South Africa's Competition Tribunal has dismissed a
complaint referred by the Competition Commission against Totalgaz
Southern Africa (Pty) Ltd, Oryx Oil South Africa (Pty) Ltd, KayaGas
(Pty) Ltd, Easigas (Pty) Ltd and African Oxygen Ltd (collectively
referred to as the "Respondents").
Following a dawn raid and an application by African Oxygen Ltd
for corporate leniency, the Commission alleged that the Respondents
had entered into an agreement and/or engaged in a concerted
practice to fix deposit fees for liquified petroleum gas
("LPG") cylinders to first-time buyers,
which would be in contravention of section 4(1)(b)(i) of
the Competition Act, 1998.
However, the Tribunal dismissed the case, finding that the
conduct of the Respondents could not be characterised as a
"hardcore cartel". The decision is significant, in that
it develops the case law on "characterisation". According
to the Supreme Court of Appeal ("SCA")
in American Natural Soda Ash Corporation v