In a request for a preliminary ruling by Randstad Italia SpA to
the European Court of Justice, Grand Chamber, the interpretation of
Article 19(1) TEU1 relating to the obligations of Member
States to provide remedies sufficient to ensure effective legal
protection was considered, specifically relating to the application
of review procedures to the award of public supply and public works
contracts.
The request was made in proceedings between Randstad Italia SpA
and Umana SpA, Azienda USL Valle d'Aosta concerning the
exclusion of Randstad from a procedure for the award of a public
contract and the regularity of that procedures.
The application of the right to an effective remedy was
requested by Randstad in the context of concession contracts2 awarded by
contracting authorities, with concession contracts including public
contracts, framework agreements, work and services concessions and
dynamic purchasing systems. Member States have an obligation to
take the necessary