In a recent High Court decision Auckland Council v Cabra
Rural Developments Ltd [2019] NZHC 1892, the Court provided
guidance on a range of fundamental issues in plan making. This note
outlines the Environment Court and High Court decisions and sets
out three key takeaways that anyone involved in plan-making
processes should bear in mind.
The Environment Court decision
In Cabra Rural Developments Ltd v Auckland Council
[2018] NZEnvC 90, the Environment Court was tasked with deciding
between two approaches to subdivision in rural Auckland: the
"relatively conservative" approach from the Auckland
Council's (Council) decision on the Auckland
Unitary Plan (AUP); or a more enabling approach,
as recommended by the Independent Hearings Panel
(IHP) constituted under the Local Government
(Auckland Transitional Provisions) Act 2010
(LGATPA).