In a court case, one might think that it will be helpful for an
expert witness to give evidence where he or she believes that an
invention is inventive (and hence patentable). In fact, our courts
disregard such evidence. Why?
Our courts' view on the role of an expert witness has now
been firmly established and was recently reiterated by our Supreme
Court of Appeal in Sandvik Intellectual Property AB vs. Outokumpu
OYJ and another (Case No. 879/2018).
The reason why our courts disregard conclusions by expert
witnesses that an invention is inventive or unobvious is that a
court must come to its own conclusion on the issue. However, this
does not mean that the evidence of an expert witness cannot be
useful to a court.