In this update, we summarise insurance decisions issued at the
close of 2013 and in first quarter of 2014. Litigation arising from
the Canterbury earthquakes continues to dominate the insurance
landscape, with the Supreme Court granting leave for the appeal of
many of the judgments discussed in our
December report.
There have now been several decisions dealing with question of
whether an insured can claim for damage sustained in successive
earthquakes. This is a vexed issue in claims where the building is
underinsured or has ultimately been destroyed. There are
conflicting High Court decisions on whether damage suffered in an
earlier event merges in the final destruction of the building. The
scope of the doctrine of merger was debated before the Supreme
Court on 10 March 2014 at the hearing of Ridgecrest New Zealand Ltd
v IAG New Zealand Ltd. The Court's judgment on the issue is
awaited.