In the recent case Malcolm Vassallo (the
“Plaintiff”) vs. Citadel Insurance
p.l.c (the “Defendant”) decided on the
1 March 2023, the Honourable Judge Lawrence Mintoff was requested
to determine and examine what constitutes a “material
fact” and the “non-disclosure of a material fact”
when purchasing an insurance policy. The case was decided before
the Court of Appeal (sitting in its inferior jurisdiction) (the
“Court”).
Background
By way of background, back in 2015 the Plaintiff suffered major
damages to his car due to a fire which broke out in a complex of
garages in which the Plaintiff used to keep his car. The Plaintiff,
a customer of the Defendant, requested that he be paid the amount
of €35,000 (being the value of the car, prior to the fire),
from the Defendant. This request was made based on the fully
comprehensive insurance policy which the Plaintiff had with the
Defendant.