A recent High Court case has thrown into sharp focus just how much rests on the precise wording of a Will. In Wilkinson v Kirkham, decided in May 2026, a judge was asked to resolve a dispute that had arisen from a single word: “daughter.” The question before the court was whether that word, used in the singular, was intended to refer to one specific person or to two. The answer had significant financial consequences, with an estate worth around £281,000 at stake.
The case is a valuable reminder that a Will is not simply a statement of wishes. It is a legal document, and every word in it carries weight.
What happened in Wilkinson v Kirkham
John Whewell died in December 2020, leaving a Will he had made in 2007. He had no children of his own, and was particularly close to his cousin, Lily Mason. His Will left his residuary estate to Lily absolutely. He then included what lawyers call a substitutionary provision: an instruction about what should happen if Lily died before him. She did,