Shoosmiths pulls together a strong offering acting in litigation related to commercial recovery, insolvency, and contractual disputes. The team is jointly led by Stuart Clubb, whose practice encompasses energy, infrastructure, and corporate disputes, and Andrew Foyle, who is sought out for his specialism in financial services disputes. Ben Zielinski has amassed considerable experience in supply contract matters, product liability mandates, and public procurement disputes.
Legal 500 Editorial commentary

Testimonials

Collated independently by Legal 500 research team.

  • Shoosmiths' Commercial Litigation team in Scotland combines strong technical litigation expertise with a highly commercial and strategic approach to dispute resolution. The team is particularly effective in complex, high-value disputes where clients require clear advice, careful risk assessment, and robust representation. It is willing to take on difficult and hard-fought cases and has the experience and confidence to litigate against much larger opponents where necessary. A key strength is its understanding of the commercial and regulatory environments in which clients operate, particularly in the financial services sector.
  • Andrew Foyle stands out for his extensive experience in financial services disputes and his ability to navigate complex and technically demanding litigation. He combines strong legal analysis with sound strategic judgment and is particularly impressive in challenging cases where careful planning and tactical awareness are essential. He is not afraid to take on difficult matters and pursues his clients' interests with determination and confidence. Stuart Clubb is an outstanding lawyer whose strengths lie in both his technical expertise and his commitment to client service. He has significant experience in corporate and insolvency-related disputes and consistently provides practical, commercially focused advice. He is responsive, approachable, and exceptionally easy to work with, building strong relationships with clients and advisers alike. His judgment is excellent, and he has a real talent for guiding clients through complex disputes in a clear and reassuring manner.
  • The litigation team at Shoosmiths is very well regarded. The team deals with a range of commercial disputes and has a particular specialism in insolvency. Stuart Clubb, one of the partners in the team, is an experienced solicitor advocate. His team focuses on identifying solutions to the problems that arise and making the experience of litigation a less difficult one for clients.
  • Stuart Clubb is an excellent lawyer. He has a very detailed knowledge of insolvency law and knows all of the pitfalls that can befall a party in litigation. He is very good at explaining difficult concepts to clients and helping them to understand the consequences of particular courses of action. He is very commercial and is particularly good at identifying litigation strategies that will help achieve the clients' goals.

Key clients

  • Manolete Partners Plc
  • The Royal Bank of Scotland Plc / Natwest Group
  • Boots UK Limited
  • Poundland Limited
  • Cabot Financial UK Limited
  • SSE / Ovo Energy
  • Middlebrooks Business Recovery and Advice
  • Grahams The Family Dairy
  • Close Brothers Limited
  • Screwfix Direct Ltd

Work highlights

Acting on behalf of the specialist insolvency litigation financing company in the pursuit of unpaid director’s loans in the Court of Session.
Acting on behalf of a minority shareholder in an unfair prejudice petition in the Court of Session.
Acting for the subsidiary of a supermarket in the defence of a supplier’s claim arising from the termination of a supply contract.
Practice head

Stuart Clubb; Andrew Foyle

Other key lawyers

Ben Zielinski