On 11 December 2019, the World Trade Organization's (WTO)
Appellate Body stopped functioning, which makes the filing of new
appeals impossible.
One of the last reports of the Appellate Body was circulated in
the dispute Russia — Railway Equipment, initiated by
Ukraine. In its report, the Appellate Body agreed with Ukraine that
Russia's measures restricting the importation of Ukrainian
railway equipment into its market were inconsistent with
international trade rules.
The reason for this Appellate Body paralysis is well known.
Since July 2017, the US has been blocking new appointments due to
"a number of long-standing concerns".
In fact, the US has two systemic concerns:
- judicial activism: the US accuses the Appellate Body of
creating law through legal rulings and imposing new obligations on
WTO Members; in particular, the US is concerned about the
prohibition of "zeroing" in anti-dumping calculations,
the definition of "public body", and China's