[2013] NZHC 3120
The plaintiffs, the Marriotts, are the owners of two small
commercial buildings in Christchurch. These properties were insured
by the defendants. The properties suffered damage in both the
September earthquake and the February earthquake. The Marriotts
take the view that the buildings suffered further damage in a third
earthquake in June 2011, but Vero considered that the building had
already been destroyed.
The parties agreed that certain questions of law should be
answered as a preliminary matter. These questions were:
- "When is the building destroyed under the policy?
- Does the sum insured reinstate after each earthquake
event?
- Are the Marriotts entitled to repair costs up to the sum
insured for the damage caused by each earthquake event?