A new ruling has been issued in the MD&A case that we
discussed in our February 3
post. In its latest opinion, the U.S. District Court for the
Southern District of Florida denied the defendants' motion to reconsider
the court's granting partial summary judgment to the SEC. The
court reiterated, among other things, that defendant BBX had failed
to disclose its internal concerns about the credit risk of its
entire commercial residential portfolio. Specifically, BBX did not
"disclose the existing trend of crumbling creditworthiness
evident in the entire Commercial Residential Loan Portfolio through
extensions, loan downgrades, and so on."
The court indicated that simply disclosing that the market may
decline in the future—while, at the same time, failing to
disclose to investors current known "problematic
trends"—is not sufficient disclosure to prevent
liability. It found unpersuasive the defendants' arguments that
"they could not have foreseen the sudden crash of the