It seems absurd that South Africa's Supreme Court of Appeal
("SCA") should be called on to decide
what the word "between" means. But that's exactly
what happened in the recent patent case of Orica Mining
Services v Elbroc Mining Products. In the process, the SCA
very clearly opted for a purposive interpretation of patent
claims.
The two parties involved, Orica and Elbroc, supply goods to the
mining industry. Orica has a patent for a "roof bolter
rig", a drill rig that's used to drill holes on the
hanging roof or wall of a mine for the purpose of placing roof
bolts or other stabilising apparatus into the roof or wall. A roof
bolter rig has two extendable telescopic rigs on which the drill
carriage is mounted. This makes the device self-supporting; in
other words, one that does not need to be held by a person. Ideal
when you need to drill holes in confined spaces!