Guarantees are intended to provide surety in respect of lending
agreements, but what happens when they are not documented
correctly?
A recent decision of the Supreme Court, Brougham v Regan
& Jefferey as trustees of Winchester Trust [2020] NZSC
118, demonstrates the importance of guarantees being recorded and
executed correctly.
The background
The trustees of the Winchester Trust agreed to lend money to a
company set up by Mr Brougham and Ms Dey.
The loan to the company was recorded in a term loan agreement
which contained a condition precedent that any persons named as
guarantor must have signed a separate deed of guarantee and
indemnity in an approved form.
In contrast, the terms of the loan provided that a person
signing the agreement as covenantor agreed to comply with the
obligations in the loan agreement, in other words no separate
document recording the obligations of the covenantor was
required.