
Brodies LLP acts on the full spectrum of commercial disputes, spanning both litigation and ADR forums such as arbitration and mediation. The team is well-versed in both high-stakes corporate litigation in the energy, financial services, and food and drink sectors and class action proceedings. The practice is led by Iain Rutherford, who is a recognised authority on IP, IT, and cross-border disputes. Joining the team from CMS in October 2025, Graeme MacLeod’s portfolio of work covers appearances in both the Court of Session and the UK Supreme Court. Tony Jones KC draws on his extensive advocacy experience to represent clients in professional negligence, construction, and insolvency disputes. Craig Watt leads the Class Actions offering, while Monica Connolly and Fiona Chute focus on the IP and energy sectors, respectively. Joyce Cullen and Kenneth MacDonald retired in 2025.
Legal 500 Editorial commentary
Accolades
Client satisfaction: Sector knowledge
Testimonials
Collated independently by Legal 500 research team.
- Jarred Oyston is our dispute resolution partner. Jarred is very responsive, pragmatic, and understands our business. Jarred provides strategic advice, helping us resolve and settle disputes on satisfactory terms.
- The Brodies commercial litigation practice stands out for its combination of deep sector knowledge and pragmatic, outcome-focused advice, particularly in regulated infrastructure and utilities contexts.
- The individuals I work with stand out for their commercial judgment, accessibility, and ability to operate effectively at the executive level.
- Great breadth of knowledge across the business, with expertise throughout. A very modern firm and great at building relationships with their clients.
- Iain Rutherford is a phenomenal lawyer. He is brilliant at understanding the needs of the client and being able to shape solutions in almost all circumstances. He is very good at commercial disputes, incredibly flexible to fit client needs, and unrelenting in his determination to succeed for his client.
- Commercial, easy to deal with, thorough, and bright.
- Craig Watt is approachable and smart. Andrew Scott is the same; he seems very diligent and thorough.
- Iain Rutherford provides commercial, strategic advice that is practical and easy to implement in the real world.
- Iain Rutherford - Partner is excellent. Ross Campbell, Senior Associate is also highly recommended. He writes an excellent letter, has fantastic attention to detail and generally makes my job much easier.
- Brodies is one of the premier Scottish commercial litigation operations. They bring an international standard to that market and are capable of handling complex matters in London and overseas.
Key clients
- Aggreko Plc
- Whyte and MacKay
- Credit Immobilier de France
- CGI IT UK Limited
- Edgen Murray Europe Limited
- FIM Forest Funds General Partner Ltd
- PRA Group (UK) Limited
- Park's of Hamilton
- The Rangers Football Club
- Network Rail
- James Findlay Limited
Work highlights
Acting for James Finlay and its former subsidiary, Browns Plantations (Kenya) Limited (BPK), in defending a class action in the Court of Session against BPK by almost 5,000 former employees, together with 7 related actions in the Scottish National Personal Injury Court (NPIC) against BPK.
Appeared as senior counsel for the Pursuers at trial establishing that the Defender had breached a warranty in a share sale and purchase agreement.
Lawyers
Hall of Fame
The lawyers at the very top of the profession, widely known and respected by peers and clients for their longstanding involvement in market-leading work.

Leading partners
The strongest partners in their field, leading on market-leading deals and endorsed by peers and clients alike.
Leading associates
Leading associates with regular involvement in their team's key work, and recognition from peers or clients as being ones to watch.
Practice head
Iain Rutherford
Other key lawyers
Graeme Macleod; Tony Jones KC; Craig Watt; Monica Campbell; Fiona Chute




