On June 6, 2016, Justice Alan D. Scheinkman of the New York
Supreme Court for Westchester County denied J.P. Morgan's
motion for summary judgment on MBIA's fraudulent concealment
claim. The court had
previously granted summary judgment in favor of J.P. Morgan on
MBIA's fraud claim, but permitted MBIA to amend its complaint
to add a fraudulent concealment claim that J.P. Morgan failed to
disclose complete and accurate third-party due diligence results
regarding the collateral underlying the securitization. First,
Scheinkman rejected J.P. Morgan's argument that it did not owe
MBIA an affirmative duty to disclose the results of the due
diligence review. The Court held that the bid letter between J.P.
Morgan and MBIA evinced a contractual relationship between the
parties, and that even in the absence of such a relationship, J.P.
Morgan was acting as an agent for the deal's sponsor, who was
obligated to share the due diligence results with MBIA. Second,
Scheinkman held