New Balance Athletic Shoe Inc v Dajee NO (251/11) [2012] ZASCA
3
This matter relates to an appeal, by New Balance Athletic Shoe,
Inc ("New Balance"), against a decision by the Registrar
of Trade Marks (upheld in first appeal to North Gauteng High Court)
to expunge trade mark nos. 1972/1361 P-F FLYERS and B1965/02999 P-F
("New Balance trade marks" or "the trade
marks") on the grounds of non-use in terms of section 27(1)(b)
of the Trade Marks Act 194 of 1993.
In expungement proceedings, in terms of section 27(1)(b), the
onus of proving relevant use of the trade marks under attack falls
on the trade mark proprietor. The relevant period is defined as a 5
year period ending 3 months before the expungement application is
launched. The Supreme Court of Appeal was given an opportunity to
examine the evidence provided in defending the expungement
application, and made various findings relating to the level of
evidence that is required of a trade mark holder in order to