Many resources are being devoted to preventing data breaches and
protecting privacy. In fact, patents have issued on various
approaches. But are those approaches really patentable? In a recent
challenge to OneTrust's patent, which is related to data
privacy risk, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board ("PTAB")
found the subject matter patent ineligible.
OneTrust's patent, U.S. Patent No. 9,691,090 ("'090
Patent"), relates to privacy management software that
calculates the risk to personal data that has been collected and is
being used, for example, by a business. OneTrust explained its
software platform is used by companies to comply with data privacy
regulations.
AvePoint, a New Jersey company that provides data protection
solutions, challenged the validity of the '090 Patent via a
petition for post-grant review ("PGR"). The PGR procedure
for challenging the validity of a patent offers more options than
the more commonly used inter partes review
("IPR"), but PGR is