The Western Australian Supreme Court decision last year
which overturned the previously accepted view that set-off remains
effective against a receiver has now been successfully
appealed.
We welcome the return of the status quo.
The original Hamersley decision
The Court in Hamersley v Forge [2017] WASC 152 ruled
that:
- because the company was in liquidation, the only permissible
form of set-off was the one allowed under the statutory liquidation
set-off rules
- granting security under the Australian version of our Personal
Property Securities Act 1999 (PPSA) confers a proprietary interest
on the secured party, which destroys the mutuality required for
insolvency set-off, and