


Heatons Unlimited


Go Ahead Ireland and


IN2 Engineering Design Partnership


Inditex Re


JD Sports


JD Wetherspoon


Liberty Insurance


MDO Management Company SA


Medlab Pathology Limited


Mitie Facilities Management Ltd


Securitas Security Services Limited


SIMS Clinic


SOMPO International Insurance


Zurich Insurance PLC


Work highlights


  • Represented Aegis and the insured structural engineer in extracting the clients from proceedings one day before the start of Commercial Court proceedings initiated by the Minister for Education over alleged defects in the Rapid Build schools programme in Ireland.
  • Defended Drogheda Port and its UK insurers in High Court Admiralty proceedings issued by Arklow Shipping after an Arklow ship went aground in the channel whilst departing the port.
  • Defended Parmont Limited (owner of the Esplanade Hotel) through expert testimony to disprove and dismiss claims by a hotel guest that serious burn injuries were sustained by a kettle allegedly bursting.

Lavelle Partners

Lavelle Partners has a major emphasis on banking and financial services litigation, insolvency cases and debt recovery engagements. Real estate disputes, defamation and data privacy matters are also a forte. Department head Ciarán Leavy and managing partner Michael Lavelle are highly rated by clients, the former recognised for his breadth of expertise across commercial litigation, insurance claims, professional indemnity and defamation, and the latter noted for big-ticket insolvency cases, partnership disputes and large-scale commercial litigation. Marc Fitzgibbon  specialises in contentious employment matters and Avril Scally leads the clinical negligence team.

Practice head(s):

Ciarán Leavy


Other key lawyers:

Marc Fitzgibbon; Michael Lavelle; Avril Scally


Testimonials

‘Highly experienced dispute resolution team, always available to offer counsel and advice, or just listen as the scenario demands. Really felt like the team were invested in our case and we were treated with empathy and respect throughout.’

‘Michael Lavelle is an industry leader in this sector. His grasp of the complex issues was second to none and his ability to offer objective advice, even when we did not want to hear it was greatly valued. We felt very confident and secure having Michael go to bat for us and knew our position always got a good hearing. We have great trust in Michael’s opinions and advices and secured a very satisfactory outcome on conclusion of our engagement.’

‘One of the key strengths of Lavelle Partners is that they put a lot of focus and effort on understanding their client’s business no matter how complex or bespoke a particular process is and they always manage to find practical solutions to any problems we encounter in our business. From my experience with other law firms, Lavelle Partners are more “hands on” and more client focused E.g. regular updates are provided on cases and tasks which they are working on. Lavelle Partners are excellent at keeping their clients up-to-date on fees and costs so there are never any surprises when it comes to their invoices. Another key strength of Lavelle Partners is their excellent publications and updates provided to clients on all legal areas relevant to businesses.’

‘Ciaran Leavy’s legal expertise as a commercial litigator is second to none and he has always been extremely professional, responsive and pleasant to deal with. He has advised us on a very bespoke matter recently and he was exceptionally comfortable with this. Ciaran is always true to his word in relation to deadlines and can really be depended upon by our company to deliver. Ciaran really makes it his business to understand how we operate our business and in turn provides top class commercially focused advice. Ciaran is very down to earth also and can explain a complex topic in a very easy to understand way. We would highly recommend Ciaran and his team.’

‘Lavelle Partners’ dispute resolution team provide solution focused, commercial and pragmatic advice to guide their clients through litigation. Their focus is on achieving the best possible outcome at each stage of the process. The team get to know their clients closely and bring a fresh approach, which aims to align any litigation strategy which is devised to the client’s business requirements.’

‘Michael Lavelle brings his significant market experience to the forefront and advocates passionately for his clients. Michael knows the Irish commercial market intimately. Michael is a strong strategist and assists his clients to place themselves in a position of strength from the outset of proceedings.’

‘Ciaran Leavy is highly knowledgeable, dedicated and extremely astute. Ciaran anticipates issues before they arise and presents his clients with carefully crafted solutions. Ciaran is able to distill his legal advice into clear and understandable language.’

‘Lavelle Partners have an outstanding dispute resolution team. They are singularly focussed in getting the best results for their clients. They are across the detail. They never let cases lie and are extremely responsive in terms of their clients.’

Key clients

Windspiel Limited


Ogier

Ogier has excellent dispute resolution credentials with a number of experienced professionals within the team, including Larry Fenelon SC, who was awarded Senior Counsel status in 2021. The firm is particularly rated for real estate disputes, along with banking and financial services litigation. Ronan McGoldrick is another prominent practitioner, especially in financial services litigation, and is also chairman of the Irish Commercial Mediation Association.

Other key lawyers:

Elaine White; Stephen O’Connor; Maria Edgeworth


Testimonials

‘My personal experience with the people I dealt with was excellent from the outset.’

‘Ronan McGoldrick was, from my initial meeting, very straightforward in his assessment of an upcoming dispute and the possible outcomes.’

‘We have been working with Ogier Leman for over 10 years. The practice is very professional, approachable and knowledgeable with an excellent team made up of skilled partners and associates. If we require urgent advice or assistance there is always a partner available to chat to us and provide us with what we need. The team have proved invaluable to us over the past decade and we will continue to work closely with them over the next 10 years.’

‘We have had the pleasure of working with a variety of the team in particular Larry Fenelon, Ronan McGoldrick and Stephen O Connor. They all stand out as going the extra mile for their clients, taking calls and emails outside of normal business hours and always being available to address any urgent matters.’

‘Good, solid team. Generally stuck to timelines, gave a sense of security to us as the client – they had a confidence and knowledge in the areas that mattered i.e. litigation and defamation. Team were friendly and very easy to talk to – more so than other law firms.’

‘Ronan McGoldrick has gravitas and is clearly quick-witted, gives a sense of a steady hand guiding the ship. I appreciated his ability to focus on the issue at hand, and cut through some of the tendency of other lawyers (inc external barristers) to pontificate on calls. Stephen O’Connor brings a fresh perspective to the partnership. He was very approachable and easy to work with.’

RDJ LLP

RDJ LLP has a large team spread across its Cork, Galway and Dublin offices. It has an especially strong record in commercial litigation, shareholder disputes, construction and planning cases, landlord and tenant actions, and product liability cases. It is also noted for its experience in professional indemnity, media and healthcare disputes. Richard Martin is a senior practitioner with a fine reputation in media, defamation and privacy cases, along with insurance and shareholder disputes; he is also noted for his expertise in judicial review proceedings. Ronan Geary leads the commercial litigation team and is also rated for judicial review and commercial disputes. Darryl Broderick heads the litigation department.

Practice head(s):

Darryl Broderick


Other key lawyers:

Richard Martin; Ronan Geary; Peter Lennon; Fergus Long; Jamie Olden; Ricky Kelly; Jennifer Noctor; Charlene Walsh


Testimonials

‘Very quickly got a grasp of the situation which was quite complex. Was able to give me great advice, and when needed took the lead in a large mediation where there was a danger of stalemate.’

‘Very personal. Helpful & understanding of the whole big picture. Gave great advice but also listened to me and took on board the difficulties of some of the decisions that had to be made. When needed, was more than able to defend the position.’

‘RDJs litigation team have provided us with effective and commercial support throughout the year.’

‘Darryl Broderick is a very ‘can do’ partner who is always available with commercial advice generally. Jennifer Noctor is an excellent litigator as are Ricky Kelly and Charlene Walsh. I would say RDJ have become more integrated across their different offices with Galway and Dublin each contributing significantly.’

‘RDJ are our go-to law firm if we have a high-stakes litigation. Their team have an excellent handle on complex legal and technical issues, are skilled negotiators and think very strategically.’

‘Richard Martin is the full package. He has incredible judgement, is a brilliant strategist and is an absolute pleasure to work with.’

Key clients

Munster Rugby


Waratek Limited


Accountant – James Norton


Trident Securities


Education Procurement Service


Abtran Group


Trinity College Dublin


Hiscox


Munster Joinery Group


Valero Ireland


Work highlights


  • Advised Mr Al Mana, a high profile Qatari businessman, in High Court proceedings against Facebook Ireland relating to a series of fake advertisements on the social media platform for cryptocurrency featuring his image and purported endorsement.
  • Acted for Abtran in resisting an attempt by Green Network Energy to terminate its outsourcing contract and in pursuing over €1m in overdue fees.
  • Acted for James Norton of Norton & Norton in oppression proceedings under Section 212 of the Companies Act 2014, involving Foxfield Inns, the owners of the Aisling Hotel in Dublin and the Imperial Hotel in Galway.
     

Whitney Moore

Whitney Moore has an impressive mix of domestic and international clients that frequently turn to it when involved in disputes and contentious situations. The firm has a particularly strong record in intellectual property, particularly patent and trade mark infringement cases, and banking disputes. Aoife Murphy and Robin Hayes are IP specialists, while Colin Hayes  impresses in the broader commercial litigation field. Brendan Moriarty  retired from the partnership in December 2021 to become a consultant.

Practice head(s):

Aoife Murphy


Other key lawyers:

Robin Hayes; Colin Hayes; Michael Ohle; Vicky Riordan; Brendan Moriarty; John Lynch; Aine Kelly


Testimonials

‘In terms of dispute resolution, my business works a great deal with Colin Hayes and Aine Kelly. While I have found all staff at Whitney Moore to be highly proficient in their respective areas of expertise, Colin Hayes and Aine Kelly have gone above and beyond in their efforts to resolve complex matters for us in circumstances where, I believe, other firms would have given up.’

‘Great team able to react quickly to difficult matters and with a very practical mindset.’

‘Colin Hayes is a bright lawyer, able to find solutions in very complex disputes.’

‘WM were recommended to us, we have found them incredibly supportive of our business, good listeners, offering options, engaging external personnel as required and bringing resolutions to a close.’

‘Colin Hayes is our prime contact, always responsive, very clear in his responses and evaluations of the issues to be resolved.’

‘Highly responsive, attentive, and a strong sense of them being partners in our legals challenges.’

‘Michael Olhe – excellent insolvency solicitor. Very responsive and a strong negotiator.’

‘The team take a practical but thorough approach to their work. They are easy to deal with, speak in plain English which is helpful when trying to understand the finer details of legal documents.’

Key clients

Allianz PLC


Novartis AG


Bentley Instruments SARL


Chartered Accountants Ireland


Edwards Lifesciences Inc.


Etex Ireland Ltd


Waterwipes UC


Daimler AG


Merck Sharp & Dohme


Bulrush Horticulture Ltd


Bank of Ireland


Fieldfisher

Fieldfisher has a well-developed dispute resolution practice with an impressive list of domestic and international clients. Contentious insolvency matters are a mainstay of the practice, which is also rated for data breach cases, insurance cases (including road traffic accident claims) and judicial review cases. Killian O’Reilly is a senior litigator with an excellent record in commercial litigation and employment matters. Mark Woodcock  is rated for commercial disputes, insolvency cases and contentious insurance matters.

Practice head(s):

Killian O’Reilly; Mark Woodcock


Testimonials

‘Killian O’Reilly is a top class lawyer.’

‘Killian O’Reilly is our go to lawyer for dispute resolution. Killian is so clear and calm under pressure. He never lets the stress of a situation get to him. A calm, knowledge and highly effective adviser.’

‘A firm that lives up to the high standards expected of solicitors in Ireland.’

Key clients

Ryanair DAC


Orange Business Services


Mazars


AIG Insurance plc


RSM Ireland


Bank of Ireland


Insomnia


TUI Group


Ornella Underwriting Limited


Insolvency Service of Ireland


Deloitte Ireland


Start Mortgages DAC


KPMG


Keta Products Limited


Work highlights


  • Acted for Start Mortgages in obtaining a High Court Order to appoint a receiver over proceeds of a Zurich Insurance policy.
  • Advised the Official Assignee in multiple simultaneous applications to the High Court and a hearing to determine multiple issues involving a number of parties with conflicting interests
  • Instructed by Ornella Underwriting in respect of a road traffic accident where a Garda officer alleged that she was struck by the unsecured door of a horse box and sustained significant personal injuries.

Holmes O'Malley Sexton

Holmes O'Malley Sexton‘s three offices in Dublin, Limerick and Cork provides it with a geographical reach in the dispute resolution field, and also allows it to offer charge out rate efficiencies through lower-cost centres. It has a prolific record in commercial litigation, including headline cases and judicial review proceedings before the Commercial Court. Financial lines litigation is another core strength of the practice. Harry Fehily and Pat McInerney lead the department. Michael Murphy is also noted for insurance claims.

Practice head(s):

Harry Fehily; Pat McInerney; Michael Murphy


Other key lawyers:

Marguerite Seymour; Aoife Skehan


Testimonials

‘Holmes O’Malley Sexton LLP are effective litigators but also have particular expertise in arbitration, mediation and other alternative dispute resolution options. They are experts in their field and are skilled dispute resolution practitioners.’

‘They provide sound, timely and comprehensive advices on legal liability, quantum/reserves and strategy. I would have no hesitation in recommending them to someone who is seeking legal advices and/or dispute resolution services.’

‘Harry Fehily – Skilled negotiator and has particular expertise in commercial dispute resolution and insurance law.’

Key clients

University of Limerick


Irish Greyhound Board


Revenue Commissioners


Galway Mayo Institute of Technology (now Atlantic Technological University)


Dublin City Council


H&MV Engineering Limited


Corajio UC t/a Mr. Price


Legal Aid Board


Limerick 2030 Development DAC


AIB


Coillte


UCC


Port of Cork


BioAtlantis Limited


Clare County Council


Mayan Construction Limited


Westair Aviation Limited


AIG Europe


Commission for Railway Regulation


IDA Ireland


Technological University Dublin


Ulster Bank


National Gallery of Ireland


Amarenco Solar Limited


Mechanical Equipment Company (MECO) Limited


IAS Medical Limited


Work highlights


  • Acted for a client in significant Commercial Court proceedings arising from a dispute with a Dutch supplier.
  • Acted on behalf of IAS Medical Limited in proceedings issued by SERE Holdings Limited pursuant to the European Communities (Public Authorities’ Contracts) (Review Procedures) Regulations 2010 (as amended) and Order 84A of the Rules of the Superior Courts.
  • Acted on behalf of AIB in respect of an appeal to the Supreme Court by two debtors.

O'Flynn Exhams

O'Flynn Exhams is based in Cork and has a strong background in dispute resolution. It continues to be noted for its commitment to and experience in ADR, and has a steady flow of engagements in commercial litigation, contentious employment matters, professional negligence claims, real estate disputes, and planning and environmental matters. Shane Crossan leads the team, which includes the highly rated Tom O’Byrne and Sion Williams.

Practice head(s):

Shane Crossan


Other key lawyers:

Pat Mullins: Tom O’Byrne; Sion Williams; Eamonn Muldoon


Testimonials

‘Tom O’Byrne is a star litigator. He has a depth of knowledge across a broad practice. He has the enviable ability to convey and explain complex legal issues for lay clients.’

‘O’Flynn Exhams have the ability to offer big firm capability with the personal services you only see at very small firms. One of their greatest strengths is in the level of expertise and experience available under one roof.’

‘Sion Williams would be my stand out individual, always available, a superb communicator and consummate expert.’

Key clients

Gas Networks Ireland


Irish Water


Kerry Group plc


Munster Technological University


Atlantic Technological University


Allied Irish Banks, plc


Permanent TSB plc


Trane Technologies International Limited (formerly Ingersoll-Rand International Limited)


Cork Education and Training Board


Powerscourt Estates Limited


Amber Petroleum Limited


Marriott International (formerly Starwood)


P.J. Hegarty & Sons UC


T&T Precision Ltd


Presentation Brothers Trustees


Brothers of Charity


MWP


GlobeTech


Westfield Investments


Carey Glass


R.E.S.A.M. Properties Limited


Cummins Sports Limited


Cope Foundation


Grangefield Developments Limited


Blaabjerg Leg APS


Abbey Machinery Limited


Irish Times Limited


Heineken Ireland Limited


Kenny Group


Grandon Car Sales Limited


Over-C Technologies


Manakau Limited


Dzogchen Beara Spiritual Care Centre


Compucal Calibration


Pinsent Masons LLP

Pinsent Masons LLP has made solid progress in the dispute resolution field, achieving a significant number of appearances in the High Court and a number of Commercial Court engagements. Ann Henry has a fine record in headline and high-value cases, including patent disputes, trade secrets cases and data breach matters. Michael Finn is also noted for IP disputes and commercial litigation. Zara West is also noted.

Practice head(s):

Ann Henry


Other key lawyers:

Michael Finn; Zara West


Testimonials

‘This practice is unique because of the balance between comprehensive experience (e.g. Ann Henry) and up and coming stars, such as Zara West. Although their sweet spot is intellectual property and financial services, they do not take a siloed approach and all have a good grounding in all areas of commercial law. This enables them to react to unexpected issues deftly.’

‘Ann Henry is a pleasure to work with. She has a massive amount of expertise and experience across intellectual property disputes, financial services and financial services regulatory. She is very responsive and thorough. Her advice is always pragmatic and she has a deep understanding of a client’s commercial objectives. It is no surprise that she has grown this practice enormously over recent years.’

‘Zara West is a rising star, with growing expertise in banking and finance litigation. She is very attentive to detail and deals with issues in a practical and business like manner. She is also gaining huge experience in the insolvency and restructuring area and is very active in IWIRC.’

Key clients

Mercer (Ireland) Limited


Rolls-Royce plc


Medatech UK Limited


Aviareto Limited


Avantor Performance Materials Poland S.A.


Decotek Automotive Limited


O&S Doors Limited


Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited/Norton (Waterford) Limited


Standard Life International DAC (part of Phoenix group)


Idox plc


Flogas Ireland Limited


DCC Energy Limited


Commission for Communications Regulation


Travel Counsellors (Ireland) Limited


WeLink Investment Holdings Ireland Limited


Snorkel Europe Limited


Intertrust Technologies


The European Marine Energy Centre Limited


Xeon Dental Services Limited


Ypsilon.net


Work highlights


  • Acted for Mercer (Ireland) Limited in the defence of Commercial Court proceedings issued by Irish Airline Pilots Pensions DAC.
  • Acted for Norton (Waterford) Limited, trading as Teva Pharmaceuticals Ireland, in two sets of patent revocation proceedings in Ireland which relate to patent and SPC revocation proceedings against Bristol-Myers Squibb Ireland Unlimited Company and Pfizer Inc.
  • Acted for Aviareto regarding a trade mark infringement by Global Closing Room, which included a successful injunction application that applied the Supreme Court decision in MSD V Clonmel, determining that damages would not be an adequate remedy in this case.