Goltsblat BLP advises of a tax dispute judgement passed by a
court of appeal that is of importance to the business
community.
The first appeal court in the Bridgetown Foods case
stated1 that a foreign owner's revenues from
assigning exclusive intellectual property rights to a Russian
entity were to be taxed at source.
The case dealt with assignment of rights to a trade mark but
this position might subsequently be extended to other IP
assets.
In the given case, the courts supported the tax office in
relying on a 2008 Russian Ministry of Finance position2,
even though the Ministry itself subsequently refuted it on several
occasions.
The Ministry of Finance, the tax office and the courts
effectively overlooked the direct legal rule3 cited by
the taxpayer determining tax treatment of assignment of exclusive
rights to IP assets: