The definitive annulment of the LEZ opens the door for affected citizens and businesses to claim damages arising from the application of a bylaw declared contrary to the principle of proportionality
The Supreme Court has refused to admit the cassation appeal lodged by Madrid City Council against the judgment of the Madrid High Court of Justice annulling the provisions governing the Low Emissions Zone (LEZ) across the municipality. As a result, the annulment of the bylaw has become final, opening a scenario with highly significant practical consequences for a large number of citizens and businesses.
The High Court of Justice found at the time that the economic impact assessment carried out prior to the bylaw’s approval was manifestly insufficient: the City Council failed to weigh adequately the balance of benefits and costs, nor did it consider less restrictive alternatives of equivalent effect. The court further underlined that the bylaw disproportionately affected citizens with
