Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 14 JULY 2012

Two Similar Cases - Two Different Outcomes - constructive dismissal before the Employee Relations Authority

A discussion of some recent decisions by the Employee Relations Authority.

New ZealandEmployment and HR
Mary-Jane Thomas
Mary-Jane Thomas

A few weeks ago the Southland Times ran an article about a decision of the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) (that was actually a case run by my office). The case involved Ms K. who claimed that she had been constructively dismissed due to a number of actions of her former employer.

The ERA member determined that Ms K. had not been constructively dismissed. She did find that the employer had unjustifiably disadvantaged Ms K. when Ms K. was instructed to move her desk in with her superior. The ERA decided that this was the only unjustified action of the employer and awarded Ms K. $500.00 compensation.

One of the grounds that Ms K. relied on to support her claim of constructive dismissal was that she had been sworn at by her superior. Her evidence was that her female manager told her she was "f%$king useless", that her work effort was "s!@t", and that all she did was "f%$k" around and distract the store men .She was told that when she came into work she looked

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from