On 14th October 2025, the Maltese Court of Appeal delivered a
judgement in Mehmet Tatlici (the
"Plaintiff") v Ugur Tatlici
(the "Defendant"), rejecting the
Plaintiff's appeal and confirming the first instance decision.
The Court held that a Florida judgement ordering the Defendant to
pay US$740 million in damages for defamation (the "US
Judgement"), could not be recognised and enforced in
Malta due to a lack of jurisdiction, as well as a violation of
Maltese public policy.
Background
The US Judgement arose from allegations that certain online
publications on social media harmed the Plaintiff's reputation.
The Florida court ordered the Defendant to pay the Plaintiff US$740
million for damages. The Plaintiff sought to recognise and enforce
the US Judgement in Malta due to the presence of local assets
belonging to the Defendant.