The ugly face of IP shows itself from time to time. It did when
SAB Miller tried (unsuccessfully) to stop a young man from
producing a t-shirt that parodied/commented on its Black Label
brand – despite the Constitutional Court's judgment,
there are people in IP who still cannot accept that something as
touchy feely as the right of free expression can ever override
something as solid as a trade mark right. Who still believe that
spoof t-shirts actually harm corporate reputations. Who really
believe that people seeing a Walocaust t-shirt suppose that Walmart
supported the Nazis, rather than seeing it as a bit of culture
jamming, a playful allusion to the fact that shopping sucks.
This ugly face has shown itself again, this time in a posting on
Stellenbosch University's IP law blog,
www.blogs.sun.ac.za/iplaw. The piece, entitled Trade Marks Going Up
In Smoke, suggests that if the SA government invokes
Australian-style legislation that bans the use of any name or logo
on