First published in The Tax Journal, Issue 877, 19 March 2007
It has been some four years since the first article on Missing Trader Intra- Community (MTIC) VAT fraud appeared in The Tax Journal (Issue 690, 28 April 2003). The jurisprudence on the subject has, over the past few years, spawned a growing body of case law, including no fewer than three European Court of Justice (ECJ) judgments. However, the case law still leaves much to be revealed about the applicable principles in this area. That is not surprising, since much judicial effort (in the UK) has related to deciding not to decide MTIC or carousel fraud-related cases on their merits. It would be much better for all concerned if the litigation were permitted to go ahead as rapidly and as thoroughly as possible straight away, rather than prolonging the current period of ‘phoney war’, during which the innocent are damaged by not receiving their EU law rights to immediate input tax refund, while the guilty escape exposure in the