Morton Fraser MacRoberts employs ‘a personable approach’ in its property litigation practice which is noted for its capabilities in ownership disputes, lease termination matters and compensation claims. The team, which is led by Kenneth Carruthers, represents blue-chip corporate clients, public authorities and property developers. Carruthers often advises housebuilders on cladding disputes and is also experienced with dilapidation claims. Douglas Milne is active in the telecoms sector, while the ’excellent’ Isobell Reid is adept at handling both leasing disputes and renewable energy matters. Lynsay Cargill is also highly recommended.
Legal 500 Editorial commentary
Testimonials
Collated independently by Legal 500 research team.
- ‘Isobell Reid is an excellent partner with great client relationship skills.’
- ‘Morton Fraser, since the amalgamation with McRoberts, has not lost its 'small practice' personable approach. This is probably their key strength. It marks them out from their competitors.'
- 'Its accomplished expertise in property litigation continues to be made evident to me when dealing with an ongoing, very complex building failure dispute.'
- 'One could not ask for more.’
- 'Kenneth Carruthers is one of the most experienced property and planning litigators in Scotland. He has a wealth of experience in dealing with complex land development transactions and his experience helps reassure clients at all times. Lynsay Cargill also has a growing reputation in complex property disputes and is very good at dealing with client's concerns.'
- 'Several first rate lawyers in the same team with considerable knowledge and experience of all types of land disputes.'
- 'Their personal approach is their key strength.'
- 'Tactical planning and their collegiate approach of the partner and associate.'
Key clients
- Scottish Government
- The Ministry of Defence
- The Student Loans Company
- Tesco Stores Limited
- Morrisons plc
- SSE plc
- CALA Homes
- Persimmon Homes
- Taylor Wimpey plc
- BAM Properties Limited
Work highlights
Advised Chisholm Hunter on its successful defence of appeal from Lands Tribunal to Inner House regarding validity of title condition at Argyll Arcade, Glasgow.
Advising a Non-Departmental Public Body on the ongoing defence of arbitrations arising from a £13m dilapidations claim following termination of a city centre lease.
Advising an International Hotel Chain in pursuing a £10m Lands Tribunal claim for compensation following the compulsory purchase of one of its Scottish properties.
Lawyers
Next Generation Partners
Junior partners with significant recognition from clients and peers in the market and key roles on multiple matters.
Practice head
Kenneth Carruthers
Other key lawyers
Douglas Milne; Isobell Reid; Lynsay Cargill