The House of Lords handed down judgment on 2 July 2008 in the Scottish case of “Spencer- Franks –v- Kellogg Brown and Root Limited and Others (2008) UKHL 46”, which heralds a change of interpretation in how the Courts should look at whether an employer has breached the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations [“PUWER”] 1998, which replaced the previous PUWER 1992 regulations.