A recent decision involving registered designs is a reminder of
how useful design law can be, in the sense that it can be used to
protect an almost limitless range of products.
The decision in the UK case of Ahmet Erol v Sumaira Javaid
(Design) (a decision of the Appointed Person, 18 May 2017)
does not create any law, but it does illustrate two things. The
first is how registered designs can often be very low-tech. The
second is how novelty is the big issue in design law, in the sense
that it's only possible to validly register a design that is,
in fact, new. Although a UK case, it is relevant in South Africa
too.
In this case, the two registered designs in issue were for
nothing more than garments bearing a modified Union Jack on the
chest (one of them also had a tick or swoosh). The registrations
were attacked on the basis that they lacked novelty or individual
character. It is important to note here that, although South
African design law is derived from and is