Agile Holdings
Corporation v. Essar Shipping Ltd (M/V Maria) [2018] EWHC 1055
(Comm)
On appeal from an arbitration award, the Court has construed the
scope of the words "similar amendment" in the
Interclub Agreement ("the ICA") and found that, in this
case, there was no such amendment making the Master responsible for
cargo handling and restricting the Charterers' liability to a
50% indemnity for a cargo claim.
The background facts
The Owners of the vessel "Maria"
time-chartered her to the Charterers under a modified NYPE 1946
form. During loading operations in Trinidad, the cargo of direct
reduced iron was observed to be on fire. Loading was paused and the
appointed supercargo inspected the holds. Concluding that the fire
was extinguished, he ordered that loading recommence. In fact, the
cargo remained on fire throughout the voyage and, upon discharge,
the Cargo Interests brought a claim against the Owners.