Leveraging its extensive global and national reach, Dentons advises major domestic and international insurance companies on insurance dispute matters. The team combines litigation and regulatory expertise to handle statutory and contract interpretation disputes. Laurie LaPalme and Douglas Stewart jointly lead the practice, with Stewart noted for his experience in coverage disputes, concerning commercial general liability, environmental policies, and professional negligence claims. Deepshikha Dutt concentrates on directors’ and officers’ and errors and omissions liability, while Arthur Hamilton focuses on non-coverage insurance. Laurie Livingstone regularly handles regulatory and commercial disputes in both insurance and reinsurance sectors.
Legal 500 Editorial commentary

Accolades

Client satisfaction: Lawyer & team quality
Client satisfaction: Sector knowledge

Testimonials

Collated independently by Legal 500 research team.

  • Deep comprehensive knowledge of insurance coverage and policy interpretation. Excellent at litigation strategy and settlement strategy. Fair billing rates given the level of expertise. Collaborative and practical.
  • What makes Dentons unique from our experience is that their firm and lawyers genuinely want to know us as a client and our insured base to be of maximum service. Dentons has taken the time over many years to get to know us and our insured market. Their firm has also had great internal stewardship for us as a client. Due to this, their expertise and service on a dispute resolution basis are effective, efficient, and a pleasure to work with for us.
  • We chose the firm because we had a need for a firm that could practice in both the US and Canada. The Dentons firm has a big bench, and the fact that one firm could handle both jurisdictions was ideal.
  • Dentons has consistently provided responsive service, practical advice, and strong strategic guidance. Overall, I have been very satisfied with the quality of service and support provided.
  • Based on our experience working with Dentons on several matters, we've found them to be practical, strategic, and highly responsive. They provide strong legal analysis while keeping a close focus on the client's objectives, litigation risk, and opportunities for early resolution. Their reporting is clear and proactive, and they're particularly effective at balancing legal considerations with commercial realities. Dentons also brings the benefit of a deep bench and broad expertise, which is valuable on complex, high-exposure matters. Overall, they consistently deliver thoughtful advice and a collaborative, client-focused approach.
  • Strong ability to manage disputes between insurers and reinsurers.
  • Deepshikha Dutt: Deepshikha Dutt is the consummate insurance lawyer. She has an innate understanding of insurance coverage and the insurance industry, and her depth of knowledge is impressive. She is also an exceptional strategic thinker, and we rely on her advice for our most complicated disputes.
  • Deepshikha Dutt: Deepshikha Dutt is a 'go-to' legal professional for us. She services complex professional liability litigation defence as well as coverage instances for us knowledgeably, efficiently, and effectively. She has taken the time over her years at Dentons from Associate to Partner to get to know us as a client and the people she works with. She is attentive, caring, and passionate about what she does, and it shows in all our interactions with her, as well as with the other Dentons team members she brings in to be of service for some of our claims.
  • Douglas Stewart: Doug Stewart is someone we trust with complex matters. He is highly responsive, easy to work with, and brings a practical, solutions-oriented approach to every file. He takes the time to understand the client's objectives and provides thoughtful strategic advice without overcomplicating issues. The broader Dentons team share those same qualities. The team is collaborative, proactive in their communications, and consistently delivers high-quality work and practical recommendations.
  • Laurie Livingstone: Laurie Livingstone is one of the best legal communicators I have worked with. Laurie particularly impressed me with her ability to accurately summarize arcane and complex details and language.

Key clients

  • ACE Property and Casualty Insurance Company
  • Chubb Insurance Company of Canada (Chubb)
  • Enbridge Pipelines
  • Carcillo ats. Canadian Hockey League
  • Continental Casualty Company

Work highlights

Representing Enbridge Pipelines in a dispute revolves around the interpretation of crossing agreements entered into prior to construction and how those crossing agreements can be varied in the field.
Representing Virginia Surety, an insurer for US-based teams involved in a landmark class action concerning allegations of abuse in Canadian Minor Junior Hockey leagues from 1977 to 2020.
Representing Continental Casualty Company in proposed class action proceedings before the Superior Court of Quebec on behalf of all individuals who have purchased a protection plan offered or sold by one of the defendants (distributors and insurers) in Quebec.
Practice head

Douglas Stewart; Laurie LaPalme

Other key lawyers

Deepshikha Dutt; Arthur Hamilton; Neil Rabinovitch; Dennis Picco; Laurie Livingstone; Vikki-Ann Flansberry