ArticleBreach Of Interdict – A Cautionary TaleYesterday saw businessman Paul MacKenzie sentenced to 10 months imprisonment after he repeatedly breached an interdict against him.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationMacRoberts
ArticleBrussels Regulation (Recast) Does Not Apply Where Competing Courts Are Within Same Member StateForum non conveniens provides the court with a discretion to dismiss a case where another court is better suited to hear it.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationClyde & Co
ArticleContractual Conundrum: Variation Or Replacement?The UK Supreme Court in *Cobalt v HMRC* emphasized that whether a contract is varied or replaced depends on the parties' objectively ascertained common intention, with legal limits to autonomy.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationA&O Shearman
ArticleCourt Of Appeal Considers How Standard Ts And Cs Can Be Incorporated Into A Contract For Goods Or Services Made OnlineThe rules for incorporating terms and conditions into a contract pre-date the digital area. Broadly, Ts and Cs do not have to be read by the other side: they just need to be aware...United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationOsborne Clarke LLP
ArticleCourt Of Appeal Rules That A Claimant Cannot Accept A FOS Award And Pursue Further Losses From The Courts For The Same Cause Of ActionThis case has brought some welcome clarity to the issue of whether a complainant's acceptance of an Ombudsman's award is truly binding in relation to that complaint.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationClyde & Co
ArticleCourt Of Appeal To Consider Legal And Procedural Requirements For Claims Regarding Secret CommissionsThe Court of Appeal has agreed to hear an appeal that is expected to involve it addressing the legal foundations of civil claims in respect of undisclosed or "secret" commissions...United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationHerbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP
ArticleCPS Offers No Evidence Following Abuse Of Process ApplicationPeters & Peters successfully secured the acquittal of a high-net-worth businessman accused of robbery after the CPS offered no evidence, following the firm's abuse of process application due to prosecutorial non-compliance and procedural failures.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationPeters & Peters Solicitors LLP
ArticleDeparting From Fixed Recoverable Costs – When Will The Court Disapply The Regime?When third party debt order applications become heavily contested and substantially more complex than anticipated, courts may exercise discretion to disapply fixed costs regimes in favour of assessed costs. A recent High Court decision demonstrates how routine enforcement proceedings can justify significantly higher cost awards when the level of contest and preparation exceeds what the fixed costs regime was designed to cover.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationBond Turner
ArticleDip In Scottish Debt Judgments RevealedThe Registry Trust, a not-for-profit company which operates the Register of Judgments and collates information on a range of court procedure, recently published figures indicating that around 1,000 less judgments were issued in respect of Scottish businesses in 2012.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationMacRoberts
Article"Golden Endurance" – English Court Considers Party's Challenge To Foreign JudgmentThe Court considered whether a foreign judgment should be recognised in England, and whether the claimant had submitted to the jurisdiction of the foreign court. United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationClyde & Co
ArticleLocal Authorities And Legal AidThose who were at Brodies' Local Government conference last month might remember that one of the cases covered in our case round-up was Glasgow City Council v Scottish Legal Aid Board and PQ [2017] CSOH 155. United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationBrodies LLP
ArticleNo Substitutions Allowed: Courts Restrict Assignment Of ICSID And ECT Arbitral AwardsThe English Commercial Court has ruled that ICSID arbitral awards and Energy Charter Treaty claims cannot be assigned to third parties for enforcement purposes, creating uncertainty for investors and litigation funders. With permission to appeal granted and conflicting approaches in other jurisdictions, the decision raises important questions about the future of award enforcement and the secondary market for arbitral claims. United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationPenningtons Manches Cooper LLP
ArticlePlea Bargaining: Coming To Japan June 2018A new regime of plea bargain style cooperation agreements will come into force in Japan this June, in a further instalment to reforms of the Japanese Criminal Procedure Code.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationMishcon de Reya LLP
Article(Re)insurance Weekly Update 2 - 2016The claimants wished to issue proceedings in order to avoid a time bar defence. However, they were not yet sure whether the claims would be pursued.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationClyde & Co
Article"Saving" Money By Representing Yourself In Court Without Legal Advice Can Prove Very CostlyThe importance of obtaining legal advice when you are involved in any kind of legal matter cannot be overstated; even if you think you have such a sound case you cannot lose; as no doubt Robert Hazeldean thought.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationGiambrone
ArticleScottish Government Decides That Civil Court Fees Do Not Impede Access To Justice; No Substantive Change To Court Fee StructureOn 26 February, the Scottish Government published the outcome of its consultation on Scottish Court Fees – that is, the fees which parties must pay to the courts to bring ...United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationBrodies LLP
ArticleSide Letter Held UnenforceableThe Court of Appeal recently had to consider whether a side letter, drafted in parallel to a binding contract, and whose purpose was to confirm the parties’ agreement to enter, at a later date, into a separate secondary agreement, was itself legally binding. United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationClyde & Co
ArticleSimple Procedure. Out With The Old, In With The New.The new Simple Procedure Rules in the Sheriff Courts came into force today, which replace Small Claims and Summary Cause procedures for low value claims of up to £5,000.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationMacRoberts
ArticleThe Home Office Counting Rules Don’t Count, Says The Administrative CourtThe Administrative Court has delivered a significant judgment clarifying that the Home Office Crime Recording Rules (HOCA) do not govern police retention of information on local databases. In a case involving an autistic eight-year-old child, the court emphasized that retention decisions must be made under the College of Policing's guidance, requiring individualized assessments of necessity and proportionality rather than relying on crime recording statistics frameworks.United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & ArbitrationKingsley Napley LLP