Harper Macleod LLP has a comprehensive professional negligence offering, allowing the team to advise on claimant and defendant cases. The practice group is co-led by experienced partners Sandy Hastie and David Kerr. Kerr is reputed for the depth of his expertise in handling allegations of negligent conduct. E-Ming Fong has a high level of experience and knowledge in matters involving solicitors’ negligence, while John McHugh specialises in construction-related claims against architects. Andrew MacKenzie is a reference for banks and financial institutions across the full remit of professional negligence matters. Adam de Ste Croix is a name to note for cases concerning solicitors’ negligence relating to property and financial transactions.
Legal 500 Editorial commentary

Testimonials

Collated independently by Legal 500 research team.

  • Bobby Murray is the main member with whom we have worked, and he is very knowledgeable. He has an excellent manner with us in explaining every aspect fully and in language that is comprehensible. I have felt in safe hands since he took on our case. One has the feeling that there is only one case in his life, which of course is unlikely!
  • David Kerr, Sandy Hastie, and E-Ming Fong are formidably strong. So too are Andrew Upton and Andrew MacKenzie. Bobby Murray, Andrew Melville, and Adam De Se Coix are increasingly prominent and always impressive.
  • Adam de Ste Croix is intelligent, responsive, and has a high degree of "legal common sense" in analysing and dealing with professional negligence work.
  • Their approach is very focused and sensible, and always with the client's interests being considered and looked after. Adam de Ste Croix is a good litigator and is very competent and has the experience and knowledge to handle professional negligence work skillfully.
  • This team is very dedicated to their clients and their cases. There is never a sense that you are a burden to them, and they are always well on top of deadlines and strategy.
  • Leading firm acting for pursuers (claimants) with considerable experience in the highest value and most complex cases.
  • David Kerr and E-Ming Fong are very well-known practitioners. Andrew Mackenzie is a tenacious fighter for the interests of his clients and is a solicitor-advocate who regularly appears in the highest courts.

Key clients

  • Robert Kidd
  • Begbies Traynor
  • Interpath Advisory Ltd
  • River Clyde Homes
  • William Gray
  • Kingdom Housing Association
  • Kircudbright Development Trust
  • Fiona and Richard Bergant
  • Pauline McKinlay

Work highlights

Acting for Begbies Traynor Group and Centenary 6 Limited in seeking to replace CH3’s liquidators so the new appointees can investigate their conduct and pursue a potential £70m professional negligence claim.
Acting for Interpath, the liquidator for Simply Construct UK LLP, in pursuing a £14m professional negligence claim against a sub-contractor whose defective design of a care home caused major reconstruction works, substantial liabilities and ultimately, Simply’s insolvency.
Advising Robert Kidd in a $350m action against the purchasers of his shareholding in an oil and gas company and their solicitors based on an unlawful means conspiracy.

Lawyers

Leading partners

The strongest partners in their field, leading on market-leading deals and endorsed by peers and clients alike.

Practice head

Sandy Hastie; David Kerr

Other key lawyers

E-Ming Fong; John McHugh; Andrew MacKenzie; Adam de Ste Croix